The shift from traditional notches to pill-shaped cutouts in modern smartphones has sparked a new era of screen design and interactive functionality. Apple’s iPhone introduced the Dynamic Island with the iPhone 14 Pro series, transforming the dual-camera cutout into an interactive hub. Meanwhile, most high-end Android devices have long featured similar pill-shaped cutouts—often housing a front camera and sometimes sensors—but without the same level of system-wide integration. The question arises: when it comes to multitasking, which implementation offers more practical value?
This isn’t just about aesthetics. It’s about how these cutouts are used beyond merely accommodating hardware. The Dynamic Island represents Apple’s attempt to turn a necessary compromise into an asset, while Android manufacturers largely treat the pill cutout as a passive element. But is Apple’s approach truly superior for multitasking, or are Android users missing out—or perhaps gaining flexibility through alternative means?
Understanding the Design Differences
The fundamental distinction between the two lies in intent. Apple designed the Dynamic Island not just to hide hardware but to serve as a live, interactive interface layer. In contrast, Android’s pill cutout—used by brands like Samsung, Google, OnePlus, and others—is primarily a structural solution to fit larger selfie cameras or under-display sensors.
On iPhones, the Dynamic Island sits at the top center of the display and dynamically expands and contracts based on ongoing activities such as music playback, timers, navigation, Face ID authentication, and incoming calls. It supports light touch interaction, allowing users to swipe up to open full apps or peek at mini-controls.
Android equivalents, however, remain mostly static. Some manufacturers offer minimal visual feedback—like Samsung’s subtle pulse animation during recording—but none integrate the cutout into core OS functionality in the way Apple does. The space above the cutout is typically reserved for status icons (Wi-Fi, battery, etc.), and no major Android OEM has replicated the concept of an animated, responsive pill that morphs with app activity.
Multitasking Capabilities: A Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Multitasking goes beyond split-screen modes. It includes background task awareness, quick access to controls, and seamless transitions between apps. Here's how each platform performs in key areas:
Live Activity Integration
Dynamic Island leverages iOS 16+’s Live Activities framework, allowing supported apps to display real-time updates directly in the pill zone. For example, while riding a Lyft, the Dynamic Island shows driver location, ETA, and license plate. During a sports game, fans can track scores without leaving their current app.
These live tiles persist across the Home screen and even during other full-screen activities, offering glanceable information with minimal disruption. Swiping up reveals more detail or redirects to the relevant app.
Android lacks a unified equivalent. While some apps use persistent notifications or floating bubbles, these appear in the notification shade or as overlays—not integrated into the display cutout. This makes them less immersive and often more intrusive.
Audio and Call Management
When switching between audio sources—say, pausing a podcast to take a phone call—the Dynamic Island visually merges both actions. Users see both the call and the paused media, then easily resume playback post-call with a tap.
On Android, this transition occurs silently in the background unless the user pulls down the notification panel. There’s no visual continuity at the cutout level, making it easier to forget what was playing or miss quick controls.
Concurrent Task Visibility
One of Dynamic Island’s strongest multitasking features is its ability to show two processes simultaneously. For instance, recording a voice memo while accepting an incoming FaceTime call results in both activities being visible in the pill. Users can toggle between them with simple gestures.
Android systems may run both tasks, but there’s no dedicated UI element acknowledging both at once in the cutout area. The experience relies heavily on memory and manual navigation rather than contextual awareness.
“Dynamic Island turns passive screen space into an active command center. It’s the first time a cutout feels purposeful rather than tolerated.” — Lisa Tran, UX Designer at Mobile Futures Lab
Comparison Table: Functionality at a Glance
| Feature | iPhone Dynamic Island | Android Pill Cutout |
|---|---|---|
| Interactive Animations | Yes – expands, contracts, reacts to touch | No – static cutout |
| Live Activity Support | Yes – sports, deliveries, rides, timers | Limited – via notifications only |
| Audio Task Switching | Visual merging of media and calls | Handled via notification drawer |
| Background Process Visibility | Real-time, glanceable | Requires user to check notifications |
| Third-Party App Integration | Growing support (e.g., Uber, Spotify) | None specific to cutout |
| Customization Options | Minimal – controlled by OS | Varies by OEM; some allow hiding cutout indicators |
Real-World Example: The Commuter’s Workflow
Consider Maria, a busy urban professional who commutes daily using public transit. She listens to a podcast, receives a calendar alert for a meeting, starts a timer for her walk to the office, and gets a message from a colleague—all within five minutes.
On her iPhone 15 Pro, the Dynamic Island seamlessly cycles through these events. First, it shows the podcast. Then, the calendar alert appears as a temporary overlay. When she starts the timer, it replaces the audio indicator momentarily before shrinking to coexist alongside it. All are accessible with a glance and a swipe.
If Maria used a Galaxy S24 with a similar pill cutout, none of these interactions would be reflected in the cutout area. Her podcast shows in the status bar, the timer runs silently in the background, and the calendar alert disappears after a few seconds unless she checks her lock screen. To manage all three, she’d need to open multiple apps or rely on memory.
In this scenario, the Dynamic Island reduces cognitive load and enhances efficiency—core components of effective multitasking.
Limitations and Trade-Offs
Despite its advantages, the Dynamic Island isn’t flawless. Its functionality is tightly bound to Apple’s ecosystem and software constraints. Only apps that adopt the Live Activities API can fully utilize it, limiting third-party reach. As of now, many popular apps still lack integration.
Additionally, the feature works best when only one or two activities are running. Overloading it—such as having multiple timers, downloads, and calls—can make the animations confusing or unresponsive. Some users report difficulty distinguishing between overlapping alerts.
On the Android side, the absence of a dynamic cutout doesn’t mean poor multitasking overall. Android excels in other areas: split-screen mode, floating windows, drag-and-drop between apps, and deeper customization. Power users often leverage these tools more than they would a visual indicator in the notch.
Moreover, Android’s open nature allows developers to experiment. Apps like Niagara Launcher or KWGT let users create custom overlays near the cutout, simulating some of Dynamic Island’s glanceability. However, these require setup and aren’t system-level features.
Step-by-Step: Maximizing Multitasking on Each Platform
To get the most out of either system, follow these optimized workflows:
- On iPhone with Dynamic Island:
- Ensure Background App Refresh is enabled for frequently used apps.
- Use Siri shortcuts to trigger Live Activities (e.g., “Start workout”).
- Swipe up from the Dynamic Island to expand and control active tasks.
- Long-press on the Island to switch between concurrent activities.
- Keep iOS updated to ensure latest Live Activity compatibility.
- On Android with Pill Cutout:
- Enable Floating Notifications or Bubbles for messaging apps.
- Use Quick Panel toggles to monitor recordings or downloads.
- Install a lightweight overlay widget app for persistent timers.
- Utilize split-screen mode for true parallel tasking.
- Customize Always-On Display to show media or calendar info.
Expert Insight: Is This the Future of UI?
Industry analysts suggest that Apple may be ahead of the curve in reimagining screen real estate. “The Dynamic Island is a prototype of contextual UI,” says Raj Mehta, mobile strategist at TechTrend Insights. “Instead of burying notifications in layers, it brings critical info to the surface—literally.”
He adds, “Android’s strength has always been flexibility, but in this case, fragmentation works against innovation. Without a unified developer standard for cutout interaction, OEMs hesitate to invest.”
Still, some argue that Apple’s approach is gimmicky. “It’s clever, but how often do you need to see your timer in the notch?” questions Lin Zhao, an Android developer. “Most multitasking happens in the app layer, not the status bar.”
Yet, for frequent users of timers, music, navigation, and ride-sharing apps, that small strip of interactive UI proves surprisingly valuable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can Android replicate Dynamic Island functionality?
Not natively. While third-party apps can mimic some behaviors using overlays or widgets, no Android OEM currently offers a system-wide, animated cutout interface like Dynamic Island. Samsung has patented similar concepts, but none have shipped in production devices.
Does Dynamic Island drain the battery faster?
Minimal impact. The animations are GPU-optimized and only active during live tasks. Since they replace full app switches in many cases, they may even improve efficiency by reducing screen-on time.
Do all iPhone models have Dynamic Island?
No. Only iPhone 14 Pro, 15 Pro, and future Pro models include Dynamic Island. Standard iPhones retain the older notch design.
Conclusion: Which Offers More Useful Multitasking?
When evaluated purely on multitasking utility, the iPhone’s Dynamic Island currently holds a clear advantage. It transforms a fixed hardware element into a responsive, intelligent interface layer that enhances awareness, reduces app-switching, and supports real-time interactions. No Android device today matches this level of integration.
However, Android counters with broader multitasking tools outside the cutout—split screens, floating apps, and customizable interfaces—that cater to different styles of productivity. For users who prioritize direct control over visual cues, Android remains powerful.
The truth is, Dynamic Island isn’t essential—but it’s useful. It exemplifies Apple’s philosophy of refining existing elements into smarter experiences. Android, meanwhile, offers raw capability but leaves the organization to the user.
As app developers increasingly adopt live activity frameworks and users demand more intuitive interfaces, expect pressure to grow on Android OEMs to innovate beyond passive cutouts. Until then, if glanceable, frictionless multitasking matters to you, the Dynamic Island sets a benchmark that the rest of the industry has yet to meet.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?