Iphone X Or Iphone 8 Plus Does Screen Size Really Matter For Daily Use

When Apple released both the iPhone X and iPhone 8 Plus in 2017, they offered two very different visions of what a flagship smartphone could be. The iPhone X introduced a radical redesign with an edge-to-edge OLED display and Face ID, while the iPhone 8 Plus stuck to the familiar Touch ID home button and LCD screen—but packed serious power under the hood. One of the most debated differences between them? Screen size and how it impacts daily usability.

At first glance, the numbers suggest a clear winner: the iPhone 8 Plus has a 5.5-inch display compared to the iPhone X’s 5.8 inches. But is that extra screen real estate actually useful in everyday tasks like browsing, messaging, or media consumption? Or does the iPhone X’s taller, more compact design offer better ergonomics despite the similar diagonal measurement? Let’s explore what screen size truly means when held in hand and used over hours each day.

Understanding the Display Differences

The iPhone 8 Plus features a traditional 16:9 aspect ratio with a 5.5-inch Retina HD LCD screen. In contrast, the iPhone X uses a 5.8-inch Super Retina OLED display with an 19.5:9 aspect ratio. While the X has a larger diagonal measurement, its taller, narrower form changes how content is displayed and interacted with.

This shift in design philosophy affects everything from app layout to one-handed usability. The iPhone X’s screen extends further vertically, allowing more content to appear on-screen at once—especially helpful in social media feeds or web browsing. However, because of the notch and curved edges, usable width is slightly less than the 8 Plus, making some interface elements feel more cramped despite the higher resolution.

Tip: When comparing screen sizes, always consider aspect ratio and usable space—not just diagonal inches.

Real-World Usability: How Size Impacts Daily Tasks

Screen size isn’t just about watching videos or playing games; it influences how efficiently you can type, scroll, and multitask. For users who frequently consume long-form content—like articles, emails, or e-books—the iPhone X’s taller display shows approximately 20% more text than the 8 Plus without increasing device width.

However, physical comfort plays a major role. The iPhone 8 Plus is wider and heavier (203g vs 174g), making it harder to operate with one hand. Many users report fatigue after extended use, especially when holding the phone near the bottom and reaching across the screen to tap navigation buttons. The iPhone X, though slightly taller, fits more comfortably in smaller hands due to its slimmer profile and improved weight distribution.

“Ergonomics often outweigh raw specs when it comes to daily satisfaction. A slightly smaller but better-proportioned screen can enhance usability more than pure size.” — David Lin, Mobile UX Designer at TechInterface Labs

Side-by-Side Comparison: iPhone X vs iPhone 8 Plus

Feature	iPhone X	iPhone 8 Plus
Screen Size	5.8 inches	5.5 inches
Display Type	OLED (Super Retina)	LCD (Retina HD)
Resolution	2436 x 1125 pixels	1920 x 1080 pixels
Aspect Ratio	19.5:9	16:9
Pixel Density	458 ppi	401 ppi
Weight	174 grams	203 grams
One-Handed Use	Easier due to narrower width	Challenging for average hand sizes
Brightness & Contrast	Higher contrast, deeper blacks	Good brightness, lower contrast

A Day in the Life: Mini Case Study

Sarah, a freelance journalist and frequent commuter, used the iPhone 8 Plus for nearly two years before upgrading to the iPhone X. She initially hesitated, believing the smaller footprint would reduce her reading and writing efficiency. After switching, however, she noticed immediate improvements.

During her morning train ride, she found herself scrolling through news apps more comfortably, with less thumb strain. The taller screen allowed her to read longer paragraphs without constant swiping. Typing on the virtual keyboard felt more natural, as she could rest the phone securely in one hand while using her thumb on either side of the central home indicator.

Even though the 8 Plus had a wide screen ideal for landscape video, Sarah admitted she rarely used that orientation outside of occasional YouTube sessions. For her core activities—email, research, note-taking, and social media—the iPhone X proved more efficient despite having only a marginally larger screen.

Tip: If you rely heavily on one-handed operation, prioritize device width and weight over screen size alone.

Does Bigger Always Mean Better?

Not necessarily. While a larger screen offers advantages in media viewing and split-screen functionality, it also introduces trade-offs. The iPhone 8 Plus may have more horizontal space, but its bulk makes pocketability and grip less convenient. Over time, these small inconveniences accumulate, affecting how likely you are to pull out your phone for quick checks or prolonged use.

Moreover, software optimization matters. iOS adapts well to the iPhone X’s unique display, utilizing the full height for notifications, Control Center, and multitasking gestures. Apps redesigned for the X take advantage of the immersive screen, minimizing black bars and maximizing visual impact.

In contrast, the 8 Plus runs the same software but within a constrained aspect ratio. Some newer apps display letterboxing or awkward scaling, reducing the benefit of its large screen. As developers focus increasingly on modern iPhone formats, older designs like the 8 Plus gradually lose relevance in practical usability.

Actionable Checklist: Choosing Based on Your Needs

• Evaluate your primary usage: Do you watch a lot of videos, or do you mostly browse and message?
• Test one-handed reach: Can you comfortably tap the top corners without shifting your grip?
• Consider portability: Will the phone fit easily in your pocket or bag?
• Assess visual quality: Prefer vibrant colors and deep blacks (OLED) or consistent brightness (LCD)?
• Think long-term: Is the device optimized for current and future iOS features?

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the iPhone X screen actually bigger than the iPhone 8 Plus?

Yes, the iPhone X has a 5.8-inch display versus the 8 Plus’s 5.5 inches. However, due to the taller aspect ratio and notch, the viewing area feels differently proportioned—more vertical space, slightly less horizontal.

Which phone is better for watching videos?

The iPhone 8 Plus displays widescreen content with minimal letterboxing due to its 16:9 screen, making it technically better for native video playback. However, the iPhone X compensates with superior OLED contrast, HDR support, and brighter visuals, offering a richer overall experience.

Can I still use my old accessories with the iPhone X?

Most cases and chargers are compatible if they don’t block the rear camera or Lightning port. However, docks designed for the home button may not align properly, and wireless charging works best with Qi-certified pads supported by both models.

Final Thoughts: Prioritize Experience Over Specs

Screen size alone doesn’t determine daily usability. The iPhone X demonstrates that thoughtful design—narrower width, edge-to-edge display, gesture navigation—can deliver a more satisfying experience than simply increasing dimensions. Meanwhile, the iPhone 8 Plus remains a capable device, particularly for those who value Touch ID and prefer a proven form factor.

Ultimately, the “best” screen depends on how you interact with your phone. If you prioritize comfort, modern aesthetics, and vertical content, the iPhone X’s design wins. If you want maximum screen width for media and aren’t concerned about weight, the 8 Plus holds its ground.

💬 What matters most to you in a smartphone display? Share your thoughts on screen size, clarity, and usability—we’d love to hear your real-world experiences!