Types of Custom-Made Bookcases
A custom-made bookcase is a tailored storage solution designed to maximize space efficiency, enhance room aesthetics, and meet specific organizational needs. Whether you're furnishing a home library, office, or compact apartment, selecting the right type of bookcase can significantly impact both functionality and visual appeal. Below is a comprehensive guide to the most popular types of custom bookcases, including their features, benefits, and ideal applications.
Wall-Mounted Bookcases
Space-saving shelves anchored directly to the wall, ideal for modern interiors and compact spaces.
Advantages
- Maximizes floor space
- Modern, minimalist appearance
- Customizable height and layout
- Great for children’s reach and safety
- Can include mix of open shelves and closed cabinets
Limitations
- Requires secure wall mounting
- Limited weight capacity
- Not easily movable once installed
Best for: Small apartments, contemporary homes, nurseries, and rooms with limited floor space
Freestanding Bookcases
Traditional floor-standing units offering flexible placement and substantial storage capacity.
Advantages
- No installation required
- High load-bearing capacity
- Easy to relocate or reconfigure
- Versatile design options (open, closed, mixed)
- Serves as both storage and room divider
Limitations
- Takes up floor space
- May tip if not secured (especially with children)
- Less integrated look compared to built-ins
Best for: Living rooms, home offices, libraries, and large open spaces
Corner Bookcases
Specially designed to utilize underused corner spaces with diagonal or curved shelving.
Advantages
- Optimizes unused corner areas
- Creates a focal point in the room
- Available in wall-mounted or freestanding styles
- Can feature tiered or radiused shelves
- Improves room flow and space perception
Limitations
- Custom fitting required for angles
- Limited access to back corners
- May feel cramped in very small rooms
Best for: Rooms with awkward corners, compact layouts, and transitional spaces
Cube Bookcases
Modular units made of uniform cubical compartments, offering flexible and modern storage.
Advantages
- Highly customizable configurations
- Perfect for books, decor, and plants
- Can mix open and closed cubes
- Easily expandable with additional modules
- Contemporary, clean aesthetic
Limitations
- May look cluttered without organization
- Exposed items collect dust
- Less formal appearance
Best for: Modern homes, kids’ rooms, media rooms, and creative workspaces
Sliding Door Bookcases
Elegant storage units with sliding glass or wood doors that save space and protect contents.
Advantages
- No clearance needed for door swing
- Keeps items dust-free and secure
- Smooth, sleek appearance
- Can conceal clutter or valuable collections
- Available in mirrored, frosted, or clear glass
Limitations
- Tracks may require maintenance
- Higher cost due to hardware and materials
- More complex installation
Best for: Living rooms, executive offices, dens, and display-focused environments
| Type | Space Efficiency | Storage Capacity | Aesthetic Style | Best Application |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wall-Mounted | Excellent | Medium | Modern, Minimalist | Small spaces, nurseries, accent walls |
| Freestanding | Good | High | Traditional, Classic | Libraries, offices, living rooms |
| Corner | Excellent | Medium to High | Architectural, Unique | Awkward corners, compact rooms |
| Cube | Good | Medium | Contemporary, Modular | Kids' rooms, media centers, creative spaces |
| Sliding Door | Very Good | High | Elegant, Refined | Living rooms, executive offices, display areas |
Expert Tip: When designing a custom bookcase, consider the weight of your collection—especially hardcover books or media equipment—and ensure the materials and supports are rated for long-term load-bearing. Reinforced back panels and adjustable shelves add both durability and flexibility.
Design of Custom Made Bookcase: Style, Materials & Functionality
Creating a custom made bookcase is more than just a storage solution—it's an opportunity to blend form and function into a piece of furniture that enhances your space. Whether you're furnishing a home library, office, or living room, the design of your bookcase should reflect both your aesthetic preferences and practical needs. From material selection to stylistic influences, every decision shapes the final outcome.
Custom bookcases can be broadly categorized into several design styles—modern, traditional, transitional, and industrial—each offering distinct visual appeal and structural characteristics. Understanding these styles, along with the materials used in construction, allows for a tailored design that complements your interior while maximizing durability and usability.
Key Design Styles
Modern
Modern custom bookcases emphasize clean lines, geometric shapes, and minimal ornamentation. This design philosophy prioritizes functionality and simplicity, making it ideal for contemporary homes and minimalist interiors.
Materials such as tempered glass, brushed steel, and high-gloss laminates are commonly used to achieve a sleek, clutter-free look. Open shelving, floating designs, and integrated lighting are popular features that enhance both aesthetics and usability. These bookcases often serve as focal points in modern living spaces, combining elegance with practical storage.
Traditional
Traditional bookcases exude timeless elegance with rich detailing and classic craftsmanship. Often constructed from solid hardwoods like oak, cherry, or mahogany, they feature ornate elements such as crown molding, fluted pilasters, carved panels, and decorative finials.
These pieces are well-suited for formal libraries, heritage homes, or spaces aiming for a vintage or academic ambiance. Many traditional designs include glass doors, concealed compartments, and adjustable shelving to protect valuable collections while maintaining visual appeal. The emphasis is on durability, symmetry, and refined aesthetics.
Transitional
Transitional style strikes a balance between modern minimalism and traditional warmth. These bookcases combine clean silhouettes with subtle decorative touches—such as a simple pediment or soft molding—allowing them to blend seamlessly into diverse interior schemes.
They are highly versatile, making them ideal for homes that mix old and new elements. Often crafted from wood with neutral finishes or paired with metal accents, transitional bookcases offer both visual harmony and functional flexibility. Their adaptability makes them a popular choice for living rooms, studies, and entryways.
Industrial
Industrial-style bookcases draw inspiration from warehouses, factories, and urban lofts. They feature raw, rugged materials such as black steel pipes, reclaimed wood, and exposed bolts, celebrating functionality and structural honesty.
This style embraces asymmetry, open frameworks, and unfinished textures to create a bold, masculine presence. Industrial bookcases are perfect for modern apartments, creative studios, or eclectic interiors where character and durability are prioritized. They often incorporate mixed materials—like wood shelves on metal frames—for both strength and visual contrast.
Material Options for Custom Bookcases
The choice of material significantly impacts the appearance, strength, and longevity of a custom bookcase. Each material brings unique advantages and design possibilities.
Wood
Wood remains one of the most popular and versatile materials for custom bookcases, prized for its natural beauty, strength, and workability. It offers a wide range of finishes and can be stained, painted, or sealed to match any decor.
- Solid Hardwoods: Oak, maple, cherry, and walnut offer exceptional durability and develop a rich patina over time, enhancing their visual appeal.
- Plywood: A cost-effective and stable engineered wood, often used with veneers to mimic the look of solid wood while resisting warping.
- MDF (Medium-Density Fiberboard): Smooth and uniform, ideal for painted finishes and intricate designs, though less durable than solid wood.
Wooden bookcases can be customized with adjustable shelves, lighting, glass doors, or integrated cabinetry, making them suitable for both display and heavy storage.
Metal
Metal is a hallmark of modern and industrial designs, offering sleekness, strength, and a minimalist aesthetic. Commonly used metals include steel, wrought iron, and aluminum, each with distinct weight, finish, and corrosion resistance properties.
Steel and iron provide robust support for heavy book collections, while aluminum offers a lightweight yet durable alternative. Metal frames can be powder-coated in various colors for a contemporary finish. Often combined with wood or glass shelves, metal bookcases create a striking visual contrast and maximize structural integrity.
They are especially popular in commercial spaces, modern homes, and areas where durability and low maintenance are key considerations.
Glass
Glass bookcases are synonymous with elegance and openness, making them ideal for contemporary interiors and small spaces. Typically constructed from tempered or laminated safety glass, they offer durability and resistance to breakage.
Shelves can be frameless or supported by minimalist metal or wooden brackets, creating a "floating" effect. Glass allows light to pass through, enhancing the sense of space and making it easier to showcase books, collectibles, artwork, or trophies.
While they require regular cleaning to maintain clarity, glass bookcases add a refined, airy quality to any room. They are often used in living rooms, offices, or foyers where visual lightness and display functionality are desired.
Hybrid Materials
Many custom bookcases combine multiple materials to achieve both aesthetic balance and structural performance. Popular combinations include:
- Wood and Metal: Warmth of wood paired with the strength and modern edge of steel or iron.
- Glass and Metal: Sleek, transparent shelves on a geometric metal frame for a futuristic look.
- Wood and Glass: Solid wood frames with glass shelves or doors for a traditional yet open feel.
Hybrid designs allow for greater customization and can be tailored to specific room dimensions, lighting conditions, and usage requirements.
| Design Style | Best Materials | Ideal For | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Modern | Glass, Metal, MDF, Laminate | Contemporary homes, minimalist spaces | Clean lines, open shelving, integrated lighting |
| Traditional | Solid Wood (Oak, Cherry, Walnut) | Libraries, formal living rooms | Ornate carvings, crown molding, glass doors |
| Transitional | Wood with Metal Accents, Veneers | Mixed-style interiors, studies | Simple elegance, balanced proportions |
| Industrial | Reclaimed Wood, Steel, Iron | Lofts, modern apartments, offices | Exposed bolts, raw finishes, open frames |
Design Considerations for Optimal Functionality
Important: Always consult with a professional designer or carpenter when planning a custom bookcase, especially for large or structural installations. Proper anchoring is essential for safety, particularly in homes with children or pets. Consider the long-term maintenance and environmental conditions (humidity, sunlight) when selecting materials to ensure lasting beauty and performance.
Scenarios of Custom Made Bookcases: Maximizing Space and Style in Every Room
Custom made bookcases are more than just storage solutions—they are architectural features that enhance both the functionality and aesthetic of a space. Tailored to fit specific dimensions, design preferences, and usage needs, these bespoke units transform ordinary walls into dynamic, organized, and visually appealing environments. Below are key scenarios where custom bookcases elevate everyday living.
Living Room: A Centerpiece of Function and Design
Custom bookcases in the living room serve as multifunctional centerpieces, combining storage, display, and architectural interest. Whether built from floor to ceiling or integrated beside a fireplace or entertainment center, these shelves maximize vertical space and eliminate clutter.
- Floor-to-ceiling units create a dramatic, library-like ambiance and utilize otherwise unused overhead space
- Combination of open shelves and glass-front cabinets allows for both display and dust-free storage of collectibles, books, and media
- Lower cabinetry provides stable surfaces for TVs, family photos, or decorative items, blending seamlessly with the overall room design
- Integrated lighting enhances visibility and adds warmth, turning the bookcase into a focal point during evening hours
Design Tip: Match the finish to existing furniture or flooring for a cohesive, high-end look.
Bedroom: Personalized Comfort and Storage
In bedrooms, custom bookcases blend utility with intimacy, creating cozy reading nooks or organized personal retreats. Whether for adults or children, these units reflect individual tastes and lifestyle needs.
- Wall-mounted or freestanding shelves opposite the bed create a dedicated reading zone, especially when paired with built-in LED lighting
- Cube-style shelving offers flexible storage for books, plants, baskets, and personal mementos
- In children’s or teen rooms, themed designs (e.g., geometric shapes, favorite colors, or educational motifs) make storage fun and engaging
- Hidden compartments or pull-out desks can add functionality without sacrificing space
Pro Insight: Use soft-close mechanisms and rounded edges for safety and quiet operation in private spaces.
Home Office: Professional Organization and Efficiency
A custom bookcase in a home or professional office enhances productivity by providing structured, accessible storage for books, files, and office supplies. Unlike standard shelving, custom designs align perfectly with workflow and decor.
- Adjustable shelves accommodate varying book sizes, binders, and archival materials
- Integrated desk extensions or hidden workspaces maximize utility in compact rooms
- Sliding or hinged doors conceal clutter and maintain a clean, professional appearance during video calls
- Dedicated compartments for stationery, puzzles, or tech accessories keep essentials within reach
Smart Feature: Add cable management cutouts for charging stations or office electronics.
Library: Elegance Meets Practicality
For dedicated libraries or reading rooms, custom bookcases are essential for both capacity and ambiance. These spaces demand intelligent design to balance storage density with aesthetic refinement.
- Tall, full-wall units with multiple horizontal and vertical sections optimize book capacity
- Open shelving highlights prized collections, while closed cabinets protect rare or sensitive materials
- Architectural details—such as crown molding, carved wood, or antique finishes—elevate the room’s sophistication
- Rolling ladders or pull-down steps ensure safe access to top shelves, doubling as decorative elements
Luxury Touch: Incorporate ambient lighting, glass doors, or brass hardware for a timeless, elegant feel.
Expert Recommendation: When designing custom bookcases, consider the room’s primary function, user demographics, and long-term adaptability. For example, a child’s bedroom bookcase can evolve with modular components, while an office unit should prioritize durability and accessibility. Always consult with a designer to ensure structural integrity, especially for floor-to-ceiling installations.
| Room Type | Primary Function | Recommended Features | Material Suggestions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Living Room | Display & Media Storage | Combination of open/closed shelves, integrated lighting, lower cabinetry | Hardwood, MDF with veneer, tempered glass doors |
| Bedroom | Personal Storage & Reading Nook | Cube shelves, built-in lights, baskets, soft-close drawers | Plywood, painted finishes, eco-friendly composites |
| Office | Document & Supply Organization | Adjustable shelves, sliding doors, cable management, desk integration | Engineered wood, laminate, metal accents |
| Library | High-Capacity Book Storage | Full-height units, rolling ladder, glass doors, ambient lighting | Solid hardwood, walnut, cherry, or stained oak |
Additional Design Considerations
- Space Optimization: Custom bookcases eliminate gaps and awkward spaces, fitting perfectly into corners, alcoves, or under sloped ceilings
- Lighting Integration: LED strips or puck lights highlight displays and improve readability, especially in low-light areas
- Child Safety: Secure tall units to wall studs to prevent tipping; use rounded corners in high-traffic areas
- Acoustic Benefits: Textured or layered shelving can help diffuse sound in open-plan living spaces
- Sustainability: Choose FSC-certified wood or recycled materials for eco-conscious builds
Specification & Maintenance of Custom-Made Bookcases
Custom-made bookcases are more than just storage solutions—they are functional works of art that blend seamlessly with your interior design while offering tailored utility. Whether you're designing a new piece or maintaining an existing one, understanding both the specifications and care requirements ensures longevity, structural integrity, and aesthetic appeal. This guide provides a comprehensive overview of how to plan, select materials, and maintain your custom bookcase for lasting beauty and performance.
Design Tip: Always measure your space twice and consider traffic flow, lighting, and adjacent furniture when planning your bookcase dimensions and placement. A well-placed bookcase can define a room’s character and improve spatial organization.
Key Specifications for Custom Bookcases
The success of a custom bookcase begins with thoughtful planning and material selection. Below are the essential factors to consider during the design phase.
- Dimensions: Tailoring Size to Space and Function
Accurate measurements are the foundation of any custom bookcase. Consider both the available wall space and the intended use. Large, floor-to-ceiling bookcases can act as room dividers or architectural focal points, especially when framing windows or anchoring a reading nook. In compact apartments or small rooms, opt for slim-depth designs or floating units to maximize floor space without sacrificing storage. Standard shelf depths range from 10–12 inches for paperbacks and hardcovers, while deeper shelves (14–16 inches) accommodate oversized art books or decorative objects.
- Material Selection: Balancing Aesthetics, Strength, and Budget
The choice of material significantly influences durability, weight capacity, and visual style. Common options include:
- Solid Wood: Offers timeless elegance, excellent durability, and natural grain variation. Ideal for heirloom-quality pieces. Species like oak, walnut, and maple are popular for their strength and finishability.
- Plywood or MDF (Medium-Density Fiberboard): Cost-effective and stable, especially for painted finishes. MDF resists warping but is heavier and less breathable than solid wood.
- Veneer: A thin layer of real wood over engineered substrate—provides the look of solid wood at a lower cost and with improved dimensional stability.
- Metal and Glass: Modern materials that lend an industrial or minimalist aesthetic. Steel frames offer high strength, while glass shelves create an open, airy feel but require frequent cleaning and careful load management.
- Shelf Configuration: Optimizing for Use and Accessibility
Customization allows you to design shelves that match your collection. Consider:
- Varying shelf heights for different book sizes (e.g., 9" for paperbacks, 14" for coffee table books).
- Adjustable shelving systems using metal pins or brackets for future flexibility.
- Dedicated compartments for media, collectibles, or display lighting.
- Closed cabinets or doors to protect delicate items from dust and sunlight.
Ensure at least 1–2 inches of clearance above each shelf for easy book removal and airflow.
- Finishes and Hardware: Elevating Style and Durability
The final appearance and longevity of your bookcase depend heavily on finish and hardware choices:
- Wood Finishes: Stains enhance grain; paints offer bold color; clear varnishes or polyurethane protect against scratches and moisture.
- Hardware: Drawer pulls, door hinges, and shelf supports should match the design theme—brass for traditional, matte black for contemporary.
- Edge Banding: On engineered wood, this prevents chipping and improves aesthetics.
Invest in high-quality finishes and hardware—they’re critical for both function and long-term visual appeal.
Maintenance Guidelines for Longevity and Beauty
Proper care preserves the structural integrity and appearance of your custom bookcase. Follow these maintenance practices to keep it looking its best for decades.
- Regular Cleaning: Preventing Dust Buildup
Dust accumulates quickly on horizontal surfaces. Clean shelves weekly using a soft microfiber cloth or electrostatic duster. For deeper cleaning:
- Remove books and wipe surfaces with a slightly damp cloth.
- Use a mild, non-abrasive cleaner suitable for the material (e.g., wood-safe cleaner for wood, glass cleaner for glass shelves).
- Always dry immediately to prevent water damage or warping.
Rotate books occasionally to prevent uneven dust accumulation and fading from sunlight exposure.
- Check for Wear and Tear: Early Problem Detection
Inspect your bookcase every 3–6 months for signs of stress:
- Wobbling or sagging shelves—may indicate overloading or loose fasteners.
- Loose brackets, screws, or joints—tighten promptly to prevent further damage.
- Cracks, chips, or peeling finish—address early to avoid moisture penetration or insect infestation in wood.
Pay special attention to load-bearing joints and floor contact points.
- Conditioning Wood: Preserving Natural Beauty
Wood bookcases benefit from regular conditioning to prevent drying, cracking, and dullness:
- Apply a quality wood conditioner or furniture oil (e.g., lemon oil, tung oil) every 3–6 months.
- For painted or sealed finishes, use a polish designed for that surface to restore luster.
- Avoid silicone-based polishes, which can build up and attract dust.
Humidity levels between 40–60% help prevent wood expansion or shrinkage.
- Stability and Hardware Maintenance
Ensure long-term stability with routine checks:
- Tighten all screws, bolts, and connectors every 6 months.
- Lubricate moving parts (e.g., drawer slides) with silicone spray if needed.
- Anchoring tall or heavy bookcases to wall studs is essential for safety, especially in homes with children or in earthquake-prone areas.
- Finish-Specific Care: Protecting Surface Integrity
Different finishes require tailored care:
- Painted Surfaces: Avoid abrasive cleaners; use a gentle soap solution.
- Stained or Oiled Wood: Reapply oil as needed to maintain moisture balance.
- Metal Components: Wipe with a dry cloth; use metal polish sparingly to prevent corrosion.
- Glass Shelves: Clean with ammonia-free glass cleaner to avoid etching.
| Maintenance Task | Frequency | Recommended Tools/Products | Material-Specific Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dusting and surface cleaning | Weekly | Microfiber cloth, soft duster, mild cleaner | Use wood-safe cleaner for wood; glass cleaner for glass |
| Hardware inspection and tightening | Every 6 months | Screwdriver, hex key, threadlocker (if needed) | Check for corrosion on metal joints |
| Wood conditioning | Every 3–6 months | Wood oil or conditioner, lint-free cloth | Not required for MDF or veneer unless sealed |
| Structural inspection | Annually | Flashlight, level, notepad | Look for sagging, warping, or foundation issues |
| Wall anchoring check | Annually or after seismic events | Stud finder, anchor kit | Essential for units over 5 feet tall |
Longevity Tip: Distribute weight evenly across shelves and avoid overloading. Use shelf liners or felt pads to protect both the bookcase and your books. Rotate heavy items periodically to prevent permanent stress on supports.
By carefully specifying your custom bookcase with attention to dimensions, materials, and design, and by following a consistent maintenance routine, you ensure it remains a beautiful, functional centerpiece in your home for generations. A well-crafted and well-maintained bookcase is not just furniture—it's a legacy.
Frequently Asked Questions About Custom Bookcases
One of the greatest advantages of a custom bookcase is its ability to be tailored precisely to your space and storage needs. Unlike mass-produced furniture, custom bookcases can be designed to fit perfectly into unique architectural spaces such as walls, corners, alcoves, or ceiling-height gaps.
- Dimensions: Height, width, and depth can be fully customized to maximize storage capacity and ensure a seamless fit within your room.
- Shelving Options: Adjustable shelves, deep shelves for large books or decor, and sliding or pull-out shelves for easy access.
- Closed Storage: Add cabinets with doors to hide clutter, protect collectibles from dust, or create a sleek, minimalist appearance.
- Integrated Features: Built-in lighting (LED strips or spotlights), power outlets, or USB charging ports enhance both functionality and ambiance.
- Design Aesthetics: Choose from various finishes, wood types, colors, and hardware to match your interior decor style—modern, rustic, traditional, or industrial.
Whether you're organizing a home library, displaying art collections, or creating a statement piece in your living room, a custom bookcase offers unmatched flexibility and personalization.
Yes, veneered wood is an excellent and cost-effective option for custom bookcases. It combines the luxurious appearance of solid hardwood with the stability and affordability of engineered wood substrates like MDF (medium-density fiberboard) or particleboard.
- Aesthetic Appeal: Veneers provide the rich grain patterns and elegance of real wood—such as walnut, oak, or cherry—without the high cost.
- Durability: When properly sealed and maintained, veneered surfaces resist warping and cracking better than solid wood in fluctuating humidity levels.
- Eco-Friendly: Veneer uses thin slices of real wood, reducing waste and making more efficient use of natural resources.
- Maintenance Tips: Avoid excessive moisture, direct sunlight, and abrasive cleaners. Use a soft, damp cloth and mild cleaner to preserve the finish.
Veneered bookcases offer a premium look at a fraction of the price of solid wood, making them ideal for homeowners seeking both beauty and value.
The timeline for a custom bookcase varies significantly based on several key factors:
- Design Complexity: Simple, modular designs may take 2–4 weeks, while intricate, built-in units with lighting or moving parts can take 6–12 weeks or more.
- Material Selection: Exotic woods or specialty finishes may require longer lead times for sourcing.
- Manufacturer Workload: Custom furniture makers often have backlogs, especially during peak seasons (e.g., holidays).
- Installation Process: On-site assembly and finishing can add a few extra days, particularly for large or multi-section units.
As a general estimate, most custom bookcases take between 4 to 8 weeks from initial consultation to final installation. In contrast, prefabricated bookcases can be purchased and assembled in a matter of days, though they lack the personalized fit and design of custom options.
Absolutely. One of the standout benefits of a tall custom bookcase is the ability to integrate a functional and safe ladder for accessing upper shelves.
- Integrated Ladders: Can be mounted on tracks or rails along the side of the bookcase, allowing smooth sliding movement.
- Stable Design: The ladder should be securely anchored to the structure and designed to support user weight without wobbling.
- Space-Saving: Retractable or wall-mounted ladders keep the floor clear when not in use.
- Safety First: For homes with children, consider ladders with handrails, non-slip steps, and locking mechanisms to prevent accidental movement.
Custom bookcases in libraries, offices, or living rooms often feature elegant ladder systems that not only improve accessibility but also add a classic, sophisticated touch to the room’s design.
Generally, yes—custom bookcases are more expensive than off-the-shelf models, but they offer long-term value through superior fit, function, and durability.
| Feature | Custom Bookcase | Prefabricated Bookcase |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Higher initial cost due to design, materials, and craftsmanship. | Affordable, mass-produced options available at big-box stores. |
| Fit & Function | Built to fit your exact space and storage needs. | Standard sizes may leave gaps or underutilize space. |
| Material Quality | Choice of premium materials, including solid wood or veneer over MDF. | Often made from lower-density materials like particleboard. |
| Longevity | Designed for durability and long-term use. | May wear out or wobble over time, especially with heavy loads. |
| Resale Value | Can increase home value, especially as a built-in feature. | No impact on property value. |
While prefabricated bookcases are budget-friendly and convenient, they often require compromises in size, style, and sturdiness. A custom bookcase, though more costly upfront, delivers a tailored solution that enhances both utility and aesthetic appeal, making it a worthwhile investment for discerning homeowners.








浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?