Types of Cantilever Frame Structures
A cantilever frame is an architectural and engineering marvel that supports horizontal structures extending outward from a vertical support, with no additional bracing at the free end. This design enables open, unobstructed spaces beneath and allows for bold, innovative architectural expressions. Cantilever frames are widely used in buildings, bridges, balconies, and modern installations where aesthetics and structural efficiency are equally important.
Each type of cantilever frame utilizes different materials and construction techniques to balance strength, weight, durability, and visual appeal. Below is a detailed breakdown of the most common types of cantilever frame structures used in modern construction.
Steel Cantilever Frame
Renowned for its high strength-to-weight ratio and structural rigidity, steel is a top choice for large-scale cantilever applications.
Advantages
- Exceptional tensile and compressive strength
- High durability and load-bearing capacity
- Quick assembly via bolting or welding
- Ideal for high-rise buildings and long-span bridges
Limitations
- Prone to corrosion without protective coatings
- Higher cost compared to some materials
- Requires skilled labor for fabrication
Best for: Skyscrapers, industrial structures, long-span bridges, and commercial overhangs
Concrete Cantilever Frame
Constructed using reinforced concrete, this type leverages mass and reinforcement to resist bending and support heavy loads.
Advantages
- High compressive strength and rigidity
- Excellent fire resistance
- Long service life with minimal maintenance
- Ideal for permanent, heavy-duty installations
Limitations
- Heavy weight increases foundation demands
- Long curing time delays construction
- Less flexibility in design modifications
Best for: Balconies, stadium overhangs, swimming pool decks, and retaining structures
Timber Cantilever Frame
Timber offers a natural aesthetic and sustainable alternative, making it popular in eco-conscious and residential architecture.
Advantages
- Lightweight and easy to transport
- Renewable and environmentally friendly
- Warm, natural appearance enhances design
- Simple connections using bolts or dowels
Limitations
- Lower strength compared to steel or concrete
- Vulnerable to moisture, rot, and insect damage
- Requires regular maintenance and protective treatments
Best for: Residential decks, garden pavilions, shelters, and rustic architectural features
Aluminum Cantilever Frame
Known for its corrosion resistance and low weight, aluminum is ideal for temporary or exposed outdoor installations.
Advantages
- Extremely lightweight and portable
- Naturally resistant to rust and weathering
- Modern, sleek appearance
- Easy to assemble and reconfigure
Limitations
- Lower structural strength than steel
- Higher cost per unit strength
- Requires welding or riveting for strong joints
Best for: Sunshades, exhibition stands, temporary canopies, and lightweight balcony systems
Complex Cantilever Frame
These advanced systems combine multiple cantilevers, hybrid materials, and intricate geometries to achieve bold architectural statements.
Advantages
- Enables innovative and sculptural designs
- Optimizes space and structural efficiency
- Can integrate steel, concrete, and composites
- Utilizes advanced modeling for precision
Limitations
- High design and engineering complexity
- Expensive to fabricate and install
- Requires specialized software and expertise
Best for: Iconic buildings, modern bridges, museum extensions, and avant-garde installations
| Frame Type | Strength | Weight | Durability | Best Applications |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steel | Excellent | Medium | Very Good | High-rises, bridges, industrial structures |
| Concrete | Excellent (Compression) | High | Excellent | Balconies, pools, permanent overhangs |
| Timber | Good (Tension) | Low | Good (with maintenance) | Residential decks, pavilions, eco-buildings |
| Aluminum | Fair to Good | Very Low | Good (weather-resistant) | Temporary structures, sunshades, exhibitions |
| Complex | Variable (High) | Variable | Excellent | Architectural landmarks, hybrid systems |
Expert Tip: When designing cantilever frames, especially long spans, always account for deflection and moment forces. Use finite element analysis (FEA) tools to simulate stress distribution and ensure structural integrity under dynamic loads like wind or seismic activity.
Features of Cantilever Frame Structure
Cantilever frame structures are a hallmark of modern engineering and architectural design, offering unique advantages in both functionality and aesthetics. These structures project horizontally into space with support only at one end, allowing for dramatic overhangs and open, unobstructed spaces beneath. Their widespread use in residential, commercial, and public buildings underscores their versatility and structural efficiency.
Ideal for Protruding Sections
Cantilever frames are exceptionally well-suited for applications requiring extended overhanging elements without external bracing. This makes them a preferred choice for architectural features such as balconies, canopies, awnings, and roof overhangs. By transferring loads back to the supported end, cantilevers maximize usable space while minimizing visual obstructions.
Because they eliminate the need for columns or supports at the free end, these structures enhance both spatial openness and design elegance. They are particularly valuable in urban environments where space is limited and architectural creativity is prioritized.
Materials and Structural Strength
Cantilever frames can be constructed from a variety of high-performance materials, each selected based on structural demands, environmental conditions, and aesthetic goals. Common materials include:
- Steel: Offers exceptional tensile strength and ductility, making it ideal for large-scale commercial and industrial applications such as stadiums, airports, and high-rise buildings.
- Reinforced Concrete: Provides excellent compressive strength and rigidity, commonly used in bridges, parking structures, and multi-story buildings due to its durability and fire resistance.
- Timber: Favored in residential and eco-friendly designs for its natural appearance, lightweight nature, and ease of fabrication—especially in modern hybrid timber-concrete systems.
- Aluminum: Lightweight and corrosion-resistant, suitable for smaller architectural features like sunshades and lightweight canopies where reduced dead load is critical.
Load Distribution and Structural Balance
One of the most critical aspects of cantilever design is effective load management. The structure must safely transfer various types of loads—including dead loads (self-weight), live loads (occupants, furniture), wind forces, and seismic activity—back to the anchored support point.
Engineers perform rigorous structural analysis to ensure that bending moments, shear forces, and deflection remain within safe limits. Counterbalancing techniques, such as extending the structure inward or integrating additional mass on the supported side, are often employed to maintain equilibrium and prevent tipping or excessive stress.
Proper detailing at the support junction—where the cantilever connects to the main structure—is essential to avoid stress concentrations and ensure long-term durability.
Versatility in Architectural Design
Cantilever frames offer unparalleled design flexibility, enabling architects to push the boundaries of form and function. Their ability to create floating or suspended appearances allows for bold, innovative designs such as curved overhangs, angular facades, and gravity-defying extensions.
This adaptability has been instrumental in solving complex spatial challenges in contemporary architecture, from cantilevered observation decks to multi-level residential extensions. The seamless integration of structure and aesthetics makes cantilevers a favorite in projects aiming for visual impact and functional efficiency.
Moreover, their compatibility with glass, composite panels, and other modern cladding systems enhances their appeal in high-end architectural applications.
Minimal Internal Supports
A defining advantage of cantilever frames is their ability to span large distances without intermediate columns or load-bearing walls. This results in completely open and flexible interior spaces—highly desirable in commercial buildings, auditoriums, exhibition halls, and parking garages.
By eliminating obstructive supports, cantilevers improve spatial flow, enhance natural lighting, and allow for adaptable floor plans that can evolve with changing functional needs. In parking structures, for example, this means wider driving lanes and easier navigation.
The reduction in internal supports also lowers long-term maintenance costs and increases the potential for future renovations or repurposing of space.
| Feature | Structural Benefit | Common Applications |
|---|---|---|
| Protruding Design | Enables overhangs without external supports | Balconies, Canopies, Awnings |
| Material Flexibility | Adaptable to steel, concrete, timber, aluminum | Residential, Commercial, Industrial |
| Load Transfer Efficiency | Channels loads to fixed support point | Bridges, Stadiums, High-Rise Buildings |
| Design Innovation | Supports bold, floating architectural forms | Museums, Observation Decks, Modern Homes |
| Open Interior Space | Eliminates need for internal columns | Auditoriums, Parking Garages, Retail Spaces |
Important: While cantilever frames offer remarkable design freedom, they require precise engineering and high-quality construction. Inadequate support design, poor material selection, or miscalculations in load distribution can lead to structural failure, excessive deflection, or safety hazards. Always engage qualified structural engineers during the design and implementation phases to ensure compliance with building codes and long-term performance.
Uses of Cantilever Frame Structure
Cantilever frame structures are a fundamental engineering solution in which a beam or structural element is supported at only one end, projecting horizontally into space. This design allows for dramatic overhangs, unobstructed spaces, and innovative architectural forms. Their ability to transfer loads efficiently through moment resistance makes them ideal for a wide range of applications—from monumental buildings to everyday furniture. Below is a comprehensive overview of the major uses of cantilever frames across industries.
Architectural Applications
Cantilever frames play a transformative role in modern architecture, enabling bold, gravity-defying designs that blend form and function. By extending structural elements beyond their supports, architects can create floating balconies, expansive overhangs, and dynamic canopies that enhance both visual appeal and spatial efficiency.
- Famous examples include Fallingwater by Frank Lloyd Wright, where reinforced concrete cantilevers extend over a waterfall, blending the structure with nature.
- The Sydney Opera House features cantilevered roof shells that appear to soar into the sky, made possible by precast concrete ribs.
- Residential and commercial buildings use cantilevered terraces to maximize views and outdoor living space without additional ground support.
- These designs require precise load calculations and high-strength materials like steel-reinforced concrete to ensure long-term stability and safety.
Design Insight: Proper counterbalancing and foundation design are crucial to prevent tipping or structural failure.
Bridges and Transportation Structures
Cantilever bridges are among the most effective solutions for spanning long distances without intermediate supports, especially over waterways, valleys, or busy roadways. These structures rely on balanced arms extending from piers, often joined by a central suspended span.
- The Quebec Bridge in Canada is one of the longest cantilever bridges in the world, showcasing the strength and scalability of this design.
- Railway and highway bridges use steel truss cantilevers to support heavy, dynamic loads while minimizing obstruction to traffic below.
- Construction is typically sequential—segments are built outward from each pier, reducing the need for temporary scaffolding in deep or fast-moving waters.
- Modern cantilever bridges incorporate high-tensile steel and advanced monitoring systems for stress and deflection.
Engineering Advantage: Cantilever construction allows for safer, more efficient building over challenging terrain.
Industrial and Commercial Buildings
In large-scale facilities such as warehouses, factories, and exhibition halls, cantilever frames enable vast, open interior spaces free of obstructive columns. This flexibility is essential for optimizing workflow, storage, and equipment movement.
- Steel cantilever trusses support expansive roofs in aircraft hangars and distribution centers, allowing unimpeded access for large machinery.
- Shelving systems in warehouses often use cantilever racks to store long or bulky materials like pipes, lumber, or steel beams.
- The absence of internal supports allows for easy reconfiguration of space as operational needs evolve.
- These frames are typically made from galvanized or coated steel to resist corrosion and maintain structural integrity over decades.
Operational Benefit: Maximizes usable floor area and improves logistics efficiency in industrial environments.
Marine and Offshore Structures
Cantilever frames are critical in marine engineering, where durability and resistance to dynamic forces are paramount. They are used in offshore platforms, piers, jetties, and docking systems exposed to waves, wind, and saltwater corrosion.
- Offshore oil and gas platforms use cantilevered arms to deploy drilling equipment or connect to subsea systems without compromising the main structure.
- Piers and loading docks extend over water using cantilevered decks, allowing ships to berth safely while maintaining structural stability.
- Materials such as marine-grade steel or fiber-reinforced composites are used to withstand hydrostatic pressure, tidal forces, and biofouling.
- Engineers incorporate shock absorbers and flexible joints to accommodate wave-induced motion and prevent fatigue failure.
Durability Focus: Protective coatings and cathodic protection systems extend the lifespan of marine cantilevers.
Furniture and Landscaping Features
The principles of cantilever design extend beyond large-scale construction into everyday objects and outdoor environments. These applications emphasize aesthetics, ergonomics, and space-saving functionality.
- Cantilever chairs, popularized by designers like Le Corbusier and Mies van der Rohe, use a single continuous frame to support the seat, creating a sleek, floating appearance.
- Tables with overhanging tops and no central legs offer unobstructed legroom and modern visual appeal.
- In landscaping, cantilevered pergolas, sunshades, and benches provide shelter and seating without blocking views or pathways.
- Materials range from tubular steel and aluminum to reinforced concrete and engineered wood, chosen for strength and weather resistance.
Design Tip: Even small-scale cantilevers require careful weight distribution to prevent tipping.
Additional Applications
Beyond the primary categories, cantilever frames are found in various specialized fields, demonstrating their versatility and engineering adaptability.
- Aerospace: Aircraft wings act as cantilevers, supported at the fuselage and bearing aerodynamic loads during flight.
- Renewable Energy: Wind turbine blades are cantilevered structures designed to capture wind energy efficiently while withstanding cyclic stresses.
- Stadiums and Arenas: Retractable roofs and upper-tier seating often use cantilevered trusses to avoid obstructing sightlines.
- Urban Infrastructure: Canopies over bus stops, pedestrian walkways, and bike shelters use lightweight cantilevers for quick installation and minimal footprint.
Innovation Spotlight: Advances in composite materials are expanding the possibilities for lightweight, high-strength cantilevers.
Professional Insight: When designing or specifying cantilever structures, always consider the moment arm, load distribution, and material fatigue. A well-designed cantilever not only performs structurally but also enhances the aesthetic and functional value of the space. For architectural and industrial applications, collaboration between architects, structural engineers, and material scientists ensures optimal performance and longevity.
| Application | Key Material | Primary Benefit | Design Consideration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Architectural Overhangs | Reinforced Concrete / Steel | Visual Drama & Space Efficiency | Foundation Stability & Load Balancing |
| Cantilever Bridges | High-Tensile Steel Trusses | Long Spans Without Supports | Dynamic Load Resistance & Fatigue Monitoring |
| Industrial Warehouses | Galvanized Steel | Column-Free Interior Space | Load Capacity & Corrosion Protection |
| Marine Structures | Marine-Grade Steel / Composites | Durability in Harsh Environments | Hydrodynamic Forces & Corrosion Resistance |
| Furniture & Landscaping | Steel Tubing / Aluminum / Wood | Aesthetic Appeal & Space Saving | Weight Distribution & Tip Resistance |
Key Engineering Principles in Cantilever Design
- Moment Resistance: The fixed end must resist bending moments generated by the load on the overhanging section.
- Deflection Control: Excessive sagging must be minimized through proper material selection and cross-sectional design.
- Vibration Damping: Especially in long spans, dynamic loads (wind, traffic) can induce oscillations that require damping mechanisms.
- Material Efficiency: Tapered or variable-depth beams optimize strength-to-weight ratio, reducing material use without compromising safety.
- Sustainability: Modern designs increasingly use recycled steel and low-carbon concrete to reduce environmental impact.
How to Choose the Right Cantilever Frame Structure
Selecting the appropriate cantilever frame structure is a critical engineering and architectural decision that impacts both the functionality and visual appeal of a building or system. Cantilever frames—structures supported at only one end, projecting horizontally into space—are widely used in modern architecture, bridges, balconies, and industrial equipment due to their ability to create open, unobstructed spaces. This guide explores the key factors to consider when choosing a cantilever frame, including material selection, load requirements, span length, deflection and stiffness, and design aesthetics, to ensure structural integrity, durability, and alignment with project goals.
Structural Integrity Warning: Improperly designed or undersized cantilever frames can lead to catastrophic failure due to excessive bending moments and stress concentrations. Always consult a licensed structural engineer before finalizing design choices, especially for large-scale or load-bearing applications.
Key Factors in Cantilever Frame Selection
- Material Selection
The choice of material is foundational to the performance, longevity, and appearance of a cantilever frame. Each material offers distinct mechanical and aesthetic properties:
- Steel: Offers exceptional tensile and compressive strength, making it ideal for high-rise buildings, industrial platforms, and long-span bridges. Its high strength-to-weight ratio supports large loads with minimal deflection.
- Reinforced Concrete: Excellent for heavy-duty applications such as stadium overhangs and parking structures. It provides high compressive strength and fire resistance but is heavier and requires formwork and curing time.
- Wood: Commonly used in residential architecture and outdoor decks for its natural aesthetic, warmth, and ease of fabrication. Best suited for shorter spans and dry environments to prevent rot and insect damage.
- Aluminum: Lightweight, corrosion-resistant, and ideal for outdoor or marine environments. Frequently used in canopies, signage, and temporary structures. However, it has lower stiffness than steel and may deflect more under load.
Environmental exposure, maintenance expectations, and budget also influence material choice. For example, coastal installations benefit from aluminum’s rust resistance, while urban high-rises often rely on steel for structural efficiency.
- Load Requirements
A thorough load analysis is essential to ensure the cantilever can safely support all expected forces. Consider the following load types:
- Dead Loads: The permanent weight of the structure itself, including beams, decking, and fixed components.
- Live Loads: Variable forces such as people, furniture, snow accumulation, or movable equipment. Building codes (e.g., IBC or Eurocodes) specify minimum live load requirements based on occupancy type.
- Environmental Loads: Wind pressure, seismic activity, and thermal expansion can induce significant stress in cantilevers due to their unsupported nature. These dynamic forces must be modeled and accounted for in the design phase.
Structural calculations should include safety factors (typically 1.5–2.0) to account for unforeseen stresses. Overlooking any load type can compromise safety and lead to premature fatigue or failure.
- Span Length
The span length—the horizontal distance from the support point to the free end—directly affects the structural complexity and material requirements. As span increases:
- Bending moments rise exponentially, requiring stronger or deeper beams.
- Deflection becomes more pronounced, potentially affecting usability and aesthetics.
- Additional bracing or secondary supports may be necessary to maintain stability.
While longer spans offer dramatic visual appeal and open floor plans, they demand advanced engineering solutions such as tapered beams, trusses, or composite materials. For spans exceeding 10 feet (3 meters), professional structural analysis is strongly recommended.
- Deflection and Stiffness
Deflection (sagging) and stiffness (resistance to deformation) are critical performance metrics for cantilevers. Excessive deflection can lead to:
- Cracking in connected materials (e.g., drywall or tile).
- User discomfort due to perceived instability.
- Drainage issues in roofing or decking applications.
Materials with a high modulus of elasticity—such as steel and reinforced concrete—resist bending more effectively. Designers often use moment of inertia calculations and finite element analysis to predict deflection under load. Industry standards typically limit deflection to L/360 (span length divided by 360) for live loads to ensure serviceability.
- Design and Aesthetics
Beyond structural performance, cantilever frames are celebrated for their architectural boldness. They enable sleek, modern designs with floating roofs, overhanging balconies, and minimalist facades. When integrating cantilevers into a design:
- Ensure the structural form complements the architectural style—industrial, contemporary, or rustic.
- Conceal or highlight structural elements based on design intent (e.g., exposed steel beams for an industrial look).
- Coordinate with other building systems (e.g., waterproofing, cladding, and lighting) to maintain both beauty and functionality.
Successful projects balance visual impact with engineering rigor, ensuring that dramatic overhangs do not compromise safety or longevity.
| Selection Factor | Best Applications | Common Challenges | Recommended Materials |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Residential, commercial, industrial, outdoor | Corrosion, weight, cost, maintenance | Steel, concrete, wood, aluminum |
| Load Requirements | High-occupancy areas, snow-prone regions, seismic zones | Underestimating dynamic loads, code compliance | Steel, reinforced concrete |
| Span Length | Overhangs, balconies, canopies | Excessive deflection, need for reinforcement | Steel, composite beams |
| Deflection & Stiffness | Precision equipment, long spans, sensitive finishes | Sagging, cracking, user discomfort | Steel, high-strength concrete |
| Design & Aesthetics | Modern architecture, luxury homes, public spaces | Cost vs. appearance, integration with finishes | Custom steel, architectural wood, aluminum |
Expert Tip: When designing cantilever structures, consider using finite element analysis (FEA) software to simulate stress distribution and deflection under various load conditions. This allows for optimization of material use and ensures compliance with safety standards before construction begins.
Additional Recommendations
- Always adhere to local building codes and standards (e.g., AISC, ACI, or Eurocode) for structural design.
- Perform regular inspections on existing cantilever structures, especially in harsh environments.
- Use protective coatings (e.g., galvanization, sealants) to extend the lifespan of exposed materials.
- Collaborate with architects, engineers, and contractors early in the design process to align structural and aesthetic goals.
- Consider sustainability by selecting recyclable materials like steel or FSC-certified wood.
Choosing the right cantilever frame structure involves a careful balance of engineering principles, material science, and design vision. By evaluating material properties, load demands, span requirements, stiffness, and aesthetic goals, you can create a safe, durable, and visually striking structure. When in doubt, always seek professional engineering input to ensure your cantilever design stands the test of time—both structurally and stylistically.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cantilever Frame Structures
A cantilever frame structure is an architectural and engineering design where horizontal beams or structural members are rigidly anchored at one end while extending freely into space at the other—without additional vertical support. This configuration allows for dramatic overhangs and unsupported spans, commonly seen in balconies, bridges, and modern building extensions.
The key principle behind a cantilever is its ability to resist bending moments and shear forces through a strong fixed connection to a supporting column or wall. This fixed end absorbs the load from the overhanging section, transferring stresses safely into the foundation. Because of this, precise engineering calculations are essential to ensure structural integrity and long-term durability.
Cantilever frames offer a range of functional and aesthetic advantages that make them highly desirable in modern architecture and civil engineering:
- Unobstructed Space: By eliminating the need for intermediate columns or supports, cantilevers create open, flexible interior or exterior areas ideal for large gathering spaces, panoramic views, or unimpeded movement.
- Aesthetic Appeal: The floating appearance of cantilevered structures adds a sense of lightness and modernity to buildings, enhancing visual interest and architectural uniqueness.
- Design Flexibility: Architects can extend living spaces, create shaded outdoor areas, or design dynamic rooflines without compromising on layout efficiency.
- Weather Protection: Overhanging roofs or balconies can shield lower levels from rain and direct sunlight, contributing to energy efficiency and comfort.
- Space Optimization: In urban environments with limited footprint availability, cantilevers allow vertical expansion without increasing the building’s ground coverage.
These benefits make cantilever designs especially popular in high-end residential homes, commercial buildings, stadiums, and public infrastructure.
The choice of material for a cantilever frame depends on the required strength, span length, environmental exposure, and design intent. Common materials include:
| Material | Strengths | Applications |
|---|---|---|
| Steel | High tensile strength, excellent load-bearing capacity, ductile under stress | Long-span bridges, high-rise buildings, industrial structures |
| Reinforced Concrete | Durable, fire-resistant, moldable into complex shapes | Balconies, stadium overhangs, parking structures |
| Wood | Lightweight, renewable, aesthetically warm, easy to work with | Residential decks, small shelters, eco-friendly designs |
| Aluminum | Corrosion-resistant, lightweight, low maintenance | Modern façades, temporary structures, marine environments |
In many cases, hybrid systems combine materials—such as steel beams with concrete slabs—to optimize performance, cost, and longevity. Engineers also consider factors like wind loads, seismic activity, and thermal expansion when selecting materials.
Cantilever frames are widely employed across various sectors due to their structural efficiency and visual impact. Key applications include:
- Architecture: Balconies, terraces, roof overhangs, and cantilevered floors in homes and commercial buildings (e.g., Frank Lloyd Wright’s “Fallingwater”).
- Bridge Construction: Cantilever bridges use balanced arms extending from piers to span large distances without temporary supports during construction.
- Stadiums and Auditoriums: Large roof canopies that provide shelter to seating areas while maintaining unobstructed sightlines.
- Furniture Design: Chairs, tables, and shelves that appear to float, offering minimalist aesthetics.
- Transportation Infrastructure: Canopies over platforms, pedestrian walkways, and airport terminals.
- Industrial Structures: Loading docks, mezzanine levels, and equipment supports requiring clear floor space.
These applications highlight how cantilever frames blend engineering precision with creative design to solve spatial challenges and enhance user experience.
Cantilever frames are engineered to efficiently manage multiple types of structural loads by transferring forces from the free end back to the fixed support:
- Dead Loads: The weight of the structure itself (beams, slabs, finishes) is continuously supported through the anchored end, which must be designed to resist constant downward force and bending moment.
- Live Loads: Temporary or variable loads—such as people, furniture, or snow on a balcony—are distributed along the span and transferred as shear and moment to the support.
- Dynamic Loads: Wind, seismic activity, or vibrations require careful analysis to prevent resonance or deflection. Damping elements or bracing may be added for stability.
- Moment Resistance: The fixed end resists rotational forces (bending moments) caused by the load acting at a distance from the support, preventing tipping or collapse.
- Deflection Control: Excessive sagging at the free end is minimized through material selection, cross-sectional depth, and reinforcement strategies.
To ensure safety, engineers perform rigorous stress analysis and often use computer-aided modeling to simulate real-world conditions. Proper anchoring, connection detailing, and regular inspections are critical to maintaining performance over time.








浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?