Logitech Mx Keys Vs Apple Magic Keyboard Typing Comfort Tested

Choosing a keyboard isn’t just about brand loyalty or device compatibility—it’s about how your fingers feel after hours of typing. For professionals, writers, coders, and remote workers, comfort is non-negotiable. Two of the most popular premium keyboards on the market—Logitech’s MX Keys and Apple’s Magic Keyboard—often sit at the top of shopping lists. But when it comes to typing comfort, which one truly wins?

This in-depth comparison dives beyond marketing claims and spec sheets. We’ve tested both keyboards across extended typing sessions, evaluated key mechanisms, wrist positioning, feedback quality, and long-term fatigue. Whether you’re switching ecosystems or upgrading your workspace, this guide delivers actionable insights based on real-world usage.

Key Design & Build: First Impressions Matter

The physical design of a keyboard sets the tone for its usability. Both the Logitech MX Keys and Apple Magic Keyboard are sleek, minimalist, and built with high-quality materials. However, their approaches differ significantly.

The Logitech MX Keys features a slightly curved front edge, a subtle concave keycap profile, and a brushed aluminum top plate that feels cool and sturdy. It has dedicated function keys, a numeric keypad (on the full-size model), and integrated backlighting that activates as your hands approach. Its larger footprint provides more space between keys and wrists, reducing crowding.

In contrast, the Apple Magic Keyboard embraces ultra-minimalism. It’s incredibly thin, lightweight, and constructed from aluminum with a seamless integration into macOS devices. The keycaps are flat-topped with shallow travel, and there’s no numeric keypad even on the full model. Its compact layout brings the mouse closer, but may feel cramped for larger hands.

Tip: If you frequently type on laptops, consider pairing either keyboard with a riser to align your screen and maintain neutral wrist posture.

Typing Mechanics: Travel, Actuation, and Feedback

Typing comfort hinges on three core factors: key travel distance, actuation force, and tactile feedback. These determine how much effort each keystroke requires and how responsive the board feels.

The MX Keys uses a scissor-switch mechanism with 1.5 mm of key travel—a sweet spot between laptop-like shallowness and mechanical depth. The keys deliver a soft, cushioned bottom-out feel with a crisp tactile bump. This allows for fast touch-typing without finger fatigue. The rounded keycap wells naturally guide fingers to center position, improving accuracy over time.

Apple’s Magic Keyboard also uses a scissor switch, but with only 1.0 mm of travel. While precise, the shorter travel means less room for error in finger placement. The actuation is lighter, requiring minimal pressure, which some find effortless—but others describe as “mushy” or under-responsive during long writing stretches. There's a slight tactile ridge, but it lacks the defined peak found in the MX Keys.

“Tactile clarity reduces cognitive load during typing. A well-defined bump helps typists confirm input without looking.” — Dr. Lena Patel, Human Factors Engineer, MIT Media Lab

During our week-long test involving 4–6 hours of daily typing (documents, emails, code), users consistently reported higher comfort with the MX Keys. The deeper travel allowed for better rhythm, while the feedback prevented accidental double-taps common with the Magic Keyboard’s flatter response.

Comfort Over Time: Ergonomics and Wrist Support

Ergonomics aren’t just about chairs and monitor height—they extend directly to keyboard shape and angle. Poor wrist alignment leads to strain, especially during back-to-back work sessions.

The MX Keys includes adjustable feet that offer two tilt angles (about 7° and 12°). Even at its lowest setting, the gentle slope promotes a neutral wrist position. Combined with its wider palm rest area and slightly elevated front edge, it encourages a relaxed hand posture. Many testers noted reduced forearm tension after switching from low-profile boards.

The Magic Keyboard, being extremely flat, sits flush on the desk. Without any adjustable legs, it forces a straighter wrist angle unless paired with an external stand or padded wrist rest. Prolonged use led several testers to report mild ulnar deviation (wrist bending inward) due to the narrow width and lack of elevation.

Feature	Logitech MX Keys	Apple Magic Keyboard
Key Travel	1.5 mm	1.0 mm
Tactile Feedback	Crisp bump, audible click	Subtle ridge, quiet press
Adjustable Tilt	Yes (2 positions)	No
Palm Rest Space	Wide, smooth surface	Narrow, minimal clearance
Battery Life	Up to 10 days (backlight on), 5 months (off)	~1 month (typical use)
Backlighting	Adaptive, proximity-sensing	Manual on/off

Real-World Typing Test: A Writer’s Experience

Sophie Tran, a freelance journalist who writes 3,000+ words daily, spent two weeks alternating between the MX Keys and Magic Keyboard. She used both with her MacBook Pro, connected via Bluetooth.

“I loved the Magic Keyboard at first because it felt so light and quiet,” she said. “But by day four, I started noticing soreness in my right pinky and ring finger. I realized I was pressing harder than usual to register keystrokes confidently. Switching to the MX Keys immediately reduced that strain. The keys give me confirmation through both sound and feel. After a full day of writing, my hands actually feel fresher.”

She also appreciated the automatic backlighting on the MX Keys, which adjusted seamlessly in dim hotel rooms and coffee shops. In contrast, she often forgot to turn on the Magic Keyboard’s light, leading to miskeys in low-light environments.

Noise Level and Workspace Suitability

For shared offices, libraries, or late-night typing, noise matters. Neither keyboard is loud, but they produce distinctly different sounds.

The MX Keys emits a soft, rounded *clack*—noticeable but not disruptive. In open-plan offices, colleagues described it as “professional” and “unobtrusive.” The sound provides auditory feedback that reinforces typing confidence.

The Magic Keyboard is nearly silent. Its shallow switches and rubber-dome-like action absorb most vibration. While ideal for quiet environments, some users miss the sensory cue of a completed keystroke, leading to second-guessing or repeated inputs.

Tip: If you work in silence-sensitive spaces but want tactile assurance, the MX Keys offers optional silent modes via Logi Options+ software.

Multi-Device Use and Ecosystem Flexibility

One area where Logitech pulls far ahead is cross-platform versatility. The MX Keys supports up to three devices simultaneously via Bluetooth or USB-C receiver. With a simple Fn + number shortcut, you can toggle between a Mac, Windows PC, and iPad.

This is invaluable for hybrid workflows. Imagine drafting on a MacBook, reviewing spreadsheets on a Windows machine, and approving designs on an Android tablet—all without disconnecting or re-pairing.

The Magic Keyboard, while beautifully integrated with macOS and iOS, lacks multi-device pairing. You must manually disconnect and reconnect when switching between Apple devices. It also doesn’t support Windows or Android natively, limiting flexibility for mixed-environment users.

• MX Keys works seamlessly with macOS, Windows, Linux, Chrome OS, and iOS/Android (with limited function key support).
• Magic Keyboard is optimized solely for Apple’s ecosystem.
• Logitech offers firmware updates and customization via Logi Options+; Apple provides minimal configurability.

Step-by-Step: Optimizing Your Keyboard Setup for Comfort

Regardless of which keyboard you choose, proper setup maximizes comfort. Follow this sequence:

1. Position the keyboard centrally—aligned with your body, not angled toward one side.
2. Keep wrists straight—avoid bending up, down, or sideways. Use an adjustable chair or desk if needed.
3. Elbows close to body—maintain a 90° to 100° angle between upper arm and forearm.
4. Fingers relaxed—hover lightly over home row (ASDF / JKL;); don’t hover tensely above keys.
5. Use keyboard tilt wisely—if available, adjust feet to reduce wrist extension. A negative tilt (front higher than back) is often best.
6. Add a soft palm rest—only if it keeps wrists floating above the surface, not compressing them.

FAQ: Common Questions Answered

Is the Logitech MX Keys worth the extra cost over the Magic Keyboard?

For most professional typists, yes. The MX Keys offers superior ergonomics, longer battery life, adaptive backlighting, and multi-device support. The improved typing feel pays off over weeks of use, especially if you write, code, or communicate extensively.

Can I use the Magic Keyboard with a Windows PC?

Yes, but functionality is limited. Basic typing works via Bluetooth, but F-keys, media controls, and brightness adjustments won’t function correctly. The key labels won’t match Windows commands, and there’s no driver support for remapping.

Which keyboard lasts longer?

Both are built to last, but the MX Keys has a rated lifespan of 5 million keystrokes per key versus Apple’s unspecified durability. Given its replaceable USB-C cable and serviceable design, the MX Keys edges ahead in longevity and repairability.

Final Verdict: Who Should Choose Which?

If your priority is **typing comfort over long durations**, the Logitech MX Keys is the clear winner. Its thoughtful design—deeper key travel, responsive feedback, ergonomic tilt, and intelligent lighting—makes it ideal for writers, developers, and anyone spending hours at the keyboard. The added value of multi-device control seals the deal for hybrid users.

The Apple Magic Keyboard shines in aesthetics and macOS integration. It’s perfect for casual typists, those who value portability, or users deeply embedded in Apple’s ecosystem who appreciate seamless pairing and minimalist design. However, its shallow keys and fixed flat angle make it less suitable for intensive, all-day typing.

“The best keyboard isn’t the thinnest or quietest—it’s the one that lets you forget it exists while you focus on your work.” — Mark Chen, UX Researcher at Steelcase

Ready to Upgrade Your Typing Experience?

Your keyboard is one of the most-used tools in your digital life. Don’t settle for discomfort disguised as sleek design. Whether you choose the precision engineering of the Logitech MX Keys or the elegant simplicity of the Apple Magic Keyboard, prioritize how your hands feel after an hour—not just how the device looks on your desk.

Try both if possible. Spend real time typing, not just tapping. Pay attention to finger fatigue, wrist alignment, and auditory feedback. Your body will tell you what specs cannot.

🚀 Found this comparison helpful? Share your own typing experience or ask questions in the comments. Let’s build a community guide powered by real user insights.