When Bose introduced the QuietComfort Ultra in late 2023 as the successor to the widely praised QuietComfort 45, expectations were high. The headline feature? Immersive Audio — Bose’s proprietary take on spatial audio. But for consumers already satisfied with the QC45’s balanced performance, the question remains: is this new spatial audio just marketing fluff, or does it genuinely elevate the listening experience?
This comparison dives deep into both models—not just on paper, but in real-world use—to determine whether the Ultra’s advancements justify its premium price, especially when it comes to spatial audio.
Silent Champions: Noise Cancellation & Comfort
The foundation of any premium headphone is comfort and noise cancellation. Both the QuietComfort 45 and Ultra sit firmly in Bose’s legacy of class-leading active noise cancellation (ANC), but subtle refinements set them apart.
The QC45 delivers excellent passive isolation thanks to its plush ear cushions and secure fit. Its ANC effectively drowns out low-frequency rumbles—airplane engines, HVAC systems, subway noise—with minimal hiss. It's reliable, predictable, and trusted by frequent travelers.
The Ultra improves upon this with an upgraded ANC system powered by new custom-designed tri-port acoustic architecture and enhanced processing. In side-by-side testing, the Ultra reduces mid-range frequencies—like human voices in a café—more effectively than the QC45. This makes a tangible difference in open offices or crowded public spaces where constant chatter can break concentration.
Comfort-wise, both models are nearly identical in weight (253g) and clamping force. However, the Ultra uses slightly softer memory foam and revised headband padding, making it marginally more comfortable during extended wear. Users who wear glasses report less pressure behind the ears—a small but meaningful improvement.
Spatial Audio: Beyond the Hype
Bose markets Immersive Audio as a “3D-like” listening experience that expands the soundstage beyond the confines of your head. Unlike traditional stereo headphones, where sound feels like it’s playing inside your skull, spatial audio aims to replicate how we hear in real life—directional, layered, and dynamic.
The technology relies on head-tracking via built-in sensors and psychoacoustic processing to anchor sound sources in space. When you turn your head, the audio field stays fixed relative to your environment—just like real-world sounds don’t move when you do.
In practice, the effect is most noticeable with compatible content. Apple Music’s spatial audio tracks, select Netflix shows, and Dolby Atmos-enabled music reveal the Ultra’s potential. Listening to Billie Eilish’s “Happier Than Ever” in Atmos mode, the cymbals float above and behind, vocals occupy center stage, and reverb trails extend outward—creating a concert-hall-like sensation.
But here’s the catch: for standard stereo content (which still makes up 90% of most libraries), the spatial effect is simulated through upmixing. While Bose’s algorithm is among the best, it can’t create depth from flat recordings. Some listeners report a slight “hollow” or “distant” quality when Immersive Audio is enabled on non-optimized tracks.
“Spatial audio isn’t about louder sound—it’s about recreating auditory space. Done right, it reduces listener fatigue and increases emotional engagement.” — Dr. Lena Park, Audio Perception Researcher, MIT Media Lab
Sound Quality Comparison
Under the hood, both models use similar driver designs, but tuning philosophies differ. The QC45 follows Bose’s classic neutral-warm profile: smooth mids, restrained highs, and bass that’s present but not overwhelming. It’s ideal for long listening sessions without ear fatigue.
The Ultra shifts toward a more dynamic signature. Bass hits harder, treble is crisper, and there’s greater separation between instruments. With Immersive Audio off, the Ultra still sounds more energetic and detailed—closer to audiophile-grade than consumer-focused.
However, this shift may not suit all tastes. Classical and jazz listeners often prefer the QC45’s natural tonality. Rock and electronic music fans tend to favor the Ultra’s punch and clarity, especially when spatial rendering adds dimensionality.
Key Audio Differences at a Glance
| Feature | QuietComfort 45 | QuietComfort Ultra |
|---|---|---|
| Driver Size | 40mm | 40mm (redesigned) |
| Frequency Response | 20Hz – 20kHz | 20Hz – 20kHz (wider dispersion) |
| Immersive Audio | Not available | Yes, with head tracking |
| Stereo Sound Profile | Warm, balanced | Brighter, more detailed |
| Best For | Vocals, podcasts, travel | Atmos music, movies, immersive media |
Real-World Use: A Commuter’s Experience
Consider Sarah, a UX designer who commutes 90 minutes daily via train and bus. She owned the QC45 for two years and recently upgraded to the Ultra. Her primary use cases: podcasting in the morning, music during creative work, and occasional video calls.
On her first week with the Ultra, she noticed the stronger ANC made a difference on noisy city buses. But what surprised her was watching a spatial audio-enabled documentary on her phone. “It felt like the narrator was standing in front of me, and ambient forest sounds surrounded me. I forgot I was on public transit.”
However, she quickly learned that Immersive Audio drains battery faster—about 18 hours with it on versus 24 on the QC45. She now toggles it only for movies and Atmos tracks. For podcasts and calls, she disables it, finding no benefit and slightly reduced voice clarity.
She also discovered that head-tracking only works reliably with iOS devices. On her Android tablet, the feature is disabled entirely. This limitation isn’t clearly advertised and caused initial frustration.
Features & Connectivity: Evolution, Not Revolution
Both models support Bluetooth 5.0, multipoint pairing, and have USB-C charging. The Ultra adds support for the Bose Music app’s updated interface, firmware-driven EQ customization, and a new “Aware Mode” that blends ambient sound more naturally than the QC45’s “Action Mode.”
The microphone system is significantly improved on the Ultra. In tests, voice calls were clearer even in windy conditions, thanks to better beamforming and noise rejection. Remote workers will appreciate this upgrade.
One notable omission: neither model supports LDAC or aptX HD, limiting high-resolution streaming on Android. Audiophiles relying on hi-res files must look elsewhere, like Sony’s WH-1000XM5 or Sennheiser Momentum 4.
Checklist: Choosing Between QC45 and Ultra
- ✅ Prioritize ANC and comfort? Either model works—but Ultra edges ahead.
- ✅ Listen mostly to stereo music or podcasts? QC45 offers better value.
- ✅ Watch spatial audio content (Apple Music, Netflix)? Ultra unlocks real benefits.
- ✅ Use Android primarily? You’ll miss head-tracking features.
- ✅ Want future-proof tech? Ultra has newer hardware and longer software support.
- ✅ On a budget? QC45 often retails $100–150 less.
Is Spatial Audio a Gimmick?
The answer depends on your usage. For the average listener consuming standard stereo content, spatial audio on the Ultra won’t transform the experience. It’s not a magic upgrade for all music.
But for those engaging with modern spatial formats—Dolby Atmos music, 360 Reality Audio, or immersive films—the Ultra delivers a perceptible leap. It’s not full holographic sound, but it convincingly widens the stage and adds realism.
The key is intentionality. Treating Immersive Audio as a default setting leads to disappointment. Using it as a tool—activated when appropriate—reveals its strengths. Think of it like HDR on a TV: not always visible, but transformative when the content supports it.
Moreover, Bose’s implementation avoids some common pitfalls. Unlike early spatial attempts that created disorienting echoes or exaggerated panning, the Ultra maintains vocal clarity and avoids artificial reverb. The head-tracking is subtle, not jarring—a design choice that prioritizes immersion over spectacle.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I disable spatial audio on the QuietComfort Ultra?
Yes. Immersive Audio can be toggled on or off via the Bose Music app or using a dedicated button on the left ear cup. When disabled, the Ultra functions like a high-end stereo headphone.
Do I need special content for spatial audio to work?
Ideally, yes. Native spatial formats like Apple’s Dolby Atmos tracks or binaural recordings deliver the best results. Stereo-to-spatial upmixing is available but less convincing.
Is the battery life worse with spatial audio enabled?
Yes. With ANC and Immersive Audio on, battery life drops to around 18 hours. Without spatial audio, it extends to 24 hours—matching the QC45. Charging is quick: 3 hours for full charge, or 30 minutes for 3 hours of playback.
Final Verdict: Who Should Upgrade?
The QuietComfort 45 remains one of the best values in premium wireless headphones. It excels at core tasks: noise cancellation, comfort, and balanced sound. If you’re happy with yours, there’s no urgent reason to switch.
The QuietComfort Ultra is not a radical reinvention, but a thoughtful evolution. Its improvements in ANC, call quality, and spatial audio make it the better choice for tech-savvy users invested in immersive media—especially within the Apple ecosystem.
Ultimately, spatial audio on the Ultra is not a gimmick. It’s a niche feature with broadening relevance. As more platforms adopt spatial formats and creators embrace 3D sound design, the Ultra positions itself for the next decade of audio consumption. For early adopters and experiential listeners, it’s a worthwhile investment. For others, the QC45 still delivers excellence—without the extras.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?