Are Closed Toe Mules Still In Style Or Are Open Toe Sandals Comfier Real People Weigh In

The debate between closed toe mules and open toe sandals isn’t just about fashion—it’s a clash of comfort, climate, and personal preference. As seasonal wardrobes shift and workplace dress codes evolve, many are reconsidering their footwear choices. Are closed toe mules still relevant in the age of breathable fabrics and minimalist design? Or do open toe sandals offer superior comfort no matter the occasion? To answer this, we’ve gathered insights from real wearers, podiatrists, and style experts to help you decide what works best—both aesthetically and functionally.

Fashion Trends: Where Closed Toe Mules Stand Today

Closed toe mules enjoyed a major resurgence in the early 2020s, thanks to minimalist fashion movements and elevated workwear trends. Their sleek silhouette pairs well with wide-leg trousers, midi skirts, and tailored dresses, making them a favorite among urban professionals and fashion editors alike. Designers like The Row, Prada, and By Far continued to feature structured leather mules in runway collections through 2023, signaling staying power beyond a fleeting trend.

However, as summers grow hotter and casual dressing becomes more normalized—even in offices—the demand for breathability has increased. While closed toe mules remain stylish, especially in cooler months or air-conditioned environments, they’re increasingly seen as transitional pieces rather than year-round staples.

Tip: Pair closed toe mules with cropped pants or socks for a modern look that balances coverage and ventilation.

Comfort Showdown: Open Toe vs. Closed Toe

When it comes to comfort, open toe sandals generally win in warm weather due to better airflow and reduced foot swelling. A 2023 survey conducted by Footwear Insight Group found that 78% of respondents preferred open toe styles during summer months, citing less sweating and greater freedom of movement.

Yet comfort isn't only about temperature. Closed toe mules often provide more arch support and heel stability, particularly those with cushioned insoles or block heels. For individuals who stand for long periods or walk frequently, this structural advantage can make a noticeable difference over time.

“Foot health isn’t just about support—it’s also about allowing your toes to move naturally. Open toe designs reduce constriction and may lower the risk of corns or calluses.” — Dr. Lena Torres, Podiatrist & Gait Specialist

Real People, Real Experiences: What Wearers Say

To understand everyday preferences, we interviewed five individuals across different lifestyles and climates:

• Maria, 34, Teacher (Miami): “I tried wearing closed toe mules last summer, but my feet felt suffocated by noon. Now I stick with sporty open toe sandals—they’re easier to clean too.”
• Derek, 29, Office Manager (Chicago): “I keep a pair of black leather mules at work. They look sharp with suits and don’t require laces. In winter, they’re perfect. Summer? Not so much.”
• Sophie, 41, Freelance Designer (Portland): “I love the aesthetic of mules, but I’ve switched to open back, open toe slides. They give me the ease of a mule without trapping heat.”
• Raj, 50, Retail Supervisor (Phoenix): “We’re on our feet eight hours a day. Breathable sandals are mandatory here. Closed shoes, even mules, cause blisters in this heat.”
• Chloe, 26, Marketing Associate (Seattle): “I own both. Closed mules for meetings, open toe Birkenstocks when I’m running errands. It depends on the agenda.”

This variety reflects a broader pattern: context matters. Climate, job demands, and personal sensitivity to heat all influence which shoe feels “comfier” on any given day.

Style vs. Practicality: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Closed Toe Mules	Open Toe Sandals
Fashion Appeal	High—sleek, polished, office-appropriate	Moderate to high—depends on design; some look casual
Ventilation	Low—can trap heat and moisture	High—allows airflow, reduces sweat
Support & Stability	Generally better heel and arch structure	Varies widely; many lack full arch support
Seasonal Use	Better for spring/fall/winter	Ideal for summer and humid climates
Durability	Often made with sturdier materials	Straps may wear faster; exposed footbeds stain easily
Easy On/Off	Yes—slip-on design	Mostly yes, though straps may need adjustment

How to Choose Based on Your Lifestyle

Instead of asking whether one style is universally better, consider your daily routine. The following checklist can help guide your decision:

Checklist: Which Shoe Fits Your Life?

• Do you spend most of the day indoors with climate control? → Closed toe mules may work well.
• Do you walk more than 5,000 steps daily? → Prioritize cushioning and breathability—consider open toe with support.
• Is your job client-facing or formal? → Closed toe mules offer a more professional appearance.
• Do you live in a hot or humid region? → Open toe sandals are likely more comfortable.
• Do you experience foot swelling or sensitivity? → Open designs reduce pressure and friction.

Expert Tips for Wearing Either Style Comfortably

No shoe is inherently uncomfortable if worn correctly. Here are science-backed tips to enhance comfort regardless of style:

1. Break them in gradually: Wear new shoes for short durations first to prevent blisters.
2. Use moisture-wicking insoles: Especially helpful in closed toe mules to reduce sweat buildup.
3. Choose the right heel height: Heels above 2 inches increase forefoot pressure. Opt for block or wedge styles under 1.5 inches for all-day wear.
4. Rotate your footwear: Avoid wearing the same pair two days in a row to allow materials to breathe and reduce odor.
5. Keep feet dry: Apply antiperspirant to feet before wearing closed mules to minimize sweating.

“In footwear, the ‘perfect’ shoe doesn’t exist. The best choice aligns with your biomechanics, environment, and aesthetic needs.” — Naomi Pierce, Footwear Ergonomics Consultant

FAQ

Can I wear closed toe mules in summer?

Yes, but choose lightweight materials like perforated leather or linen-upholstered mules. Pair them with breathable clothing and avoid prolonged sun exposure to prevent overheating.

Are open toe sandals unprofessional?

It depends on the workplace. In creative or casual offices, polished open toe sandals (e.g., leather Birkenstocks or strappy Céline-style designs) are acceptable. Traditional corporate settings may still favor closed toe options.

Do closed toe mules cause more foot odor?

Potentially. Without airflow, moisture accumulates, creating a breeding ground for bacteria. Combat this with cedar insoles, regular cleaning, and rotating shoes every 2–3 days.

Conclusion: Balance Style and Comfort Wisely

Closed toe mules aren’t out of style—but their relevance depends heavily on context. They remain a strong choice for polished, cool-weather looks and formal settings. Open toe sandals, meanwhile, dominate in comfort, especially in warmer climates or active lifestyles. The smartest approach isn’t choosing one over the other, but curating a rotation that serves different needs throughout the year.

Ultimately, real people prioritize how shoes feel after six hours of wear—not just how they look in an Instagram post. By listening to both fashion cues and bodily feedback, you can build a footwear collection that’s both stylish and sustainable for your daily life.

💬 What’s your go-to summer shoe? Have you switched from mules to sandals—or vice versa? Share your experience and help others find their perfect fit!