Nintendo DS Vs 3DS: Which Retro Handheld Has The Better Game Library Today

When it comes to portable gaming, few brands evoke nostalgia quite like Nintendo. The DS and 3DS generations defined handheld gaming for over a decade, offering millions of players access to innovative gameplay, beloved franchises, and groundbreaking dual-screen mechanics. Now, as both systems are officially discontinued, collectors and retro gamers face a pressing question: which one holds up better today in terms of game library quality, variety, and replayability?

The answer isn’t straightforward. While the 3DS brought graphical improvements, online features, and autostereoscopic 3D, the original DS laid the foundation with an expansive catalog that still resonates with fans. This article dives deep into both libraries, comparing key titles, exclusives, backward compatibility, and long-term value to determine which system offers the richer experience for modern retro enthusiasts.

Game Library Size and Diversity

One of the most immediate differences between the DS and 3DS is the sheer volume of available games. The Nintendo DS boasts over 1,500 unique titles released across North America alone, with many more in Japan and Europe. Its longevity—spanning from 2004 to 2013—and broad appeal made it a magnet for developers of all sizes, resulting in a diverse mix of genres: puzzle games, RPGs, edutainment, action-adventure, and experimental touch-based titles.

In contrast, the Nintendo 3DS launched in 2011 and was supported until 2020, amassing around 1,000 retail games globally. While smaller in number, the 3DS library is often considered more refined, with tighter curation and stronger first-party support. Many late-generation 3DS titles pushed the hardware to its limits, delivering console-quality experiences in a handheld form.

Where the DS shines is accessibility. Titles like Brain Age, Nintendogs, and Big Brain Academy reached non-traditional gamers, expanding Nintendo’s audience. Meanwhile, the 3DS leaned harder into core gaming demographics with entries in series like Fire Emblem, Paper Mario, and Kid Icarus.

Tip: If you're building a retro collection, consider starting with the DS for broader genre variety, then supplement with 3DS exclusives for polished, story-driven experiences.

Backward Compatibility and System Flexibility

A major factor in favor of the 3DS is its full backward compatibility with Nintendo DS games. Every model of the 3DS (original, XL, 2XL, and New 3DS variants) can play physical DS cartridges, making it a two-in-one solution for retro gaming. This means that by owning a 3DS, you effectively have access to both libraries—provided you’re willing to navigate the slight screen size mismatch when playing DS games on the larger 3DS screen.

The reverse is not true. The original DS cannot play 3DS games, nor does it support digital downloads from the defunct Nintendo eShop (which shut down in March 2023). This makes the 3DS a more future-proof choice despite its discontinuation.

Additionally, the 3DS introduced the Nintendo eShop, allowing users to purchase digital versions of both DS and 3DS titles. Though no new purchases are possible post-shutdown, those who bought games digitally before closure still retain access through redownloads—assuming they haven't deleted their system data.

“The 3DS was Nintendo’s most versatile handheld, bridging the gap between casual DS innovation and hardcore portable gaming.” — Jeremy Parish, Retronauts Host & Gaming Historian

Exclusive Titles and Franchise Evolution

To assess which system has the “better” library, we must examine flagship exclusives—the games you can’t play anywhere else.

Nintendo DS Exclusives Worth Revisiting

• The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass – A direct sequel to The Wind Waker, using stylus controls for sailing and combat.
• Mother 3 – Though never officially localized outside Japan, this cult-classic RPG remains one of the most sought-after DS titles.
• Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow and Portrait of Ruin – Two of the finest entries in the Metroidvania subgenre.
• Pokémon HeartGold/SoulSilver – Remakes of Gen II Pokémon games with DS enhancements like Pokéwalker integration.
• Advance Wars: Dual Strike – Turn-based strategy at its finest, with co-op multiplayer via local wireless.

Nintendo 3DS Exclusives That Defined a Generation

• Paper Mario: Sticker Star and Color Splash – Divisive among fans but visually inventive.
• Fire Emblem: Awakening – Revived the franchise globally and introduced accessible permadeath mechanics.
• Bravely Default – A spiritual successor to Final Fantasy traditions, praised for its job system and narrative depth.
• Kid Icarus: Uprising – Fast-paced aerial combat with dense storytelling by Masahiro Sakurai.
• Luigi’s Mansion: Dark Moon – Charming, atmospheric exploration with strong level design.

While the DS had more quantity, the 3DS delivered higher production values and deeper narratives. However, some argue that the DS offered more gameplay innovation due to its reliance on touch mechanics and microphone use—features that felt fresh at the time.

Comparison Table: Key Metrics at a Glance

Metric	Nintendo DS	Nintendo 3DS
Total Games (NA)	~1,500+	~900+
Backward Compatible?	No	Yes (plays DS carts)
Digital Store Support	Never had one	eShop closed (Mar 2023)
Online Multiplayer	Limited (Wi-Fi Connection)	Robust (SpotPass, StreetPass)
Flagship RPGs	Phantom Hourglass, Golden Sun: Dark Dawn	Fire Emblem: Awakening, Bravely Default
Pokémon Mainline Games	Diamond/Pearl/Platinum, HeartGold/SoulSilver	Black/White, X/Y, Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire
Long-Term Collectibility	High (due to rarity of certain carts)	Very High (limited runs, eShop exclusives)

Real-World Example: The Collector’s Dilemma

Consider Alex, a retro gamer based in Portland who began collecting handhelds in 2020. Initially drawn to the DS for its colorful design and low price on secondhand markets, Alex quickly amassed a library of 40+ games, including rare Japanese imports of Mother 3 and Dragon Quest IX. But after borrowing a friend’s New 3DS, he discovered Fire Emblem: Awakening—a game he’d heard praised for years. The depth of customization, permanent character relationships, and strategic difficulty hooked him instantly.

Faced with limited shelf space and budget, Alex had to decide: double down on the DS or pivot to the 3DS. He eventually chose the latter—not because the DS lacked quality, but because the 3DS allowed him to keep his DS collection while adding hundreds of new experiences. His final setup? A New 3DS XL running both DS carts and homebrew tools to preserve digital titles.

His journey reflects a growing trend: serious collectors are prioritizing the 3DS not just for its own library, but for its ability to serve as a unified platform for both generations.

Step-by-Step Guide: Building the Ultimate Retro Handheld Library

If you're deciding between the two systems—or aiming to collect both—follow this practical guide to maximize your investment:

1. Assess Your Priorities: Are you focused on nostalgia, game variety, or high-quality exclusives? Define your goal before buying hardware.
2. Choose Your Primary Device: For versatility, go with a 3DS (preferably New 3DS XL for better performance and analog nub).
3. Source Physical Cartridges: Buy from reputable sellers; check for save file corruption and battery health (especially in older DS carts).
4. Preserve Digital Content: If you own a 3DS with prior eShop activity, ensure you can redownload purchases. Back up titles using homebrew if legally compliant in your region.
5. Invest in Accessories: SD cards, charging docks, and screen protectors help maintain device longevity.
6. Explore Homebrew Options: Tools like Luma3DS allow emulation enhancements and backup launching, though legality depends on usage and jurisdiction.
7. Join Communities: Engage with forums like GBAtemp or Reddit’s r/3DShacks to stay updated on preservation efforts and fan translations.

Tip: Always test used cartridges before purchasing. Some DS games suffer from dead batteries that prevent saving, especially in RPGs like Final Fantasy III.

FAQ: Common Questions About DS vs 3DS Libraries

Can I still buy digital games for the 3DS?

No. The Nintendo eShop for 3DS and Wii U shut down permanently in March 2023. You can no longer purchase or add funds to accounts. However, users who previously bought games can still re-download them if linked to their Nintendo Network ID.

Are DS games playable on all 3DS models?

Yes. All 3DS family systems—including the New 3DS and 2DS models—support DS cartridge playback. Note that DSi-enhanced games requiring the camera or internal storage may have limitations.

Which system has better Pokémon games?

This is subjective. DS titles like HeartGold/SoulSilver are often praised for their faithful remakes and nostalgic value. However, 3DS entries like Pokémon X/Y introduced fully 3D battles and Mega Evolutions, modernizing the series significantly. Both generations offer compelling experiences, but the 3DS games benefit from smoother pacing and online trading improvements.

Final Verdict: Which Library Reigns Supreme?

The Nintendo DS built an empire on accessibility, innovation, and sheer volume. It introduced touch-based gaming to the mainstream and gave us timeless classics across multiple genres. Its legacy is secure, and its library remains one of the most varied in handheld history.

Yet, the 3DS edges ahead when evaluated through the lens of modern retro gaming. Why? Because it combines its own robust lineup with full access to the DS catalog. It also benefits from superior build quality, better screens, and enhanced audio—making long play sessions more enjoyable. The closure of the eShop stings, but physical media ensures these games remain playable indefinitely.

Moreover, the 3DS era saw Nintendo doubling down on narrative depth and mechanical refinement. Games like Bravely Default and Fire Emblem: Awakening didn’t just entertain—they influenced the direction of JRPGs for years. Even divisive titles sparked passionate discussions, a hallmark of a vibrant library.

Ultimately, if forced to choose only one system for retro gaming today, the **Nintendo 3DS** is the smarter pick. It honors the DS’s legacy while elevating the experience with technical polish and expanded functionality. But dismissing the DS would be a mistake. Together, they represent the peak of Nintendo’s handheld dominance—a golden age where creativity met mass appeal.

“Between the DS’s experimentation and the 3DS’s refinement, we got over a decade of handheld brilliance. You don’t need to pick a favorite—you just need to play them both.” — Patricia Hernandez, Senior Editor at Kotaku

Take Action: Preserve the Legacy

The end of official support doesn’t mean the end of these platforms. With proper care, community-driven preservation, and thoughtful collecting, both the DS and 3DS can continue to deliver joy for years to come. Whether you’re reliving childhood memories or discovering these gems for the first time, now is the time to explore, share, and celebrate these remarkable systems.

💬 What’s your favorite DS or 3DS game? Share your top picks and hidden gems in the comments—help keep the conversation alive for future retro gamers!