Types of Guitar Effect Circuits
Guitar effect circuits are essential tools for shaping tone, adding texture, and expanding sonic possibilities. Whether used in pedals, amps, or multi-effects units, these circuits manipulate the guitar's electrical signal in unique ways to create everything from subtle coloration to dramatic sonic transformations. Understanding the different circuit types helps musicians choose gear that matches their tonal goals and playing style.
Analog Effects Circuits
These circuits process the guitar signal using purely analog components such as transistors, diodes, capacitors, and resistors. The signal remains in continuous electrical form throughout the processing chain, preserving the natural dynamics and harmonic richness of the original tone.
Advantages
- Warm, organic, and responsive tone
- Smooth, natural-sounding signal transitions
- High dynamic sensitivity to playing nuances
- Timeless appeal with vintage character
Limitations
- Limited preset storage capability
- Less consistency across units due to component variance
- Fewer complex modulation or time-based effects
- More susceptible to noise and signal degradation
Best for: Blues, rock, jazz, and genres valuing tonal authenticity and dynamic expression
Digital Effects Circuits
Digital circuits convert the incoming analog guitar signal into binary data using an analog-to-digital converter (ADC). This allows for precise algorithmic processing, enabling complex effects like multi-tap delays, pitch shifting, reverb modeling, and amp simulations. The processed signal is then converted back to analog for output.
Advantages
- High precision and consistency in effect parameters
- Ability to store and recall multiple presets
- Wide range of complex and customizable effects
- Superior signal-to-noise ratio and stability
Limitations
- Can sound "cold" or sterile compared to analog
- Potential latency in signal processing
- Less dynamic interaction with playing style
- Higher power consumption and complexity
Best for: Modern rock, metal, electronic, and studio environments requiring versatility and repeatability
Proprietary Effects Circuits
Developed by specific manufacturers, these circuits are engineered to deliver unique tonal signatures or performance features not found in standard designs. Often protected by patents or trade secrets, they form the core identity of premium pedals and processors. For example, Boss’s "Tone Core" or Strymon’s reverb algorithms are proprietary systems designed to outperform generic counterparts.
Advantages
- Distinctive, brand-defining sound characteristics
- Superior performance in targeted effect types
- High build quality and reliability
- Often include innovative control interfaces
Limitations
- Higher cost due to R&D and exclusivity
- Limited compatibility or integration with third-party gear
- Firmware updates may be required for fixes or enhancements
- Can lock users into a specific ecosystem
Best for: Professional musicians seeking signature tones, brand loyalists, and those investing in high-end signal chains
Hybrid Effects Circuits
Hybrid circuits merge analog and digital technologies to leverage the strengths of both. Typically, the signal path uses analog components for core tone shaping (e.g., overdrive or filtering), while digital circuitry handles control functions like preset storage, MIDI integration, or DSP-based modulation. This approach balances warmth with modern convenience.
Advantages
- Warm analog tone with digital flexibility
- Preset memory and recall functionality
- Improved tuning stability and parameter accuracy
- Ideal for gigging musicians needing consistency
Limitations
- More complex design increases potential failure points
- Higher cost than pure analog units
- Tonal character may still lean digital depending on design
- Requires power supply with stable voltage
Best for: Touring artists, session players, and hobbyists wanting both vintage tone and modern features
| Type | Tonal Quality | Versatility | Preset Support | Best Use Case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Analog | Warm, Organic | Moderate | Limited/None | Vintage tone seekers, dynamic players |
| Digital | Precise, Clean | High | Extensive | Studio work, complex sound design |
| Proprietary | Unique, Branded | Varies | Yes (often advanced) | Signature tones, professional use |
| Hybrid | Balanced, Flexible | High | Yes (common) | Live performance, tone + convenience |
Expert Tip: When building a pedalboard, consider mixing analog and digital/hybrid pedals—use analog for core tone (overdrive, compression) and digital for time-based effects (delay, reverb) to achieve the best balance of warmth and functionality.
Industry Trends of Guitar Effect Circuits
The guitar effect circuit market has evolved into a dynamic and technologically driven space, shaped by innovations in digital processing, shifting consumer expectations, and growing environmental awareness. Musicians today demand more from their gear—not only in terms of sonic versatility but also reliability, portability, and sustainability. Below is a comprehensive overview of the most influential trends currently shaping the future of guitar effects.
Integration with Multi-Effects Systems
Consolidation of Effects in One Unit
Modern guitarists are increasingly favoring multi-effects pedals that integrate a wide range of sound-shaping tools into a single compact unit. These systems combine classic analog-inspired circuits with advanced digital algorithms to offer effects such as reverb, delay, chorus, phaser, distortion, overdrive, compression, and pitch shifting—all within one device.
This consolidation reduces the need for large pedalboards, making it easier for musicians to travel, set up quickly, and manage power and cabling. Brands like Boss, Line 6, and Zoom have led this trend with highly programmable units that simulate not only effects but also amplifier and cabinet tones.
Space and Workflow Efficiency
For gigging musicians and studio producers alike, space efficiency is a major advantage. Instead of managing dozens of individual pedals, artists can now access hundreds of preset combinations through intuitive interfaces or mobile apps.
Multi-effects units often feature footswitch banks, expression pedal inputs, and MIDI connectivity, enabling seamless integration into complex live rigs. This shift reflects a broader industry movement toward streamlined, all-in-one solutions without sacrificing tonal depth or flexibility.
Increased Demand for Customization and Programmability
User-Defined Sound Design
Guitarists are no longer satisfied with static, one-size-fits-all tones. There is a growing demand for effects circuits that allow deep customization of parameters such as decay time, modulation rate, feedback levels, filter cutoff, and drive characteristics.
High-end pedals now feature high-resolution encoders, OLED displays, and onboard editing software, empowering users to sculpt unique sounds tailored to specific genres or performance contexts. This level of control is especially valuable for session players and touring artists who need precise tonal consistency across sets.
Preset Management and Recall
Programmable presets have become a standard expectation. Modern effects processors allow users to save, organize, and recall entire signal chains with the press of a button. Some units support scene-based switching, where changing a single preset alters multiple effects simultaneously—ideal for transitioning between song sections.
Integration with DAWs (Digital Audio Workstations) and wireless editing via Bluetooth or USB further enhances usability, allowing real-time tweaking during recording or rehearsal. This programmability bridges the gap between analog warmth and digital precision.
Rise of Digital Technologies and Hybrid Circuits
Digital Signal Processing (DSP) Advancements
Advances in DSP technology have revolutionized guitar effects, enabling ultra-low latency processing, high-fidelity modeling, and complex algorithmic effects like granular delay, spectral filtering, and artificial intelligence-driven tone matching.
Units like the Neural DSP Quad Cortex and HeadRush PX-5 use powerful processors to emulate not just effects but entire amplifier setups with remarkable accuracy. These digital platforms offer near-infinite sonic possibilities, rivaling—and sometimes surpassing—traditional analog gear in both versatility and consistency.
Hybrid Analog-Digital Designs
Recognizing the enduring appeal of analog warmth, many manufacturers are adopting hybrid approaches. These circuits use analog components for input/output stages and tone shaping while leveraging digital processing for effect generation and routing.
This fusion preserves the tactile feel and organic response of analog gear while benefiting from the flexibility and recallability of digital systems. Examples include Strymon’s multi-effects pedals and Empress Effects’ modular designs, which blend both worlds to satisfy purists and innovators alike.
Sustainability and Eco-Conscious Manufacturing
| Trend | Key Drivers | Leading Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Multi-Effects Integration | Portability, cost-efficiency, live performance needs | Boss GT-1000, Line 6 Helix, Zoom G3Xn |
| Customization & Programmability | Personal expression, genre diversity, studio precision | Strymon Timeline, Eventide H9, TC Electronic Ditto+ X4 |
| Digital & Hybrid Technologies | Signal fidelity, modeling accuracy, feature richness | Neural DSP Quad Cortex, HeadRush FX, Empress Zoia |
| Sustainability Initiatives | Consumer demand, regulatory trends, brand reputation | Catalinbread (eco-housings), EarthQuaker Devices (green packaging), Walrus Audio (repair programs) |
Important: While digital and multi-functional systems dominate current trends, the analog vs. digital debate remains subjective. Musicians should evaluate gear based on personal tone preferences, performance requirements, and long-term usability. Additionally, investing in sustainable and repairable products not only supports environmental responsibility but also offers better value over time.
Commercial Value and Uses of Guitar Effect Circuits
The global guitar effects circuit market represents a dynamic and growing segment of the music technology industry, serving diverse business interests while fulfilling essential creative needs for musicians worldwide. Valued at over $1.5 billion and projected to grow steadily, this market thrives on innovation, brand loyalty, and the universal desire for sonic expression. From boutique pedal builders to multinational manufacturers, guitar effect circuits create economic opportunities across the supply chain—from component sourcing and manufacturing to distribution, retail, and digital content creation.
Commercial Value of Guitar Effects Circuits
The commercial significance of guitar effect circuits stems from sustained global demand driven by evolving musical trends, technological advancements, and a passionate user base. As artists and producers seek unique tones, manufacturers respond with innovative analog and digital solutions, fueling continuous product development and market expansion.
- The market includes mass-produced units and high-end boutique pedals, allowing for tiered pricing strategies and premium branding
- Patented circuit designs and signature artist collaborations enhance brand value and justify higher price points
- Modular and programmable effects (e.g., multi-effects processors) offer scalability and long-term customer engagement
- Global supply chains enable cost-effective production while niche hand-wired pedals command luxury pricing
Key insight: The emotional and creative connection users have with tone drives willingness to pay premium prices, increasing overall market value.
Market for Music Professionals and Amateurs
Guitar effect circuits serve a broad demographic—from touring professionals and studio engineers to weekend hobbyists and beginner guitarists. Their accessibility and ease of use make them indispensable tools for shaping sound across skill levels and musical genres.
- Professional musicians rely on effects for signature tones in live performances and recordings (e.g., Jimi Hendrix’s use of fuzz, David Gilmour’s delay textures)
- Home studio producers use digital modeling and pedal emulations to achieve studio-grade effects affordably
- Beginners benefit from compact multi-effects units that offer dozens of sounds in one device, lowering entry barriers
- YouTube creators and social media musicians use unique pedal combinations to differentiate their content
Trend note: The rise of “pedalboard culture” has turned effects into both functional tools and collectible items.
Sales and Profit Margins for Manufacturers
Manufacturers of guitar effect circuits enjoy strong profit margins due to low production costs relative to retail pricing, especially in the boutique and mid-tier segments. The perceived value of tone and brand heritage allows companies to maintain pricing power.
- Boutique pedal makers often achieve 60–80% gross margins on hand-built units priced at $150–$300+
- Larger brands (e.g., Boss, TC Electronic) benefit from economies of scale and global distribution networks
- Software-based effects (plugins, modelers) offer near-zero marginal costs and recurring revenue through updates and subscriptions
- Strategic partnerships with artists generate buzz and drive sales without direct inventory risk
Business advantage: Limited edition runs and serialized units create scarcity, boosting demand and resale value.
Commercial Use in Performance and Recording
Guitar effect circuits are foundational in shaping the sonic identity of modern music. In both live and studio environments, they allow artists to craft distinctive sounds that define genres and elevate performances.
- Reverb and delay circuits add spatial depth, making guitar parts more immersive in mix
- Distortion, overdrive, and fuzz pedals are essential for rock, metal, and alternative genres, providing aggressive tonal textures
- Modulation effects (chorus, phaser, flanger) enhance tonal complexity and movement in solos and rhythm parts
- Studio engineers use analog pedals to impart warmth and character that digital processing alone cannot replicate
Pro insight: Many hit records feature iconic pedal tones—such as the Big Muff on “Smells Like Teen Spirit”—demonstrating their lasting commercial and artistic impact.
Enhancing Retail and eCommerce Businesses
Guitar effect circuits are a high-margin category that drives traffic and repeat business for both physical and online music retailers. Their visual appeal, brand diversity, and frequent new releases make them ideal for marketing and customer engagement.
- Specialty music stores curate pedal selections to appeal to local musicians, often hosting demo events and artist signings
- eCommerce platforms use video demos, customer reviews, and comparison tools to boost conversion rates
- Bundling pedals with cables, power supplies, and cases increases average order value
- Subscription boxes and “pedal of the month” clubs create recurring revenue and community engagement
Retail strategy: Featuring user-generated content (e.g., customer pedalboard photos) builds trust and encourages purchases.
Integration with Broader Music Ecosystem
Beyond standalone sales, guitar effect circuits are integrated into larger product ecosystems, amplifying their commercial reach and utility.
- Instrument manufacturers bundle effects with guitars or amps (e.g., Fender Mustang GT series with built-in effects)
- DAWs and audio interfaces include pedal simulation software to attract guitarists
- Mobile apps and Bluetooth pedals allow silent practice and direct recording, appealing to urban musicians
- Online learning platforms incorporate effects into lesson content, driving demand for specific pedals
Emerging trend: Smart pedals with app control and firmware updates extend product lifecycles and customer relationships.
Strategic Recommendation: Businesses should emphasize the emotional and creative value of guitar effects—not just technical specs. Highlighting artist endorsements, genre applications, and real-world tone examples helps customers connect with products on a deeper level, increasing conversion and brand loyalty. For retailers, offering pedalboard design services or tone clinics can differentiate offerings in a competitive market.
| Market Segment | Key Products | Average Price Range | Primary Sales Channels |
|---|---|---|---|
| Professional Musicians | Boutique analog pedals, multi-effects processors | $200–$600 | Specialty stores, direct online, artist dealers |
| Amateur Enthusiasts | Entry-level multi-effects, compact pedals | $50–$150 | Online retailers, big-box music stores |
| Home Studio Users | Pedal emulations, USB effects, modeling units | $100–$400 | Digital marketplaces, plugin stores, music tech sites |
| Beginners | Starter kits, practice amps with effects | $30–$100 | Retail chains, online marketplaces, educational suppliers |
Additional Commercial Considerations
- Brand Loyalty: Musicians often develop strong attachments to specific pedal brands (e.g., Boss, Electro-Harmonix, Strymon), leading to repeat purchases and word-of-mouth marketing
- Innovation Cycles: Regular product updates and limited editions keep the market dynamic and encourage upgrades
- Sustainability: Rechargeable and energy-efficient pedals appeal to eco-conscious consumers and reduce long-term costs
- Global Reach: Online sales and international shipping allow even small manufacturers to access global markets
- Educational Partnerships: Collaborations with music schools and content creators expand market penetration and brand awareness
How to Choose Guitar Effect Circuits for Resale
Selecting the right guitar effect circuits for resale is a strategic decision that directly impacts customer satisfaction, brand reputation, and profitability. Whether you're supplying music retailers, online stores, or boutique gear shops, understanding the nuances of guitar effects is essential. This comprehensive guide outlines the key factors businesses should evaluate when sourcing guitar effect circuits to ensure they meet market demand and deliver consistent quality.
Important Note: Guitar effects are not just technical components—they shape a musician’s sound and creative expression. Choosing the right circuits means aligning technical performance with artistic needs, making informed decisions critical for long-term business success.
1. Functionality: Matching Effects to Musical Styles
The primary function of a guitar effect circuit determines its appeal to different types of musicians. Understanding the musical genres your target customers engage in will help you select the most in-demand effects.
- Distortion/Overdrive: Ideal for rock, metal, and blues players seeking aggressive tones. These circuits clip the signal to create harmonic richness and sustain.
- Modulation Effects: Includes chorus, flanger, phaser, and tremolo—popular among indie, funk, and ambient artists for adding movement and depth to clean or distorted tones.
- Time-Based Effects: Reverb and delay circuits are essential for creating space and atmosphere, widely used across genres from country to shoegaze.
- Pitch and Filter Effects: Octavers, pitch shifters, and wah-wah pedals cater to experimental and lead guitarists looking for dynamic tonal control.
Tip: Offer a balanced inventory that includes both classic staples (like overdrive) and niche effects (like ring modulators) to serve a broad customer base.
2. Circuit Type: Analog, Digital, or Hybrid?
The technology behind the circuit significantly influences tone, flexibility, and user experience. Each type has distinct advantages and appeals to different segments of guitarists.
| Circuit Type | Sound Characteristics | Key Advantages | Ideal For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Analog | Warm, organic, natural compression | Simple interface, responsive to playing dynamics | Traditionalists, tube amp users, vintage tone seekers |
| Digital | Precise, consistent, highly customizable | Multiple effects in one unit, programmable presets, compact size | Session musicians, touring artists, tech-savvy players |
| Hybrid | Best of both worlds—warmth with digital control | Retains analog signal path with digital switching/memory | Musicians wanting versatility without sacrificing tone |
Consider stocking a mix of types to cater to diverse preferences. Digital circuits are increasingly popular due to their versatility, while analog remains a favorite for purists.
3. Quality and Reliability: Building Trust Through Durability
In the world of guitar effects, reliability is non-negotiable. Musicians depend on their gear during live performances and recordings, so failures can lead to negative reviews and lost customers.
- Source from manufacturers with a proven track record of quality control and consistent build standards.
- Look for circuits built with high-grade components such as metal enclosures, true-bypass switching, and robust jacks.
- Favor brands that offer warranties (typically 1–5 years), as this reflects confidence in product longevity.
- Check for certifications like RoHS compliance or CE marking, which indicate adherence to international safety and environmental standards.
Expert Tip: Request sample units before bulk ordering. Test them under real-world conditions—connect to amplifiers, use with different guitars, and simulate stage use—to evaluate noise levels, signal integrity, and durability.
4. Price Point and Profitability Strategy
Pricing directly affects both market positioning and profit margins. A well-balanced pricing strategy considers customer expectations and business goals.
- Budget Range ($20–$60): Appeals to beginners and hobbyists. Higher margins possible, but quality may vary. Ideal for volume sales.
- Mid-Tier ($60–$150): The sweet spot for most players. Offers solid quality with reasonable margins. Strong demand in this segment.
- Premium ($150+): Targets professionals and collectors. Lower turnover but enhances brand prestige. Often includes boutique or hand-wired circuits.
Recommendation: Build a tiered inventory that includes entry-level, mid-range, and premium options to capture multiple market segments. Avoid over-reliance on ultra-cheap circuits, as poor performance can damage your reputation.
5. Customer Reviews and Market Feedback
Real-world user experiences are invaluable when evaluating guitar effect circuits. Reviews provide insights into performance, durability, and common issues not evident from specifications alone.
- Analyze feedback on platforms like Reverb, Sweetwater, Thomann, and Amazon to identify recurring praises or complaints.
- Look for patterns—frequent mentions of "noisy at high gain" or "switch fails after 6 months" are red flags.
- Pay attention to how manufacturers respond to negative reviews. Proactive customer support indicates a reliable brand.
- Consider partnering with influencers or music educators for hands-on reviews before committing to large orders.
Pro Tip: Create a simple scoring system (e.g., 1–5 stars) based on functionality, build quality, sound, and value to objectively compare different models.
Strategic Insight: Stay ahead of trends by monitoring emerging genres and popular artists. For example, the rise of lo-fi and bedroom pop has increased demand for compact delay and reverb pedals with simple controls.
Final Recommendations for Resellers
- Conduct market research to understand your local or online customer base—age, genre preference, skill level.
- Develop relationships with reputable distributors or manufacturers who offer return policies and marketing support.
- Offer bundles (e.g., overdrive + delay) to increase average order value and help customers get started easily.
- Provide clear product descriptions highlighting key features, tone characteristics, and ideal use cases.
- Stay updated on new technologies, such as MIDI integration, USB connectivity, and app-controlled effects.
By carefully evaluating functionality, circuit type, quality, price, and user feedback, businesses can curate a guitar effects inventory that meets customer needs, builds brand loyalty, and drives sustainable growth. Remember, in the music gear industry, trust and performance go hand in hand—choose wisely to succeed.
Frequently Asked Questions About Guitar Effects Circuits
Guitar effects circuits rely on a combination of electronic components and structural materials, each playing a vital role in performance, durability, and sound quality. The core electronic components include:
- Resistors: Often made from carbon film or metal film, these regulate current flow and are essential for tone shaping and signal control.
- Capacitors: Typically constructed with ceramic, polyester (Mylar), or electrolytic materials, capacitors filter frequencies and store electrical charge, directly influencing tone characteristics such as brightness and bass response.
- Integrated Circuits (ICs): Made primarily from silicon, ICs are the brains of many digital and analog pedals, processing the audio signal to produce effects like reverb, delay, or distortion.
- Potentiometers and Switches: Usually built with conductive plastics or carbon tracks, these allow user control over parameters like volume, tone, and effect intensity.
In addition to internal components, the enclosure is crucial for protection and shielding. Common materials include:
- Aluminum: Lightweight, durable, and excellent at blocking electromagnetic interference (EMI), making it ideal for high-end pedals.
- Steel: Offers robust protection and superior grounding but is heavier than aluminum.
- Plastic: Used in budget-friendly pedals; less durable and offers minimal EMI shielding, but allows for creative designs and lower manufacturing costs.
Together, these materials ensure reliable operation, noise reduction, and long-term resilience against environmental wear and physical impact.
While guitar effect pedals are generally low-maintenance, especially digital models with solid-state components, regular care can significantly extend their lifespan and performance. Here's what to consider:
- Analog Pedals: These benefit from occasional inspection of solder joints and internal wiring, as vibrations and temperature changes can cause cracks or loose connections over time.
- Jack Sockets and Switches: Regular use can lead to dirt buildup or oxidation. Cleaning with contact cleaner every 6–12 months helps maintain reliable signal transfer and prevents crackling sounds.
- Battery Compartment: If your pedal uses batteries, check for corrosion periodically and replace batteries before they leak.
- External Cleaning: Wipe down the enclosure with a soft, dry cloth. Avoid harsh chemicals that could damage labels or finishes.
- Storage: Keep pedals in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and moisture. Using a pedalboard case adds extra protection during transport.
Although the internal circuitry rarely fails under normal conditions, proactive maintenance—especially for vintage or hand-built pedals—can prevent issues before they affect your tone or reliability on stage.
This is one of the most debated topics in the guitar community—and the answer largely depends on personal preference, musical style, and desired tone. Here’s a breakdown of both technologies:
| Feature | Analog Circuits | Digital Circuits |
|---|---|---|
| Tone Quality | Known for warm, organic, and "natural" sound; often described as more dynamic and responsive to playing nuances. | Can emulate analog tones precisely and offer ultra-clean processing; some players find them less "alive" or slightly sterile. |
| Effects Range | Limited to specific circuit designs (e.g., one pedal = one effect type); stacking multiple pedals needed for variety. | Capable of hosting multiple effects in one unit, including complex simulations of vintage gear, amp modeling, and advanced modulation. |
| Customization | Minimal; adjustments are typically limited to knobs on the pedal face. | High; allows deep editing, preset saving, MIDI integration, and firmware updates. |
| Reliability & Maintenance | More susceptible to component aging and environmental factors; simpler to repair for technicians. | Highly stable; less prone to drift or noise over time, though repairs may require specialized knowledge. |
| Cost & Portability | Can become expensive when building a full pedalboard; individual units take up more space. | More cost-effective for multiple effects; compact multi-effects units save space and setup time. |
Ultimately, many musicians use a hybrid setup—combining the warmth of analog pedals with the versatility of digital processors. The best choice depends on your tonal goals, performance needs, and budget.
Yes, the materials used in guitar effect circuits can significantly influence the sound, though not always in obvious or dramatic ways. While the circuit design is the primary factor in tone shaping, component quality and material composition play supporting—but important—roles:
- Capacitor Dielectrics: Different materials (e.g., ceramic, film, tantalum) affect frequency response. For example, polyester (Mylar) caps are known for smooth mids, while polypropylene offers greater clarity and detail.
- Resistor Types: Metal film resistors provide more precise values and lower noise compared to carbon composition, which can add subtle harmonic distortion prized in vintage-style overdrive pedals.
- Circuit Board Quality: Fiberglass (FR4) boards offer better signal integrity and durability than cheaper phenolic boards, which may degrade over time and introduce noise.
- Shielding Materials: Aluminum enclosures or conductive paint inside plastic housings reduce electromagnetic interference, minimizing hum and radio frequency noise.
- Power Supply Components: High-quality diodes, regulators, and filtering capacitors ensure clean power delivery, which is crucial for noise-free operation, especially in sensitive analog circuits.
While a single component may not drastically change the sound, the cumulative effect of using premium materials results in a more transparent, reliable, and consistent signal path. This is why boutique pedal builders often emphasize "component-grade" parts and hand-selected materials to achieve superior tonal performance.
In short, while materials don’t directly "create" the sound, they shape how faithfully and cleanly the circuit reproduces it—making them an essential consideration for discerning players and builders alike.








浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?