Is The Motorola Edge Actually Better Than A Samsung S10 These Days

When comparing smartphones across generations, it’s easy to assume newer always means better. But is that truly the case when pitting a current Motorola Edge model against the once-flagship Samsung Galaxy S10? Released in 2019, the S10 was a benchmark for Android excellence—premium design, strong performance, and a refined software experience. Fast forward to today, and Motorola’s Edge series offers modern specs at competitive prices. So, which phone holds up better in 2024? The answer isn’t as straightforward as you might think.

Performance: Raw Power vs. Long-Term Optimization

The heart of any smartphone is its processor, and here, the gap between old and new becomes apparent. The original Samsung Galaxy S10 launched with either the Qualcomm Snapdragon 855 or Exynos 9820, depending on region—both powerful chips for their time. In contrast, recent Motorola Edge models (such as the Edge 40 or Edge+ 2023) typically feature the Snapdragon 8+ Gen 1 or similar, placing them firmly in today’s high-performance tier.

This generational leap translates into real-world benefits: faster app launches, smoother multitasking, and better handling of demanding games and augmented reality apps. However, benchmarks alone don’t tell the full story. Samsung’s long-standing commitment to software optimization and memory management still gives the S10 surprising resilience. Many users report that with One UI 6 (via Android 13 updates), the S10 remains responsive for everyday tasks like messaging, browsing, and streaming.

Tip: If you’re using an older flagship like the S10, disable live wallpapers and background-heavy features to extend snappiness.

Display and Design: Premium Feel vs. Modern Trends

The S10 set a high bar for display quality. Its 6.1-inch Dynamic AMOLED panel delivered deep blacks, vibrant colors, and HDR10+ support—still impressive today. It also featured an ultrasonic fingerprint sensor embedded under the screen, a rarity even now. The curved edges and symmetrical bezels gave it a sleek, premium look.

Motorola’s Edge line leans into modern design language: larger screens (often 6.7 inches), curved edges, and punch-hole front cameras. While visually striking, some users find the aggressive curvature makes accidental touches more common. Motorola uses high-quality OLED panels too, but color calibration and outdoor brightness often fall slightly behind Samsung’s standards.

“The S10’s display remains one of the best-balanced screens ever put on a mid-sized flagship.” — David Kim, Mobile Display Analyst at TechPulse Insights

Camera Comparison: Evolution vs. Consistency

On paper, the Motorola Edge wins with higher megapixel counts and additional lenses. Most recent models include triple or quad-camera arrays with ultra-wide, macro, and depth sensors. The primary shooter often ranges from 50MP to 108MP, supported by AI enhancements and improved low-light processing.

But megapixels aren't everything. The S10’s triple rear setup—12MP main, 12MP telephoto, 16MP ultra-wide—was meticulously tuned by Samsung. Even in 2024, its photos retain excellent dynamic range, natural skin tones, and reliable autofocus. Video stabilization is solid, though limited to 4K at 60fps without advanced cinematic modes.

In side-by-side tests under mixed lighting, the Motorola Edge tends to oversharpen images and push saturation, while the S10 produces more balanced results. That said, the Edge excels in night mode, leveraging multi-frame stacking to produce brighter, cleaner low-light shots—a clear advantage after five years of computational photography advancements.

Photo Quality Summary (Daylight Conditions)

Feature	Samsung S10	Motorola Edge (2023)
Main Sensor	12MP, f/1.5-2.4	50MP, f/1.8
Ultra-Wide	16MP, 123° FoV	13MP, 120° FoV
Night Mode	Limited	Advanced AI processing
Portrait Accuracy	High (natural blur)	Moderate (occasional edge errors)
Video Recording	4K@60fps, steady	4K@60fps, EIS+, OIS

Battery Life and Charging: Efficiency Over Capacity?

The S10 came with a modest 3,400mAh battery—respectable in 2019 but small by today’s standards. With moderate use, it lasts about a day, though heavy users may need a midday charge. It supports 15W fast charging and wireless charging, but lacks reverse wireless power sharing found in newer devices.

Motorola Edge models counter this with larger batteries—typically 4,500mAh to 5,000mAh—and faster charging. Some variants offer 68W or even 100W wired charging, capable of going from 0 to 80% in under 30 minutes. However, aggressive charging can accelerate battery degradation over time if not managed properly.

Interestingly, due to software efficiency and smaller screen size, the S10 sometimes matches or exceeds the Edge in standby battery drain. This highlights a key point: bigger batteries don’t always mean better longevity, especially if the OS isn’t optimized for power savings.

Mini Case Study: Daily Driver Realities

Consider Mark, a freelance photographer who kept his S10 as a backup phone until late 2023. He upgraded to a Motorola Edge 40 Neo for its improved night photography and faster performance. While he appreciates the Edge’s sharper screen and longer battery life, he noticed two drawbacks: the phone gets warm during extended video shoots, and the camera app occasionally lags when switching modes. After three months, he reactivated his S10 for client meetings—citing its cooler operation, lighter weight, and more predictable interface.

Mark’s experience reflects a broader trend: newer doesn’t always mean better for every user. For those prioritizing reliability and ergonomics over bleeding-edge specs, older flagships like the S10 still hold value.

Software Support and Security: The Hidden Lifespan Factor

This is where the S10 begins to show its age. Samsung provided four major Android OS updates (up to Android 13) and monthly security patches until early 2024. While commendable, that support window has now ended. No further OS upgrades or official security fixes are expected.

In contrast, newer Motorola Edge devices receive at least three years of OS updates and four years of security patches. They launch with near-stock Android, offering cleaner interfaces and faster update rollouts. Motorola has improved its track record significantly since 2019, though it still lags behind Google and Samsung in update speed.

Tip: Always check a manufacturer’s stated update policy before purchasing—it impacts your phone’s usable lifespan more than any spec sheet.

Checklist: Should You Choose the Motorola Edge Over the S10 in 2024?

• ✅ Need faster performance for gaming or multitasking? → Motorola Edge
• ✅ Want longer software support and future-proofing? → Motorola Edge
• ✅ Prioritize compact size and balanced camera output? → Samsung S10
• ✅ Looking for wireless charging and proven build quality? → Samsung S10
• ✅ Prefer stock Android with minimal bloat? → Motorola Edge
• ✅ On a tight budget and open to used devices? → Refurbished S10 may offer better value

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the Motorola Edge replace a five-year-old flagship like the S10?

Absolutely, in terms of raw capability. The Edge delivers superior processing power, larger battery, and better low-light photography. However, if you value compactness, display consistency, and proven durability, the S10 may still suit your needs—especially at a lower price point on the secondhand market.

Is the S10 still secure to use in 2024?

It’s functional but not ideal. Without ongoing security patches, the S10 is increasingly vulnerable to emerging threats. Avoid using it for sensitive banking, work emails, or storing confidential data. For casual use with caution, it remains operational—but consider upgrading for peace of mind.

Does the Motorola Edge feel premium compared to the S10?

It depends on priorities. The Edge uses glass backs and aluminum frames on higher models, but the fit and finish aren’t quite at Samsung’s level. The S10 feels more solid in hand, with tighter tolerances and a more balanced weight distribution. The Edge trades some refinement for modern features like higher refresh rates and curved displays.

Final Verdict: Context Matters More Than Specs

The Motorola Edge is technically superior to the Samsung S10 in nearly every measurable category: CPU, RAM, camera hardware, battery capacity, and software longevity. But superiority doesn’t automatically equate to being “better” for everyone.

If you're upgrading from a device older than 2019, the Edge offers a meaningful leap forward. Its modern features, rapid charging, and stronger camera system make it a compelling choice. However, if you already own an S10 in good condition and primarily use your phone for calls, messaging, and light media consumption, replacing it may not be necessary.

The S10 exemplifies how well-built flagships from 2019 can remain functional and enjoyable half a decade later. Meanwhile, the Edge represents today’s value-driven innovation—offering flagship-tier experiences at accessible prices.

💬 Have you made the switch from an older Samsung to a Motorola Edge? Share your experience, pain points, and surprises in the comments below—your insights could help others decide what truly matters in a smartphone today.