In 2017, the iPhone X and Samsung Galaxy S8 represented the pinnacle of smartphone innovation. The iPhone X introduced Face ID and a notch display, while the Galaxy S8 delivered an edge-to-edge screen and Bixby-powered AI. Fast forward to 2024, and both devices are nearly seven years old—ancient by tech standards. Yet, some users still rely on them or consider picking one up secondhand. So, was switching from iPhone to Galaxy (or vice versa) back then a smart move? And more importantly, does the Galaxy S8 still hold up today?
This article examines both phones through the lens of modern usability, comparing hardware longevity, software support, app compatibility, and real-world performance in 2024.
Hardware Comparison: Design and Build Quality
The Galaxy S8 and iPhone X were both flagship devices built with premium materials. The S8 featured a glass back with an aluminum frame and curved AMOLED edges that gave it a futuristic look. Its compact 5.8-inch display fit comfortably in one hand, despite its high screen-to-body ratio. The iPhone X matched this with surgical-grade stainless steel, a ceramic front, and a slightly larger 5.8-inch OLED display—but with flat edges and Apple’s signature minimalist design.
Both phones supported wireless charging and had IP68 water resistance. However, the S8 used a micro-USB port instead of USB-C—a notable omission even in 2017. The iPhone X, meanwhile, embraced Lightning, which remains in use across Apple's lineup.
Software Support and Updates: The Real Lifespan Factor
Software updates determine how long a phone remains functional in the modern ecosystem. Apple provided iOS updates for the iPhone X until iOS 16, released in 2022. It did not receive iOS 17, cutting off major feature upgrades and security patches after six years—an impressive run by industry standards.
Samsung promised four years of OS upgrades for select flagships starting with the S20 series. The Galaxy S8, launched with Android 7 (Nougat), received updates up to Android 9 (Pie). That means it stopped receiving official OS updates just three years after release. Security patches ceased shortly thereafter.
“Even if the hardware holds up, lack of software support turns a once-great phone into a security risk.” — David Kim, Mobile Security Analyst at TechShield Labs
Without current OS versions, neither device supports the latest privacy features, camera enhancements, or accessibility tools. More critically, many apps now require newer Android or iOS versions to function.
Performance in 2024: Can These Phones Still Handle Daily Tasks?
Under the hood, the iPhone X used Apple’s A11 Bionic chip, while the Galaxy S8 ran on the Qualcomm Snapdragon 835 (or Exynos 9810 in some regions). In their prime, both offered smooth multitasking and excellent gaming performance.
But performance isn’t just about raw power—it’s about optimization. Thanks to iOS efficiency, the iPhone X continues to handle basic tasks like calling, messaging, web browsing, and light social media use reasonably well in 2024. Apps like WhatsApp, Gmail, and Spotify still run, though some newer features may be missing or laggy.
The Galaxy S8 struggles more. Many modern Android apps are optimized for at least Android 10 or higher. On Android 9, users face frequent crashes, slow loading times, and outright incompatibility. Google Play Store often blocks installations due to OS version restrictions.
| Feature | iPhone X | Galaxy S8 |
|---|---|---|
| Last OS Version | iOS 16.7 (2023) | Android 9 (2019) |
| Final Major Update Year | 2022 | 2019 |
| Current App Compatibility | Moderate (most core apps work) | Poor (many apps refuse to install) |
| Battery Health After 6+ Years | Typically degraded; replaceable via Apple | Severely degraded; hard to replace officially |
| Security Patch Status | No active patches since late 2023 | No patches since 2020 |
Real-World Example: Using the S8 as a Daily Driver in 2024
Mark, a freelance photographer based in Portland, kept his Galaxy S8 as a backup device for controlling drone cameras and reviewing shots in the field. He found that by early 2023, the device could no longer connect reliably to newer drone apps. Firmware updates required Android 10+, and the Bluetooth stack began dropping connections.
He tried installing alternative app stores and sideloading APKs, but faced constant crashes and permission errors. By mid-2023, he abandoned the S8 entirely. “It wasn’t slow,” he said. “It was incompatible. The ecosystem moved on.”
In contrast, Mark’s friend Lisa still uses her iPhone X for music production notes and voice memos. While she avoids heavy apps, she says iMessage, Notes, and GarageBand Lite remain functional. “It’s not fast, but it doesn’t feel broken,” she noted.
Was Switching Worth It Back Then?
In 2017, switching between iPhone X and Galaxy S8 came down to ecosystem preference. iPhone users gained seamless integration with iCloud, AirPods, and Mac devices. The S8 offered expandable storage, headphone jack retention, and superior screen brightness outdoors.
For productivity, the S8’s multi-window mode and DeX desktop interface gave it an edge. But iOS offered better long-term app optimization and tighter security. Gamers noticed smoother frame rates on the A11 Bionic over time, thanks to Apple’s metal-level graphics control.
Those who switched from iPhone to Galaxy in 2017 likely enjoyed short-term novelty but faced earlier obsolescence due to Samsung’s weaker update policy at the time. Conversely, iPhone X adopters benefited from longer support—though they paid a premium price and lost the headphone jack.
Checklist: Is Your Old Phone Still Safe to Use in 2024?
- ✅ Check if your OS is still receiving security updates
- ✅ Verify app compatibility with essential services (banking, email, messaging)
- ✅ Test Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connectivity with modern accessories
- ✅ Assess battery health—replace if capacity is below 70%
- ❌ Avoid entering sensitive data (credit cards, passwords) on outdated devices
- ❌ Don’t use public Wi-Fi without a trusted VPN connection
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I still use the Galaxy S8 as a phone in 2024?
Technically yes, but practically no. Basic calling and texting work on most carriers, but app incompatibility, lack of security updates, and degraded battery make it unreliable for daily use. Some banking and social media apps will not install or function properly.
Is the iPhone X secure to use in 2024?
It’s safer than the S8 due to later software support, but it hasn’t received security patches since late 2023. Avoid storing sensitive information or logging into financial accounts regularly. For emergency or secondary use, it’s acceptable—with precautions.
Which phone held value better over time?
The iPhone X retained resale value significantly better. Even in 2024, used units sell for $50–$80 depending on condition. The Galaxy S8 typically fetches under $30 and is often considered e-waste by recyclers.
Conclusion: Time Has Moved On
The iPhone X vs Galaxy S8 debate was compelling in 2017. Today, neither device meets modern standards for performance, security, or software relevance. However, the iPhone X edges out the S8 in longevity thanks to Apple’s six-year update cycle—a benchmark the industry has only recently begun to match.
The Galaxy S8, while innovative, fell behind quickly due to limited OS upgrades and rapid app ecosystem evolution. By 2024, it’s effectively obsolete. The iPhone X lingers in usability but should not be relied upon as a primary device.
If you’re still using either phone, consider it a testament to solid engineering—but also a warning. Technology waits for no one. Upgrading ensures access to critical security patches, modern features, and reliable performance.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?