Mechanical Keyboard Switches Red Vs Blue Which Is Actually Better For Open Offices

In open-plan offices, where collaboration and proximity go hand in hand, the smallest sound can become a distraction. One of the loudest offenders? A clacky mechanical keyboard. While many professionals swear by mechanical switches for their responsiveness and durability, not all switches are created equal—especially when it comes to office etiquette. Among the most debated pairings are red and blue switches. Both fall under the Cherry MX family, but they differ dramatically in sound, actuation, and tactile feedback. So, which one truly belongs in an open office environment?

The answer isn’t just about personal preference—it’s about acoustic impact, typing efficiency, and respect for shared workspace dynamics. Understanding the core differences between red and blue switches can help you make a choice that balances performance with professionalism.

Understanding Mechanical Switch Types: Red vs Blue

Cherry MX Red and Blue are two of the most popular mechanical switch types, each catering to different user needs. Their design affects how they feel, how loud they are, and how suitable they are for environments like open offices.

Cherry MX Blue switches are known for their pronounced tactile bump and audible “click” at the point of actuation. This click provides clear auditory and physical feedback, making them favorites among typists who enjoy a responsive, almost typewriter-like experience. However, that same satisfying click is also what makes them disruptive in quiet or shared spaces.

Cherry MX Red switches, on the other hand, are linear—meaning they offer no tactile bump or audible click. They have a smooth keystroke from top to bottom and require less force to actuate (45g vs 50g for Blues). This makes them quieter and more consistent, ideal for environments where noise control matters.

The fundamental difference lies in feedback: Blues provide both tactile and auditory confirmation; Reds rely solely on muscle memory and visual input. In an open office, where every sound travels, this distinction becomes critical.

Tip: If you're sensitive to finger fatigue during long typing sessions, Reds may offer greater comfort due to their lighter actuation and smoother travel.

Noise Comparison: Why Sound Matters in Shared Workspaces

Noise pollution in open offices isn't just annoying—it's been linked to reduced concentration, increased stress, and lower productivity. A study published in the Journal of Environmental Psychology found that even moderate background noise can impair cognitive performance, particularly in tasks requiring focus and memory.

Cherry MX Blue switches generate significantly more sound than Reds. The audible \"click\" is produced by a small plastic component inside the switch that snaps into place when the key is pressed. This click registers around 50–60 decibels—comparable to a quiet conversation or a refrigerator hum—but because it’s sharp and repetitive, it cuts through ambient noise more effectively than continuous sounds.

In contrast, Red switches produce a softer thock or tap, primarily from the keycap hitting the top housing and the bottom-out impact. Without the internal click mechanism, the overall sound profile is much flatter and less intrusive. When tested side-by-side in controlled environments, keyboards with Blue switches consistently register as the noisiest option among common mechanical variants.

“Even subtle, repetitive sounds like keyboard clicks can trigger cognitive distraction in shared workspaces.” — Dr. Lena Torres, Cognitive Ergonomics Researcher, MIT Human Factors Lab

Performance and Typing Experience: Speed vs Feedback

Beyond noise, the typing experience plays a major role in daily productivity. Some users argue that the tactile feedback of Blue switches improves accuracy and rhythm, especially for long-form writing or coding. The distinct bump and click confirm each keystroke has registered, reducing errors and increasing confidence.

However, in practice, experienced typists often develop muscle memory that makes such feedback redundant. Gamers, for example, frequently prefer Red switches precisely because they allow rapid, uninterrupted keypresses without tactile resistance. This same advantage translates well to fast-paced typing, where double-taps or accidental repeats are minimized by the smooth linear action.

For touch typists who don’t look at the keyboard, the absence of a tactile bump may initially feel disorienting. But after a short adjustment period—usually a few days to a week—most users report no significant drop in accuracy. In fact, some find that the lack of interruption in keystroke flow enhances their speed and endurance.

Bottom line: while Blue switches offer satisfying feedback, Red switches support faster, quieter, and more fluid typing—qualities that align better with the demands of collaborative office environments.

Workplace Etiquette and Real-World Scenarios

Consider this scenario: Sarah, a software developer, recently upgraded her ergonomic setup with a mechanical keyboard featuring Cherry MX Blue switches. She loves the crisp response and rhythmic clicking that helps her stay in the zone. But within a week, two colleagues have mentioned the noise during stand-up meetings. One says it’s distracting during video calls; another jokes (but not entirely) about bringing noise-canceling headphones to her desk.

Sarah isn’t doing anything wrong technically—she’s using high-quality equipment and maintaining good posture. Yet, the unintended consequence of her choice affects team dynamics. Her keyboard, while excellent for her individual workflow, disrupts the collective focus of the space.

This is a common issue in tech startups, co-working spaces, and hybrid offices where employees bring personal gear. What feels empowering to one person can be grating to another. In such settings, minimizing auditory intrusion isn’t just considerate—it’s part of professional courtesy.

Switching to Reds—or even quieter alternatives like Browns (tactile but non-clicky) or optical switches—could resolve the conflict without sacrificing performance. It’s a small change that preserves both personal productivity and team harmony.

Tip: If you must use Blue switches in an office, pair them with O-rings or foam dampeners to reduce noise. However, these modifications may slightly alter the typing feel.

Comparison Table: Red vs Blue Switches for Open Offices

Feature	Cherry MX Red	Cherry MX Blue
Switch Type	Linear (smooth press)	Tactile + Clicky
Actuation Force	45g	50g
Actuation Point	2.0 mm	2.2 mm
Noise Level	Low to moderate (no click)	High (audible click)
Tactile Feedback	None	Pronounced bump + click
Best For	Gaming, fast typing, quiet offices	Typists who want feedback, home use
Office-Friendly?	Yes – minimal disruption	No – likely to disturb others

Actionable Checklist: Choosing the Right Switch for Your Office

• ✅ Assess your environment: Is your desk near others? Are there frequent meetings or calls nearby?
• ✅ Prioritize low-noise switches if working in close proximity to teammates.
• ✅ Test both Red and Blue switches in person, if possible, at a local electronics store or coworker’s desk.
• ✅ Consider alternatives: Brown (tactile but quiet), Silent Reds, or low-profile mechanical switches.
• ✅ Use keyboard foam or case dampening if you already own a loud board and can’t replace it.
• ✅ Be open to feedback: If a colleague mentions noise, take it seriously—even if it doesn’t bother you.

Expert Insight: What Industry Professionals Recommend

Many IT departments and ergonomic consultants now include keyboard noise in their workplace wellness assessments. As remote and hybrid models evolve, personal devices are increasingly scrutinized for their impact on shared digital and physical spaces.

“In open offices, we recommend linear switches like Reds or silent variants. The goal is to maintain high performance without compromising acoustic comfort.” — Mark Delaney, Workplace Ergonomics Consultant, FlexWork Solutions

Delaney notes that companies investing in employee well-being are starting to provide quiet mechanical keyboards as standard issue—particularly in roles involving prolonged typing or customer-facing communication.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use Blue switches in an open office if I type softly?

Even with light typing, Blue switches will still produce a noticeable click. While touch can reduce volume slightly, the inherent design ensures sound generation with every keystroke. Over time, the cumulative effect remains disruptive.

Are Red switches only for gamers?

No. While popular in gaming due to their fast response, Reds are also excellent for typing, programming, and general office work. Their smooth action benefits anyone who values speed and consistency over tactile feedback.

Do silent mechanical switches exist?

Yes. Options like Cherry MX Silent Reds, Gateron Silent Browns, or Kailh Low-Noise switches are engineered to minimize sound through internal dampeners. These are ideal for open offices where even standard Reds might be too loud.

Final Recommendation: Reds Win for Open Offices

When weighing mechanical keyboard switches for an open office, the choice ultimately comes down to responsibility and sustainability. While Blue switches deliver a satisfying, retro-style typing experience, their noise profile makes them poorly suited for shared environments. The constant clicking can erode concentration, prompt complaints, and create unnecessary friction among colleagues.

Red switches, by contrast, offer a balanced compromise: responsive actuation, durability, and a quiet operation that respects the space of others. They support high-performance work without the sonic footprint. For teams emphasizing collaboration, focus, and mutual respect, Reds aren’t just preferable—they’re the professional standard.

If you're upgrading your keyboard or selecting one for a team rollout, prioritize quiet, linear switches. The slight reduction in tactile feedback is far outweighed by the gains in workplace harmony and sustained productivity.

🚀 Ready to upgrade your office setup? Swap out that clicky keyboard for a quieter alternative and notice the difference—in both your focus and your coworkers’ smiles. Share your switch experience in the comments below!