In 2024, flagship smartphones evolve rapidly, but older models like the Google Pixel 3 XL and iPhone 11 Pro Max remain in conversations—especially among budget-conscious buyers or those who value specific features over raw performance. While both devices launched years ago, their legacy lingers due to strong camera systems, software support history, and loyal user bases. But which one holds up better today? Is the Pixel 3 XL still a smart buy, or does the iPhone 11 Pro Max offer more longevity and real-world usability?
This analysis dives deep into performance, software, camera quality, battery life, and long-term ownership costs to determine which device delivers better value in 2024.
Performance and Hardware: How Do They Hold Up?
The Pixel 3 XL launched in 2018 with the Qualcomm Snapdragon 845, 4GB of RAM, and storage options up to 128GB. At the time, it was a top-tier configuration, but by 2024 standards, it struggles with multitasking and modern app demands. Apps like Instagram, TikTok, and even Chrome can feel sluggish during heavy use. The phone lacks expandable storage, and its aging processor limits background app retention.
In contrast, the iPhone 11 Pro Max arrived in 2019 with Apple’s A13 Bionic chip—a powerhouse even by mid-2020s benchmarks. With 4GB of RAM (optimized efficiently by iOS), it handles most current apps smoothly. Even under sustained loads, thermal throttling is minimal thanks to Apple’s hardware-software integration. iOS updates continue to run well on this chip, making the device far more future-proof than its Android counterpart.
Software Support and Security Updates
Google officially ended major Android OS updates for the Pixel 3 series in late 2021. Security patches ceased entirely by late 2023. That means no official protection against emerging vulnerabilities—an increasing risk in an era of mobile banking and two-factor authentication.
Apple, meanwhile, supports devices longer. The iPhone 11 Pro Max received iOS 17 in 2023 and may get iOS 18 in 2024, though final confirmation depends on Apple’s rollout strategy. Even if it stops at iOS 17, that’s six years of software support—double Google’s policy at the time. Extended security updates are also more reliable on iPhones, especially within Apple’s tightly controlled ecosystem.
“Long-term software support is often the deciding factor between a usable phone and a security liability after five years.” — David Lin, Mobile Security Analyst at TechShield Labs
Camera Comparison: Still a Pixel Strength?
The Pixel 3 XL made waves for its single rear camera. Using computational photography magic—HDR+, Night Sight, and Super Res Zoom—it outperformed many multi-lens rivals. In 2024, its photos still impress in daylight: accurate colors, excellent dynamic range, and natural skin tones. However, low-light performance now shows limitations. Noise appears in darker scenes, and processing takes longer than modern devices.
The iPhone 11 Pro Max features a triple-camera system: wide, ultra-wide, and telephoto. All three sensors benefit from Deep Fusion and Night mode across lenses. While not always matching Pixel color science in ideal conditions, the iPhone offers greater versatility. You can shoot wide-angle landscapes or zoomed portraits without sacrificing much quality. Video recording is where the iPhone dominates—offering 4K at 60fps with cinematic stabilization, something the Pixel 3 XL cannot match.
| Feature | Pixel 3 XL | iPhone 11 Pro Max |
|---|---|---|
| Rear Cameras | 12.2MP (single) | 12MP wide + ultra-wide + telephoto |
| Low-Light Mode | Night Sight (still capable) | Night mode (all lenses) |
| Video Recording | 4K @ 30fps | 4K @ 60fps with extended dynamic range |
| Front Camera | 8MP dual front (wide-angle) | 12MP TrueDepth with slofie support |
| Portrait Mode | Software-based (face only) | Depth mapping with LiDAR-like tuning |
Battery Life and Charging Realities
The Pixel 3 XL came with a 3,430mAh battery—modest even in 2018. By 2024, after years of charge cycles, most units show significant degradation. Users report struggling to reach half a day with moderate use. Fast charging helps, but wireless charging is limited to 10W (with compatible pads). No reverse charging or adaptive battery learning beyond basic Doze modes.
The iPhone 11 Pro Max packs a 3,969mAh battery and consistently delivers 6–8 hours of screen-on time even in 2024, assuming the battery hasn’t degraded below 80%. It supports fast charging (up to 50% in 30 minutes with 18W adapter, sold separately) and Qi wireless charging. iOS power management is also more aggressive, suspending background tasks effectively.
Real-World Example: Sarah’s Upgrade Dilemma
Sarah, a freelance photographer, needed a secondary phone for client calls and social media posting. Her budget capped at $200. She considered both the Pixel 3 XL ($140 refurbished) and iPhone 11 Pro Max ($190 used with 85% battery).
She chose the iPhone. Though heavier and less compact, its superior video quality allowed her to record quick client testimonials. The extra lens flexibility helped capture environment shots during shoots. Most importantly, iOS 17 compatibility gave her confidence in app support for at least another year. The Pixel, while offering cleaner Android and great stills, felt outdated in daily responsiveness and lacked ongoing security patches.
Her decision highlights a broader trend: in 2024, longevity and reliability often outweigh nostalgic loyalty to past camera champions.
Checklist: What to Evaluate Before Buying Either Phone
- ✅ Verify battery health (below 80% = likely needs replacement)
- ✅ Confirm software version and update eligibility
- ✅ Check for physical damage (especially OLED burn-in on Pixel 3 XL)
- ✅ Test all core functions: cameras, speakers, charging ports
- ✅ Research seller reputation (if buying used)
- ✅ Consider cost of potential repairs (battery, screen)
- ✅ Assess your app usage—do you rely on heavy multitasking or AR features?
FAQ
Can the Pixel 3 XL run Android 14?
No. The last official update was Android 12. Any Android 14 installation would require unofficial custom ROMs, which sacrifice stability and security.
Is the iPhone 11 Pro Max waterproof?
Yes. It has an IP68 rating, meaning it can survive submersion up to 4 meters for 30 minutes. However, water resistance degrades over time, especially on used units.
Which phone has better audio?
The Pixel 3 XL wins here. It includes front-facing stereo speakers tuned by Google with high clarity and minimal distortion. The iPhone 11 Pro Max also has excellent stereo separation, but the Pixel’s audio profile remains a favorite among audiophiles.
Final Verdict: Which Should You Buy in 2024?
The Google Pixel 3 XL was revolutionary in its time—especially for photography—but in 2024, it's functionally obsolete. Lack of updates, weak battery life, and declining performance make it a risky choice unless you're acquiring it for free or as a backup device with very light use.
The iPhone 11 Pro Max, despite being a year newer, benefits from Apple’s longer support cycle, better hardware optimization, and continued relevance in app ecosystems. Even at similar price points, it offers more practical value: longer software life, better battery, superior video, and wider accessory compatibility.
If you're choosing between the two today, the iPhone 11 Pro Max is clearly the better investment. It may lack some of the Pixel’s software purity, but iOS stability and update longevity win in the long run.
“The best phone isn’t always the one with the best camera—it’s the one that keeps working securely and reliably when you need it.” — Lena Patel, Senior Editor at MobileEdge Review
Conclusion: Make a Smart, Future-Focused Choice
While nostalgia might pull you toward the Pixel 3 XL’s clean Android experience and legendary point-and-shoot camera, reality favors the iPhone 11 Pro Max in 2024. It offers stronger performance, better software support, and a more durable ecosystem fit for modern usage patterns.
Before purchasing any older flagship, ask: Will this device meet my needs for the next 12 months? Is it secure? Can it run the apps I depend on? For most users, the answer leans firmly toward the iPhone.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?