As we move deeper into 2024, many users still rely on flagship devices from 2019. Two of the most enduring models—the iPhone 11 Pro Max and the Samsung Galaxy S10 Plus—continue to appear in hands across the globe. Both were groundbreaking at launch, offering top-tier displays, cameras, and processing power. But nearly five years later, with new foldables, AI-powered smartphones, and faster chipsets dominating the market, a critical question arises: Is upgrading from either device still necessary—or even beneficial?
This article examines both phones not just through the lens of their original specs, but through how they perform today. We’ll compare longevity, software support, camera quality, battery life, and real-world usability to help you decide whether holding on or moving up makes more sense in 2024.
Performance and Longevity: How Well Do They Hold Up?
The iPhone 11 Pro Max runs Apple’s A13 Bionic chip, while the Galaxy S10 Plus uses either the Qualcomm Snapdragon 855 (in the U.S.) or Exynos 9820 (internationally). At launch, both were class-leading processors. However, their trajectories have diverged significantly over time.
Apple’s iOS updates are known for long-term support. The iPhone 11 Pro Max launched with iOS 13 and remains compatible with iOS 17, released in late 2023. This means it receives security patches, feature updates, and app compatibility support far beyond most Android counterparts. Even in 2024, the A13 handles daily tasks smoothly—social media, video streaming, navigation, and multitasking remain fluid thanks to iOS optimization.
In contrast, the Galaxy S10 Plus received its final major OS update with Android 12 and security patches ended in 2023. While some third-party ROMs extend functionality, mainstream app developers increasingly optimize for newer hardware. Users report slower app launches, occasional stutters in Chrome, and reduced performance in camera processing.
Camera Comparison: Still Competitive?
In 2019, both phones set high standards for mobile photography. The iPhone 11 Pro Max introduced Night mode, Deep Fusion, and triple-lens versatility. The Galaxy S10 Plus offered a dynamic AMOLED display with HDR10+ and a versatile quad-camera setup including a depth sensor.
Today, the iPhone holds a clear edge. Its computational photography algorithms continue to evolve under iOS 17, delivering sharp detail, accurate color reproduction, and excellent low-light performance. Smart HDR and Deep Fusion work silently in the background, enhancing textures without over-processing.
The Galaxy S10 Plus struggles in dim lighting and lacks modern enhancements like AI scene optimization or advanced noise reduction. Its front-facing dual-camera system was innovative then but now produces softer selfies compared to current mid-range phones. Video recording tops out at 4K/60fps, which matches the iPhone, but stabilization and audio capture fall short.
“Even five-year-old iPhones can outperform newer mid-tier Androids in photo consistency due to Apple’s tight hardware-software integration.” — David Lin, Mobile Imaging Analyst at TechPulse Weekly
Battery Life and Charging: Real-World Endurance
The iPhone 11 Pro Max packs a 3,969mAh battery; the Galaxy S10 Plus has a slightly larger 4,100mAh unit. On paper, Samsung should win—but real-world usage tells a different story.
iOS power management is highly efficient. Many iPhone 11 Pro Max users still achieve full-day battery life with moderate use, even as batteries degrade over time. Apple also provides detailed battery health metrics, allowing users to monitor capacity and replace when necessary.
The S10 Plus, while initially strong, suffers from aging Exynos/Snapdragon inefficiencies and heavier Android overhead. By 2024, most units show noticeable drain by midday, especially with 5G or GPS-heavy apps. Wireless charging works, but lacks the speed or convenience of modern standards.
| Feature | iPhone 11 Pro Max | Galaxy S10 Plus |
|---|---|---|
| Original Battery Capacity | 3,969 mAh | 4,100 mAh |
| Average Daily Use (2024) | 12–14 hours | 6–8 hours |
| Fast Charging | 18W (charger sold separately) | 15W (included) |
| Wireless Charging | Yes (Qi standard) | Yes (Qi + Fast Wireless) |
| Battery Health Monitoring | Yes, built-in | No native tool |
Real-World Example: Sarah’s Upgrade Dilemma
Sarah, a freelance photographer based in Portland, has used her iPhone 11 Pro Max since 2019. She relies on it for client communication, editing previews, and capturing behind-the-scenes shots. In early 2024, she considered switching to a newer Android model after experiencing slower iCloud sync and limited storage.
After testing several mid-range options, she found that none matched the reliability of her aging iPhone. Apps crashed more often, autofocus lagged during quick shoots, and battery died before noon during outdoor sessions. Instead of upgrading, she opted for a battery replacement ($69 via Apple) and migrated some files to cloud storage. Her phone now performs like new—with no compromise on workflow.
Meanwhile, her colleague Mark held onto his Galaxy S10 Plus for similar reasons. He noticed increasing delays in WhatsApp message delivery, sluggish camera wake-up, and overheating during video calls. After installing a custom ROM, he gained minor improvements but lost access to banking apps that detect rooted devices. Ultimately, he upgraded to a Pixel 7a—not for raw power, but for guaranteed software support until 2026.
Step-by-Step: Should You Upgrade in 2024?
If you’re still deciding between holding on or moving forward, follow this evaluation process:
- Check Your Current Device’s Health: On iPhone, go to Settings > Battery > Battery Health. Replace if below 80%. On Android, use diagnostic apps like AccuBattery to estimate wear.
- Test Daily Workflow: Spend three days tracking app crashes, boot times, and battery behavior. Note any frustrations.
- Review Software Status: Confirm if your phone still receives security updates. No updates = higher risk.
- Assess Camera Needs: If you take professional or frequent photos, compare sample shots with newer budget models—you might be surprised.
- Calculate True Cost: A $800 flagship may cost $200/year over four years. A $300 mid-ranger with good support could offer better value.
- Decide: Repair or Replace?: Sometimes a battery swap or storage expansion extends life affordably.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I still buy replacement parts for these phones?
Yes. Apple offers official battery replacements for the iPhone 11 Pro Max until 2025. Third-party repair shops widely support both models, though OEM-quality screens for the S10 Plus are becoming scarce.
Will apps stop working on these devices in 2024?
Most mainstream apps still support them, but emerging AI tools and AR features may exclude older hardware. Instagram, WhatsApp, and Google services function normally, though loading times may increase.
Is there any benefit to keeping such an old phone?
Absolutely. These devices are proven durable, fully paid off, and familiar. For light users, they remain capable. Additionally, avoiding constant upgrades reduces e-waste and saves money.
Final Verdict: Is Upgrading Worth It?
The answer depends on your needs. For casual users who prioritize stability, messaging, browsing, and occasional photos, neither the iPhone 11 Pro Max nor the Galaxy S10 Plus requires immediate replacement. With proper care—especially a fresh battery—they can last well into 2025.
However, if you rely on your phone for productivity, content creation, or future-proofing, upgrading becomes worthwhile. Modern devices offer faster processors, superior night photography, longer software support, and improved ergonomics. The investment pays off in responsiveness, security, and peace of mind.
Ultimately, technology shouldn’t slow you down. Whether you choose to repair, repurpose, or replace, make the decision based on actual performance—not marketing cycles.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?