In 2024, comparing two smartphones launched in 2017—Apple’s iPhone X and Samsung’s Galaxy S8—might seem like a trip down memory lane. Yet, both devices still surface in secondhand markets, budget listings, and nostalgic debates. With prices now well under $100 for either model, some buyers wonder: is it worth picking up one of these flagships from the past? And if so, which offers more real-world usability today?
The answer isn’t as simple as “newer is better.” While neither phone meets modern standards for flagship performance, each has strengths that could appeal to specific users—those seeking a compact iOS device, a lightweight Android option, or even a backup phone. Let’s break down the iPhone X and Galaxy S8 in 2024 across key categories to determine which, if either, still holds relevance.
Design and Build: Premium Materials, Aging Gracefully
Both phones were groundbreaking in design when released. The iPhone X introduced Apple’s edge-to-edge OLED display with the controversial notch, while the Galaxy S8 pushed bezel-less innovation with its curved Infinity Display. Today, their builds remain impressive for vintage devices.
The iPhone X features glass front and back with a stainless steel frame, giving it a premium feel. It’s compact at 5.65 inches tall and weighs just 174g. In contrast, the Galaxy S8 is slightly taller (5.93 inches) but narrower, making it easier to grip despite its larger 5.8-inch screen. Its aluminum frame and glass back also convey high-end craftsmanship.
However, durability is a concern. Neither phone has an official IP rating higher than IP68, but water resistance degrades over time. After six years, any exposure to moisture poses significant risk. Drop resistance is similarly compromised—glass backs on both are prone to cracking.
Performance and Software: The Real Showstopper
This is where the reality check hits. Both phones launched with top-tier processors—the A11 Bionic for the iPhone X and Qualcomm Snapdragon 835 for the Galaxy S8. In 2017, they handled multitasking and gaming effortlessly. But in 2024, expectations have evolved.
The iPhone X runs iOS 16 as its final update, missing out on iOS 17 and all future security patches. While iOS 16 remains functional, many newer apps are optimized for iOS 17+ and may run sluggishly or not at all. App developers increasingly drop support for older OS versions, limiting access to banking apps, social media platforms, and productivity tools.
The Galaxy S8 originally shipped with Android 7 and received updates up to Android 9 (Pie). Samsung ended support in 2020. Without Google Play Services updates or security patches, using the S8 as a primary device poses privacy risks. Even basic browsing can be slow due to outdated WebView components.
“Devices stuck on unsupported operating systems become vulnerable quickly. By 2024, even well-maintained legacy phones like the S8 or iPhone X should not handle sensitive data.” — Lin Zhao, Mobile Security Analyst at TechShield Labs
Real-world usage reflects this: launching Instagram takes 5–7 seconds on the iPhone X; the S8 often crashes during login. YouTube playback stutters intermittently on both. Neither handles split-screen or background app switching smoothly.
Camera Comparison: Nostalgia vs. Usability
In their prime, both cameras were class-leading. The iPhone X offered natural color science, excellent dynamic range, and reliable portrait mode. The Galaxy S8 delivered vibrant, contrast-rich photos ideal for social media, though sometimes oversaturated.
Today, limitations are stark. Low-light performance is poor on both—images are noisy, autofocus hunts, and HDR processing takes seconds. Video tops out at 4K/60fps on the iPhone X and 4K/30fps on the S8, but stabilization is inconsistent. Front cameras lack modern AI enhancements, making selfies grainy in dim lighting.
That said, in perfect daylight, both can still capture usable 12MP shots. The iPhone X edges ahead with more consistent white balance and better video quality. The S8’s dual-pixel autofocus gives it faster subject tracking, but software lag undermines responsiveness.
Camera Performance Summary (2024 Real-World Use)
| Feature | iPhone X | Galaxy S8 |
|---|---|---|
| Daylight Photos | Good detail, accurate colors | Vibrant, slightly oversharpened |
| Low-Light Quality | Noisy, slow focus | Poor, excessive blur |
| Video Recording | Stable 4K, decent audio | 4K shaky, audio muffled |
| Front Camera | Sharp, natural skin tones | Soft focus, halo effects |
| App Compatibility | Limited third-party camera apps | Most apps no longer supported |
Battery Life and Charging: Diminishing Returns
Original battery capacities were modest: 2716mAh (iPhone X) and 3000mAh (S8). After six years, even if the battery health is “good,” capacity likely sits between 60–75% of original. This translates to about 4–5 hours of screen time under light use—checking messages, light browsing, and occasional calls.
Neither supports fast charging by modern standards. The iPhone X charges at up to 15W with a USB-C to Lightning cable and adapter, but ships with a 5W brick. The S8 supports Quick Charge 2.0 (up to 15W), but chargers must be purchased separately. Wireless charging works on both, though slowly.
Mini Case Study: Daily Use Test (June 2024)
Austin, a college student, tested both phones for one week as secondary devices. He used them for music playback, note-taking, and offline navigation. The iPhone X lasted through morning classes before needing a charge; the S8 died mid-afternoon. Austin noted that the S8’s screen brightness dropped significantly in sunlight, while the iPhone X maintained readability. However, he preferred the S8’s Always-On Display for checking time without unlocking. Ultimately, he found both too limited for daily reliance and upgraded to a refurbished iPhone SE (2022).
Value Proposition in 2024: Who Should Consider Them?
At current market prices—typically $40–$80 for either device—the question shifts from performance to purpose. These phones aren’t suitable as primary devices for most users, but they can serve niche roles:
- Kids’ first phone: Limited app access reduces distractions; parental controls work reliably on iOS.
- Digital detox device: Use only for calls, texts, and music—no social media.
- Car dashcam or GPS unit: Mount the phone permanently with offline maps.
- Media player: Load with podcasts or audiobooks for workouts.
Between the two, the iPhone X holds slight advantages: longer software support history, better app optimization for older hardware, and stronger resale ecosystem for parts. The S8 offers a larger, more immersive screen and microSD support (up to 400GB), useful for media storage.
Checklist: Before Buying an iPhone X or Galaxy S8 in 2024
- Verify battery health (iPhone) or replace the battery upfront.
- Confirm the device is unlocked and not iCloud/FRP locked.
- Test all core functions: speakers, microphone, charging port, cameras.
- Check for deep scratches or separation on the OLED screen.
- Ensure Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connect reliably to modern devices.
- Avoid units with swollen batteries or water damage indicators.
- Assume no future software updates—use only for low-risk tasks.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the iPhone X run iOS 17?
No. The iPhone X’s last supported version is iOS 16.7.8. It does not qualify for iOS 17, which requires iPhone XS or later.
Is the Galaxy S8 still secure to use?
Not for sensitive activities. Without security updates since 2020, it’s vulnerable to known exploits. Avoid entering passwords, banking, or storing personal data on the device.
Which phone lasts longer on a charge today?
It depends on battery condition, but generally, a well-maintained iPhone X performs slightly better due to iOS power management. However, both require daily charging, often twice.
Final Verdict: Is Either Phone Worth It in 2024?
The iPhone X and Galaxy S8 were revolutionary in 2017. Today, they’re relics—not broken, but outpaced. For under $100, they might seem like bargains, but their technological shelf life has expired.
If forced to choose, the iPhone X is the less outdated option. Its build quality, iOS efficiency, and slightly longer update cycle give it an edge in stability. But the Galaxy S8’s elegant design and expandable storage still charm enthusiasts.
Ultimately, neither is “worth it” as a main phone. But as a backup, gift for a child, or retro tech experiment, either can serve—with clear limitations. Just don’t expect speed, security, or compatibility with the digital world of 2024.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?