Pixel 3 Vs Galaxy S9 Three Years Later Is The Pixel Still Worth It

It’s been over three years since the Google Pixel 3 and Samsung Galaxy S9 hit the market—two flagships that defined their era in different ways. The Pixel 3 brought pure Android, unmatched camera quality, and AI-driven features. The Galaxy S9 countered with a dynamic AMOLED display, expandable storage, and Samsung’s ecosystem polish. Fast forward to today: both phones are long past their prime support cycles, yet they still circulate in secondhand markets and budget-conscious circles. So, is the Pixel 3 still worth choosing over the Galaxy S9 in 2024? The answer isn’t as simple as specs suggest.

Performance and Hardware Longevity

At launch, both devices were powered by top-tier chipsets—the Pixel 3 used the Qualcomm Snapdragon 845, as did the Galaxy S9 (in most regions). On paper, they were equals. But real-world longevity tells a different story.

The Pixel 3, while efficient, came with only 4GB of RAM—a decision Google justified with its aggressive memory management. In contrast, the Galaxy S9 shipped with 4GB as well, but Samsung’s heavier One UI demands more resources over time. Both phones now struggle with multitasking, app reloads, and background processes, especially when running modern versions of Android.

Battery degradation is another critical factor. The Pixel 3 had a modest 2,915mAh battery, while the S9 packed 3,000mAh. After three years of charging cycles, both likely retain only 60–70% of their original capacity. However, users report the Pixel 3’s battery management remains slightly more predictable due to minimal bloatware.

Tip: If buying used, check battery health via developer settings or third-party apps like AccuBattery before committing.

Software and Security: Where the Pixel Shines

One area where the Pixel 3 clearly outperforms the Galaxy S9 even today is software support. Google guaranteed three years of OS and security updates for the Pixel 3, meaning it received Android 12 and patches through late 2021. The Galaxy S9, despite Samsung’s improved update policy in recent years, only received up to Android 10 and stopped receiving major updates earlier.

As of 2024, neither phone receives official security patches. However, the Pixel 3 ran cleaner, faster software for longer. Its stock Android experience also makes it a favorite among enthusiasts who flash custom ROMs like LineageOS. The Galaxy S9 supports custom firmware too, but the process is more fragmented due to regional variants and carrier locks.

“Even outdated, Pixels age more gracefully because Google designs them from the ground up for software efficiency.” — David Kim, Mobile Systems Analyst

Camera Comparison: Still a Pixel Strength?

The camera was the Pixel 3’s crown jewel at launch—and remarkably, it still holds up in many scenarios. Despite having just a single rear lens (the XL had a telephoto), Google’s computational photography—HDR+, Night Sight, Super Res Zoom—delivers impressive results in daylight and low light.

In side-by-side tests today, the Pixel 3 often beats the Galaxy S9 in dynamic range and noise reduction, especially in dim lighting. The S9’s dual-pixel sensor captures vibrant colors and has optical image stabilization, but its processing tends to oversharpen and oversaturate, aging less gracefully.

The front cameras tell an even starker story. The Pixel 3’s wide-angle dual-front shooters (8MP each) allow for natural group selfies. The S9’s single 8MP front camera lacks width and depth, making it less versatile.

Feature	Pixel 3	Galaxy S9
Rear Camera	12.2MP, f/1.8, OIS	12MP, f/1.5–f/2.4, Dual Aperture, OIS
Front Camera	Dual 8MP, wide-angle	Single 8MP, f/1.7
Night Mode	Yes (via software)	No native night mode
Video Recording	4K@30fps, steady cam	4K@60fps, superior stabilization

The S9 wins in video recording flexibility, supporting 4K at 60fps and smoother stabilization. But for still photography—especially point-and-shoot convenience—the Pixel 3 remains surprisingly competitive.

Real-World Use Case: Can Either Phone Be a Daily Driver in 2024?

Consider Mark, a freelance writer who bought a used Pixel 3 in 2022 for $80. He wanted a lightweight, distraction-free device for emails, note-taking, and occasional photography. Two years later, he still uses it as his secondary phone. “It boots fast, takes great photos, and doesn’t bombard me with ads or bloat,” he says. “I’ve replaced the battery, and with /e/ OS installed, it feels snappier than my old S9 ever did.”

Meanwhile, Sarah, a college student, picked up a Galaxy S9 for $60 in 2021. She liked the expandable storage and headphone jack. But by 2023, she noticed frequent app crashes, slow updates, and degraded battery life. “It worked okay for a year, but now it struggles with Instagram and Chrome,” she admits. She upgraded to a mid-range 2023 model last month.

This contrast highlights a key insight: both phones can function in 2024, but the experience depends heavily on usage patterns and expectations. Light users may find the Pixel 3 sufficient; heavier users will hit limitations quickly.

Step-by-Step: How to Extend Life If You Own Either Phone

If you’re holding onto a Pixel 3 or Galaxy S9, here’s how to maximize its lifespan in 2024:

1. Replace the battery – A new OEM or high-quality third-party battery can restore 80–90% of original performance.
2. Install a lightweight OS – Consider /e/ OS, LineageOS, or GrapheneOS for better speed and privacy.
3. Limit background apps – Disable auto-start and restrict battery usage for non-essential apps.
4. Use Lite versions of apps – Facebook Lite, Twitter Lite, and YouTube Vanced reduce strain.
5. Clear cache monthly – Go to Settings > Storage > Clear Cache to maintain responsiveness.

Tip: Avoid installing Play Store-heavy devices without Google services if you rely on Gmail or Maps—use microG instead.

Checklist: Is It Smart to Buy a Used Pixel 3 or S9 Today?

• ✅ Need a backup or emergency phone? → Yes, both can serve this role.
• ✅ Want a clean Android experience? → Choose Pixel 3.
• ✅ Need expandable storage or headphone amp? → Galaxy S9 has advantages.
• ✅ Planning to root or customize? → Pixel 3 has better developer support.
• ❌ Using banking apps or modern social platforms daily? → Expect slowdowns and compatibility issues.
• ❌ Prioritize battery life? → Neither excels—consider newer budget phones instead.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the Pixel 3 run Android 13 or 14?

No, Google ended official support after Android 12. However, community developers have ported Android 13 and 14 to the Pixel 3 via custom ROMs, though stability varies.

Which phone has better build quality?

The Galaxy S9 feels more premium with its glass back and aluminum frame, plus IP68 water resistance. The Pixel 3 also has IP68 but uses a glossy finish that attracts fingerprints and scratches easily.

Is the Pixel 3 camera better than newer mid-range phones?

In daylight and moderate lighting, yes—its processing still produces natural-looking photos. However, in extreme low light or for zoom, even budget 2023 phones with multiple lenses outperform it.

Final Verdict: Is the Pixel 3 Still Worth It?

In a straight comparison today, the Pixel 3 edges out the Galaxy S9—not because it’s more powerful, but because it aged with purpose. Its software cleanliness, superior camera algorithms, and strong developer community give it staying power the S9 lacks. For collectors, tinkerers, or minimalists seeking a compact, no-frills device, the Pixel 3 remains a compelling relic.

That said, neither phone should be anyone’s primary device in 2024 unless necessity dictates. Modern budget smartphones like the Pixel 6a, Samsung A14, or OnePlus Nord offer better batteries, faster chips, and ongoing support at similar price points.

If you already own a Pixel 3, optimize it with a battery swap and a lightweight OS. If you're considering buying one used, go in with low expectations—treat it as a temporary solution or hobby device, not a long-term investment.

🚀 Still using a Pixel 3 or S9? Share your experience below. How has it held up for you? Your insights could help others decide whether these classics deserve a second life.