Funko Pop In Box Vs Out Of Box Does Taking Them Out Ruin Resale Value

For collectors and fans alike, Funko Pops have evolved from novelty collectibles into serious investments. With rare variants selling for hundreds or even thousands of dollars, the decision to keep a figure sealed in its original packaging—or to remove it—can significantly impact both emotional satisfaction and financial return. This choice isn't just about display preferences; it's about understanding how condition, scarcity, and collector culture shape long-term value.

The debate over whether to open a Funko Pop centers on one key question: does unboxing diminish its worth? While some collectors proudly display their figures outside the box, others treat the packaging as sacred. The truth lies in nuance—context matters more than dogma. Factors like rarity, demand, edition type, and personal goals all influence the right decision.

Understanding Collector Value: What Makes a Funko Pop Valuable?

Before deciding whether to open a Pop, it’s essential to understand what drives value in the first place. Unlike mass-market toys, Funko Pops are judged not only by brand popularity but also by production details that affect scarcity and desirability.

• Limited Editions: Released in small batches, often exclusive to events like San Diego Comic-Con or retailer promotions.
• Chase Variants: Rare color or design variations inserted randomly into standard production runs (e.g., metallic finishes, glow-in-the-dark versions).
• Discontinued Lines: Characters from canceled series or retired franchises gain value when no new stock is produced.
• Condition: Mint-in-box (MIB) items command higher prices, especially if the box shows no creases, dents, or shelf wear.
• Demand: A figure of a beloved character from a trending show may spike in value regardless of rarity.

When these factors align, even common-looking Pops can become valuable. But once removed from the box, many lose their premium status—particularly if the goal is investment rather than enjoyment.

Tip: Always check the Funko database or fan forums before opening a new Pop—you might unknowingly own a rare variant.

In Box vs Out of Box: The Resale Value Breakdown

At the heart of the debate is a fundamental split between two types of collectors: investors and enthusiasts. Their priorities differ, and so do their approaches to unboxing.

Mint-in-Box (MIB) figures are generally considered the gold standard for resale. On platforms like eBay, Mercari, and specialized collector marketplaces, MIB listings consistently sell for higher multiples than opened ones—even when the figure itself appears flawless.

Consider this example: a Funko Pop! San Diego Comic-Con Exclusive Batman Beyond released in 2018. In mint-in-box condition, it regularly sells for $350–$450. The same figure, opened and displayed with care, typically fetches $120–$175. That’s a difference of over 60% in potential value.

Condition Type	Avg. Resale Premium	Market Demand	Storage Needs
Mint-in-Box (Sealed)	High (50–200%+)	Very High	Requires protective casing, low light
Opened, Displayed Well	Low to Moderate	Moderate	Dust-free shelf, away from sunlight
Box Damaged / Crushed	Negative Impact	Low	Less critical

This disparity exists because unopened boxes serve as proof of authenticity and preservation. Once opened, there’s no guarantee the figure hasn’t been altered, repaired, or exposed to damage—even minor scuffing around the base can reduce perceived value.

“From a grading standpoint, original packaging is part of the item. It’s not just protection—it’s documentation of provenance.” — David Lin, Collectibles Appraiser & Founder of PopGrade

When Opening Might Make Sense

Despite the resale penalty, many collectors choose to open their Pops—and they’re not wrong. For some, collecting is about joy, not profit. Displaying your favorite characters brings daily satisfaction that outweighs future earnings.

There are also strategic reasons to remove a Pop from its box:

• Protecting the Figure: Some boxes yellow over time due to plastic windows reacting with UV light. Removing the figure prevents fading or discoloration caused by prolonged exposure.
• Preventing Damage Inside Box: Poorly packed Pops can shift during shipping, causing scratches or broken parts while still sealed. Early inspection allows prompt replacement requests.
• Custom Display Projects: Enthusiasts building themed dioramas or LED-lit shelves often need figures free of cardboard constraints.
• Testing Quality Control: Funko has faced criticism for inconsistent paint apps and fragile stands. Opening lets you assess build quality immediately.

One collector, Maria Tran from Portland, shared her experience: “I bought three chase variants of the Mandalorian Grogu (Yoda Ears) Pop. I kept two sealed for investment, but opened one to display on my desk. Seeing it every day reminds me why I love collecting. Even if it loses resale value, it adds value to my life.”

This mindset reflects a growing trend: hybrid collecting. Savvy fans balance financial prudence with personal enjoyment by selectively opening lower-value pieces while preserving high-potential ones in pristine condition.

Best Practices for Preserving Value (Whether Opened or Sealed)

If you decide to keep a Pop in the box, proper storage is non-negotiable. Similarly, opened figures require maintenance to retain appeal. Follow this checklist to protect your collection:

✅ Preservation Checklist

1. Store boxes upright in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight.
2. Use UV-filtering display cases to prevent yellowing of plastic windows.
3. Avoid temperature fluctuations (e.g., attics or garages).
4. Never stack boxes—they can crush corners or bend flaps.
5. For opened figures, dust weekly with a soft microfiber cloth.
6. Keep away from humid environments to prevent mold or sticker peeling.
7. Photograph each piece upon receipt to document condition for insurance or resale.

For those who open their Pops, consider using acrylic display domes. These create a protective barrier while maintaining visibility, mimicking the \"in-box\" aesthetic without sacrificing access. Some sellers even list opened Pops with domes as a selling point, signaling care and presentation.

Tip: Use acid-free paper inside storage areas to absorb moisture and prevent musty odors in boxed collections.

Step-by-Step Guide: How to Decide Whether to Open Your Funko Pop

Instead of making an emotional impulse, follow this structured approach to evaluate your options:

1. Identify the Pop: Check the number on the bottom and cross-reference it with databases like PopVinyl.com or the Funko Wiki. Look for terms like “exclusive,” “chase,” or “convention release.”
2. Research Recent Sales: Search completed listings on eBay filtered by “sold” items. See what similar Pops have fetched—both opened and sealed.
3. Evaluate Condition: Inspect the box for factory defects, dents, or misaligned windows. A damaged box reduces MIB value regardless of intent.
4. Assess Personal Goals: Are you collecting for fun, decoration, or investment? Be honest about your primary motivation.
5. Make the Decision: If it’s a rare or appreciating Pop, keep it sealed. If it’s common and you’ll enjoy it more displayed, go ahead and open it.
6. Document Everything: Take photos pre- and post-opening. Save receipts and packaging materials in case you later reconsider resale.

This method removes guesswork and ensures your choices align with both logic and passion.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does opening a Funko Pop automatically make it worthless?

No. While most opened Pops sell for less than sealed ones, many still hold value—especially if they're rare, well-maintained, or highly sought after. However, expect a significant discount compared to mint-in-box equivalents.

Can I reseal a Funko Pop to increase resale value?

Resealing is possible using archival tape or custom inserts, but experienced buyers can usually tell the difference. Most collectors and resellers view resealed boxes skeptically, and doing so may hurt credibility. Authenticity matters more than appearance.

Are there any Pops that are better off opened?

Yes. Some early releases had poor packaging that traps moisture or causes vinyl fogging. Others, like large-scale or glow-in-the-dark variants, are designed for display. Additionally, damaged boxes may justify removal to preserve the figure itself.

Final Thoughts: Balancing Joy and Investment

The decision to open a Funko Pop ultimately comes down to purpose. If your aim is maximum resale value, keeping figures sealed in optimal condition is the clear path. Rarity compounds over time, and original packaging serves as a certificate of untouched history.

But collecting shouldn’t be purely transactional. Many fans started with a single Pop inspired by a favorite movie or game. That emotional connection is valid—and sometimes more enduring than profit. There’s no shame in choosing enjoyment over equity.

The smartest collectors do both: they curate a portion of their collection for long-term growth while freeing other pieces to bring daily delight. By researching each purchase, storing carefully, and documenting thoroughly, you maintain flexibility—whether you decide to keep it in the box or set it free.

💬 What’s your stance—collector or exhibitor? Share your story or tips in the comments below. Let’s build a community where passion and knowledge grow together.