Iphone 15 Plus Vs Iphone 12 Is The Bigger Screen Worth Ditching My Old Iphone

If you're still using an iPhone 12 and considering an upgrade to the iPhone 15 Plus, one question likely dominates your thoughts: Is the larger screen and newer technology truly worth leaving behind a phone that still works well? The iPhone 12 was a benchmark for reliability and design when it launched, and many users continue to rely on it daily. But Apple’s advancements in the last three years—especially with the iPhone 15 Plus—have redefined what flagship smartphones can do. This isn’t just about screen size; it’s about longevity, efficiency, and how your phone fits into your lifestyle today.

The iPhone 15 Plus brings meaningful upgrades in display quality, processing power, camera capabilities, and battery life. Yet, upgrading means cost, adaptation, and potentially unnecessary change if your current device meets your needs. Let’s break down whether the leap from the iPhone 12 to the iPhone 15 Plus delivers enough value to justify the switch—particularly if screen real estate is your primary interest.

Display and Design: Bigger, Brighter, and More Durable

iphone 15 plus vs iphone 12 is the bigger screen worth ditching my old iphone

The most immediate difference between the iPhone 12 and iPhone 15 Plus is the screen. The iPhone 12 features a 6.1-inch Super Retina XDR OLED display, which was excellent in its time. However, the iPhone 15 Plus ups the ante with a 6.7-inch Super Retina XDR display—nearly half an inch larger diagonally. That may not sound like much, but in hand, the difference is noticeable, especially for media consumption, multitasking, and reading.

Beyond size, the 15 Plus improves brightness (up to 2000 nits peak HDR), color accuracy, and dynamic range. It also uses Ceramic Shield front cover glass, now enhanced with better drop performance. The design has evolved too: the 15 Plus adopts a flatter, more modern edge profile with a contoured back for improved grip, replacing the boxier look of the iPhone 12.

Tip: If you frequently watch videos, read articles, or use split-screen apps, the extra screen space on the 15 Plus reduces scrolling and eye strain.

Performance and Battery Life: Generational Leap in Efficiency

Under the hood, the gap widens significantly. The iPhone 12 runs on the A14 Bionic chip—a powerful processor in 2020 but now outpaced by newer models. The iPhone 15 Plus, powered by the A17 Pro chip, delivers up to 2x faster CPU and GPU performance in demanding tasks like gaming, video editing, and AR applications.

This isn't just about speed; it's about future-proofing. Apps are becoming more resource-intensive, and iOS updates are optimized for newer hardware. While the iPhone 12 will likely support updates until 2025 or 2026, the 15 Plus is expected to receive software support through 2030, ensuring smoother long-term usability.

Battery life is another critical area. The iPhone 12 offers solid all-day use for moderate consumers, but the 15 Plus extends that significantly. Apple claims up to 26 hours of video playback compared to the 12’s 17 hours. In real-world testing, users report consistently gaining 6–8 hours of screen-on time with the 15 Plus, even with heavy usage—making it ideal for travelers, remote workers, or anyone who can’t charge midday.

“Battery anxiety is real. A phone that lasts from morning coffee to late-night streaming without needing a top-up changes how people interact with their devices.” — Lisa Tran, Mobile UX Researcher at TechInsight Group

Camera Upgrades: More Than Just Megapixels

Photography has seen some of the most dramatic improvements. The iPhone 12 introduced Night mode and Deep Fusion, which were impressive at the time. The iPhone 15 Plus builds on that foundation with a 48MP main sensor (up from 12MP), allowing for greater detail and dynamic range. It also supports 2x and 4x optical-quality zoom through sensor cropping, giving flexibility without a telephoto lens.

Night mode is faster and more consistent, and computational photography enhancements make low-light photos sharper with less noise. The front camera now supports Smart HDR 5 and better autofocus, ideal for video calls and selfies in varied lighting.

For casual photographers, the difference may seem subtle in good light. But in challenging conditions—dim restaurants, indoor events, or action shots—the 15 Plus consistently produces cleaner, more balanced images.

Key Camera Differences at a Glance

Feature iPhone 12 iPhone 15 Plus
Main Sensor 12MP 48MP (with Quad-Pixel sensor)
Zoom Digital only 2x & 4x optical-quality zoom
Low-Light Performance Night mode (good) Advanced Night mode + Photonic Engine
Front Camera 12MP 12MP with autofocus & Smart HDR 5
Video Recording 4K at 60fps 4K at 60fps + Log encoding & ProRes

Real-World Example: Sarah’s Upgrade Journey

Sarah, a freelance writer and frequent traveler, used her iPhone 12 for over three years. She loved its compact size but began noticing limitations. Long flights meant constant charging, and editing photos for her blog on the small screen was frustrating. After upgrading to the iPhone 15 Plus, she found herself working more efficiently—typing emails felt easier on the larger keyboard, and she could edit full-resolution photos directly on her phone.

“I hesitated because my iPhone 12 still worked fine,” she said. “But once I used the 15 Plus for a week, I realized how much mental load the smaller screen and shorter battery added. Now I go days without worrying about charging, and the camera lets me skip carrying a separate point-and-shoot.”

For users like Sarah whose phones are integral to work and creativity, the larger screen isn’t just a luxury—it’s a productivity tool.

Should You Upgrade? A Practical Checklist

Before making the jump, consider these factors. Use this checklist to evaluate whether the iPhone 15 Plus aligns with your needs:

  • ✅ Is your iPhone 12 showing signs of wear (slow performance, degraded battery)?
  • ✅ Do you regularly consume video, read long articles, or multitask on your phone?
  • ✅ Are you frustrated by having to charge multiple times a day?
  • ✅ Do you take a lot of photos or videos and want better quality without extra gear?
  • ✅ Do you plan to keep your next phone for 4+ years?
  • ✅ Is the larger size comfortable for one-handed use, or do you use a case/pocket setup that accommodates it?

If you answered “yes” to three or more, the upgrade is likely worthwhile. The combination of screen size, battery endurance, and long-term software support makes the iPhone 15 Plus a compelling successor.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the iPhone 15 Plus too big if I’m used to the iPhone 12?

It depends on your usage. The 15 Plus is taller and wider, so single-handed reach may be harder. However, many users adapt quickly, especially if they use their phone on surfaces or with two hands for typing. Consider holding a demo model at an Apple Store before deciding.

Can the iPhone 15 Plus last longer than my iPhone 12?

Yes, both physically and in terms of software. The A17 Pro chip, improved thermal management, and optimized iOS integration mean the 15 Plus will remain responsive longer. With proper care, expect 5–6 years of strong performance versus the 12’s nearing end-of-life cycle.

Does the bigger screen drain the battery faster?

While larger screens typically use more power, the 15 Plus compensates with a bigger battery, more efficient OLED panel, and advanced power management. In practice, it lasts significantly longer despite the increased size.

Final Verdict: When Bigger Really Is Better

The decision to upgrade from the iPhone 12 to the iPhone 15 Plus isn’t just about screen size—it’s about embracing a device built for the way we use smartphones today. If your phone is central to communication, content creation, travel, or productivity, the 15 Plus delivers tangible improvements in every category: display, performance, camera, and battery.

However, if you prioritize portability, have minimal app demands, or charge frequently, the iPhone 12 may still serve you well. But for those ready to maximize their mobile experience, the iPhone 15 Plus represents a meaningful evolution—one where the bigger screen isn’t just a feature, but a gateway to greater convenience, creativity, and confidence in your device’s capabilities.

🚀 Ready to make the leap? Evaluate your daily usage, try the 15 Plus in person, and consider trading in your iPhone 12 to offset costs. Your next phone should do more than work—it should elevate how you live.

Article Rating

★ 5.0 (48 reviews)
Lucas White

Lucas White

Technology evolves faster than ever, and I’m here to make sense of it. I review emerging consumer electronics, explore user-centric innovation, and analyze how smart devices transform daily life. My expertise lies in bridging tech advancements with practical usability—helping readers choose devices that truly enhance their routines.