As Apple continues to release new models every year, many users are left wondering whether older iPhones still hold up—especially when considering value, performance, and longevity. The iPhone XR and iPhone 8 represent two distinct generations of Apple’s design philosophy and technology. Released just a year apart (2017 and 2018), they serve different user needs and price points. But in 2024, with both models discontinued and available only through third-party sellers or refurbished markets, the real question emerges: Is the iPhone XR still worth choosing over the iPhone 8, or has time made the 8 “good enough” for basic tasks?
Design and Display: A Clear Generational Shift
The most immediate difference between the iPhone XR and iPhone 8 lies in their design language and screen technology. The iPhone 8 retains Apple’s pre–Face ID era design: a 4.7-inch LCD display framed by thick bezels and topped with a physical Home button featuring Touch ID. It’s compact, familiar, and easy to handle with one hand.
In contrast, the iPhone XR introduced a modern edge-to-edge Liquid Retina display, measuring 6.1 inches diagonally. While also an LCD panel, it uses advanced backlighting and color calibration to deliver richer visuals, better brightness, and True Tone support. The absence of a Home button means Face ID for unlocking and Apple Pay authentication—a significant shift in user interaction.
The XR’s larger size makes it more suited for media consumption, web browsing, and multitasking, but less ideal for those who prefer smaller phones. Its aluminum frame and glass back give it a premium feel despite lacking the 8’s IP67 water resistance (both have similar ratings).
Performance and Longevity: Chipset Matters
Under the hood, both phones launched with powerful processors for their time—the iPhone 8 uses the A11 Bionic chip, while the XR features the A12 Bionic. On paper, this seems like a small leap, but in practice, it’s substantial.
The A12 Bionic was Apple’s first 7nm chip, offering up to 15% faster CPU performance and 50% better GPU efficiency than the A11. More importantly, it brought improved machine learning capabilities and better power management. This translates directly into longer software support and smoother performance over time.
Apple typically supports its devices with iOS updates for five to six years. The iPhone 8 received updates from iOS 11 through iOS 16, with iOS 17 dropping support. The iPhone XR, however, continues to receive updates—including iOS 17—and is expected to get iOS 18 in 2024. That extra year or two of software relevance can be crucial for security, app compatibility, and feature access.
“Software support is often the deciding factor in whether an older iPhone remains usable. The XR’s inclusion in current iOS versions gives it a clear edge.” — David Lin, Mobile Analyst at TechPulse Insights
Camera Comparison: Quality Over Quantity
Both phones feature single-lens rear cameras, but the differences in image processing and sensor technology are notable. The iPhone 8 has a 12MP f/1.8 wide-angle camera with optical image stabilization (OIS), capable of solid daylight photos and decent low-light shots for its era.
The iPhone XR improves on this with a newer 12MP sensor (also f/1.8) that captures more light and detail, thanks to Smart HDR and advanced noise reduction powered by the A12 chip. Its portrait mode, though simulated via software rather than dual lenses, performs surprisingly well using depth mapping and facial recognition.
Front-facing cameras tell a similar story: the 8’s 7MP FaceTime camera is serviceable, but the XR’s 7MP TrueDepth system enables Animoji, better Portrait Mode selfies, and more accurate Face ID recognition.
| Feature | iPhone 8 | iPhone XR |
|---|---|---|
| Display Size | 4.7 inches | 6.1 inches |
| Display Type | Retina HD LCD | Liquid Retina HD LCD |
| Processor | A11 Bionic | A12 Bionic |
| iOS Support (Latest) | iOS 16 | iOS 17+ (expected) |
| Rear Camera | 12MP f/1.8 (OIS) | 12MP f/1.8 (Smart HDR) |
| Front Camera | 7MP | 7MP TrueDepth |
| Battery Life (Video Playback) | Up to 13 hours | Up to 16 hours |
| Water Resistance | IP67 (1m for 30 min) | IP67 (1m for 30 min) |
| Biometric Security | Touch ID | Face ID |
Battery Life and Daily Usability
The iPhone XR delivers significantly better battery life than the iPhone 8. Apple rated the XR for up to 16 hours of video playback, compared to 13 hours on the 8. Real-world usage confirms this gap: the XR typically lasts a full day with moderate to heavy use, while the 8 often requires midday charging for active users.
This advantage stems not only from the larger battery but also from the A12’s power efficiency. Background processes, screen brightness management, and app optimization all contribute to extended endurance. For anyone relying on their phone throughout the workday, commute, or travel, the XR’s stamina is a tangible benefit.
That said, if your usage is light—checking messages, occasional calls, and social media—the iPhone 8 can still manage a full day, especially if the battery has been recently replaced. Refurbished units often come with new batteries, which can restore near-original performance.
Real-World Example: Sarah’s Upgrade Dilemma
Sarah, a freelance writer in her early 30s, needed a reliable phone for emails, note-taking, and video calls. She considered buying a used iPhone 8 for $150 due to its lower price and compact size. After testing one for a week, she found the small screen tiring for long writing sessions, and apps like Zoom occasionally lagged during multitasking.
She then tried a refurbished iPhone XR priced at $220. Despite being larger, the screen made document editing easier, Face ID worked reliably, and the battery lasted through her entire workday without charging. Even after two weeks, she noticed fewer app crashes and faster loading times. Ultimately, she chose the XR, citing long-term usability as her deciding factor.
Her experience reflects a broader trend: while budget options exist, spending slightly more for future-proofing often pays off in daily comfort and reliability.
Is the iPhone 8 Still Good Enough?
Yes—but with caveats. The iPhone 8 remains functional for basic smartphone tasks: calling, texting, browsing, and using essential apps like Maps, WhatsApp, and banking tools. However, its limitations become apparent when running newer apps, especially those requiring AR, high-resolution video, or background processing.
Moreover, lack of iOS 17 support means no new features, reduced app compatibility over time, and potentially slower security patches. App developers increasingly optimize for newer OS versions, so even if an app installs, it may run poorly or lack functionality.
If you’re on a tight budget, plan to use the phone for less than a year, or need a temporary device, the iPhone 8 is acceptable. But for anyone planning to keep a phone for 18 months or longer, the XR offers better value.
Checklist: Choosing Between iPhone XR and iPhone 8
- ✅ Do you want longer software support? → Choose XR
- ✅ Will you use the phone heavily each day? → Choose XR
- ✅ Do you prefer a compact, lightweight device? → Consider 8
- ✅ Are you on a strict budget under $180? → 8 may suffice
- ✅ Do you value Face ID or use Animoji? → XR only
- ✅ Is battery life critical? → XR wins
- ✅ Do you already own accessories (cases, docks) for iPhone 8? → May favor 8
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the iPhone 8 still get security updates?
While Apple may issue critical security patches for unsupported devices in rare cases, official update support ended with iOS 16. Most security fixes now go only to supported models, making the iPhone 8 increasingly vulnerable over time.
Is the iPhone XR waterproof?
It has an IP67 rating, meaning it can survive submersion in up to 1 meter of water for 30 minutes. However, this isn’t permanent protection—water resistance diminishes over time, especially if the device has been dropped or repaired.
Which phone holds resale value better?
The iPhone XR generally maintains higher resale value due to its newer processor, larger screen, and continued iOS support. Even among older models, demand for the XR remains stronger in the refurbished market.
Final Verdict: Is the XR Still Worth It?
In 2024, the iPhone XR remains the smarter choice for most users looking at these two models. It delivers a modern smartphone experience with a large, vibrant display, robust performance, strong battery life, and ongoing software support. While the iPhone 8 is cheaper and more compact, its aging hardware and lack of future updates make it a short-term solution at best.
The extra $50–$70 investment in an iPhone XR today can save you from needing to upgrade again within a year. Whether you're buying for yourself, a family member, or as a backup device, the XR strikes the right balance between cost and capability. Technology evolves quickly, but usability and longevity matter more than ever.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?