Samsung Note 8 Vs S8 Is The Upgrade Worth It Even Now

Even years after their release, the Samsung Galaxy Note 8 and Galaxy S8 remain topics of discussion among budget-conscious buyers and tech enthusiasts exploring older flagship models. While both phones were top-tier in 2017, the question persists: does the jump from the S8 to the Note 8 still justify the price difference today? Whether you're considering a secondhand purchase or evaluating trade-in options, understanding the tangible differences—and how they hold up in 2024—is essential.

The S8 set a new standard for smartphone design with its edge-to-edge display and refined software experience. The Note 8 built on that foundation, adding premium features tailored for productivity and creativity. But as we move further into the era of AI-powered devices and long-term software support, the relevance of these aging flagships depends heavily on your usage patterns and expectations.

Design and Display: Subtle Evolution, Not Revolution

At first glance, the Galaxy S8 and Note 8 look nearly identical. Both feature curved AMOLED displays, glass backs, and aluminum frames. However, closer inspection reveals meaningful differences. The S8 sports a 5.8-inch Quad HD+ display, while the Note 8 steps up to a larger 6.3-inch panel—offering more screen real estate without drastically increasing device width due to its taller 18.5:9 aspect ratio.

This extra space benefits multitasking and media consumption. Samsung introduced split-screen functionality more prominently with the Note 8, taking advantage of the larger canvas. For users who frequently read documents, watch videos, or use dual apps, the size difference becomes noticeable over time.

Tip: If you prioritize one-handed use, the S8 remains more compact and easier to handle than the Note 8.

Both phones are IP68-rated for water and dust resistance and support Samsung DeX via an adapter—a feature that turns your phone into a desktop-like interface. However, only the Note 8 includes the S Pen, which fundamentally changes how you interact with the device.

Performance and Software: Aging Gracefully?

Under the hood, both phones launched with either the Qualcomm Snapdragon 835 or Exynos 8895 (depending on region), delivering smooth performance for everyday tasks at the time. In 2024, neither chip can compete with modern mid-range processors in raw power, but they’re still capable of handling basic apps like messaging, web browsing, and streaming if optimized well.

Software support ended years ago; neither device receives major Android updates beyond Android 9 Pie with One UI 1.1. Security patches ceased entirely by 2020. This lack of ongoing support poses real risks, especially for users who rely on banking apps, secure messaging platforms, or services requiring updated encryption protocols.

“Phones stuck on outdated OS versions become vulnerable targets. Even minor delays in patching can expose users to known exploits.” — David Lin, Mobile Security Analyst at CyberShield Labs

If security and app compatibility are priorities, consider this a significant drawback. Many newer versions of popular apps no longer optimize for such old operating systems, leading to crashes or missing features.

Camera Comparison: Dual Lenses Make a Difference

The camera is where the Note 8 pulls decisively ahead. The S8 features a single 12MP rear sensor with Dual Pixel autofocus and f/1.7 aperture—an excellent shooter for its time. The Note 8 introduces a dual-camera system: a primary 12MP f/1.7 lens paired with a secondary 12MP telephoto lens (f/2.4), enabling 2x optical zoom and improved portrait mode effects.

In practical terms, this means clearer close-ups without digital noise, better background blur in low light, and greater creative flexibility. For users interested in photography—even casually—the Note 8’s added depth sensor offers tangible benefits.

Feature	Samsung Galaxy S8	Samsung Galaxy Note 8
Rear Camera	12MP (f/1.7)	12MP + 12MP dual (f/1.7 + f/2.4)
Optical Zoom	No	2x
Portrait Mode	Digital simulation	Hardware-assisted
Front Camera	8MP (f/1.7)	8MP (f/1.7)
Video Recording	4K @ 30fps	4K @ 30fps

The front-facing cameras are identical, so selfies and video calls perform similarly across both devices. However, the Note 8’s ability to capture more dimensionally accurate bokeh effects gives it an edge for social media creators or those who enjoy stylized photography.

The S Pen Factor: More Than Just a Stylus

The defining feature of the Note series is the S Pen, and the Note 8 marks the first model where it became truly integral to the user experience. Unlike earlier versions, the S Pen here supports pressure sensitivity (4,096 levels) and enables functions like live message creation, screen-off memos, and precise editing.

You can write directly on screenshots, translate text in real time using the Air Command menu, or create animated GIFs from handwritten notes. These tools may seem niche, but for students, professionals, or artists, they add functional value unmatched by the S8.

• Take quick notes without unlocking the phone
• Edit photos or PDFs with pixel-level accuracy
• Use magnify, smart select, and translation tools hands-free

In a world increasingly reliant on digital annotation and remote collaboration, the S Pen transforms the Note 8 into a mini productivity hub. The S8 lacks any stylus support, limiting interaction to touch alone.

Real-World Example: Maria’s Upgrade Decision

Maria, a freelance graphic designer and part-time instructor, used her Galaxy S8 for five years before considering a replacement. She needed a phone that could handle sketching ideas during client calls, annotating design proofs, and managing course materials—all on the go.

She tested both phones side-by-side. While the S8 still booted apps quickly, she found herself frustrated when trying to mark up images. Without a stylus, she had to rely on clumsy finger gestures or third-party apps. When she switched to a refurbished Note 8, the S Pen allowed her to highlight areas, add handwritten feedback, and save annotated files directly to cloud storage.

“It felt like going from typing on a keyboard with gloves to using bare fingers,” she said. “The precision changed how I work.” Despite the age of the hardware, the workflow improvement made the Note 8 feel current for her needs.

Is the Upgrade Worth It Today? A Practical Checklist

Before deciding whether the Note 8 is worth stepping up from the S8—or choosing between them outright—consider the following checklist:

1. Evaluate your need for the S Pen: Do you take notes, draw, or edit documents regularly?
2. Assess software longevity: Are you comfortable using a phone without security updates?
3. Check app compatibility: Will your essential apps run smoothly on Android 9?
4. Compare condition and price: On the secondhand market, is the Note 8 priced significantly higher?
5. Consider battery health: After years of charging cycles, original batteries degrade—can replacements be easily sourced?

Tip: Always verify battery cycle count and physical condition when buying used. Refurbished units vary widely in quality.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the Galaxy Note 8 still receive app updates?

Some apps will continue to function, but many developers have dropped support for devices running below Android 10. Banking, ride-sharing, and communication apps may stop working or fail to install altogether.

Is the S Pen replaceable if lost?

Yes, genuine S Pens for the Note 8 are available through Samsung and third-party retailers. They’re relatively affordable and easy to pair—no setup required.

Which phone lasts longer on battery?

The Note 8 has a slightly larger 3,300mAh battery compared to the S8’s 3,000mAh, but its bigger screen offsets gains. Real-world usage shows similar endurance: about one full day with moderate use. Neither supports fast charging out of the box (without a compatible charger).

Final Verdict: Value Depends on Use Case

For most general users in 2024, neither the Galaxy S8 nor the Note 8 should be a primary phone choice. Modern entry-level smartphones offer better performance, longer software support, and improved cameras. However, if you're on a tight budget and need a temporary device, the decision hinges on functionality.

The Galaxy S8 is sufficient for calls, texts, and casual browsing. But if you value handwriting input, multitasking, or enhanced photography features, the Note 8 delivers meaningful advantages—even today. Its combination of dual cameras, larger display, and S Pen utility creates a unique niche that few older phones fill.

Ultimately, the upgrade from S8 to Note 8 was justified in 2017. Now, it’s only worthwhile if your workflow benefits directly from the S Pen or dual-lens camera. Otherwise, investing in a newer budget model would provide better long-term reliability and security.

💬 Still using a Galaxy Note 8 or S8? Share your experience! How has it held up over the years? Your insights could help others make smarter decisions about legacy devices.