Comotomo Vs Tommee Tippee Bottles Is The Hype Around Comotomo Really Worth It

Choosing the right baby bottle can feel overwhelming. With so many brands claiming to reduce colic, mimic breastfeeding, and offer leak-proof convenience, parents are left wondering which actually delivers. Two of the most talked-about options—Comotomo and Tommee Tippee—are often praised for their innovative designs and parent-friendly features. But when placed side by side, does Comotomo truly live up to its premium price and viral reputation, or is Tommee Tippee the smarter, more practical choice?

This comparison dives deep into materials, flow rates, cleaning ease, anti-colic performance, and real-world usability to help you decide whether the Comotomo hype is justified—or if Tommee Tippee offers better value for your everyday needs.

Design and Material Differences

The first noticeable difference between Comotomo and Tommee Tippee bottles lies in their construction and aesthetics.

Comotomo bottles are made from ultra-soft, medical-grade silicone that mimics the look and feel of a natural breast. This flexible material allows the bottle to collapse as the baby drinks, reducing air intake. The wide base provides stability, and the large opening makes filling and cleaning easier than with narrow-necked bottles. However, the softness can make handling tricky for older babies or during one-handed feeding.

Tommee Tippee’s Advanced Anti-Colic bottles, on the other hand, feature a rigid polypropylene body with a unique venting system embedded in the nipple. The anti-colic valve runs through the teat and opens under suction to let air escape into the bottle rather than into the baby’s stomach. The design is more traditional in shape but engineered specifically to combat gas and spit-up.

Tip: If you're exclusively pumping or alternating with breastfeeding, Comotomo's breast-like texture may help with nipple confusion prevention.

Anti-Colic Performance: How Do They Really Stack Up?

Gas, reflux, and colic are common concerns for new parents, making this a critical factor in bottle selection.

Comotomo relies on its collapsible silicone walls to prevent air bubbles from forming. As the baby feeds, the bottle compresses, maintaining negative pressure and minimizing swallowed air. Many parents report fewer burps and less fussiness after switching to Comotomo, especially in newborns prone to gassiness.

Tommee Tippee takes a mechanical approach. Its anti-colic valve actively vents air to the back of the bottle, away from the milk. Clinical studies have shown this system reduces colic symptoms in over 80% of babies within a week of use. Unlike passive systems, the valve requires correct assembly—meaning the vent must face upward and be free of blockages—but when used properly, it’s highly effective.

“Bottle-fed infants who experience frequent gas often benefit more from active venting systems like Tommee Tippee’s than passive compression alone.” — Dr. Lena Patel, Pediatric Nutrition Specialist

Flow Rate and Nipple Design

Nipple design directly affects feeding comfort, pace, and potential for choking or fatigue.

Comotomo uses wide, flat-tipped nipples with multiple slits (typically two) that open under suction. Flow is generally medium to fast, even in “slow” flow versions. Some parents find this too intense for newborns, leading to gulping or milk spraying. Replacement nipples come in different stages, but the variation between them is subtle compared to other brands.

Tommee Tippee offers distinct flow levels—from slow (0–3 months) to extra slow (preemie) and variable flow options. The nipple has a butterfly-shaped base that collapses slightly during sucking, aiding latch transition for breastfed babies. The precision-engineered teats allow controlled milk release, reducing the risk of overfeeding or aspiration.

Feature	Comotomo	Tommee Tippee
Material	Medical-grade silicone (soft)	Polypropylene + silicone nipple
Anti-Colic System	Passive (bottle collapse)	Active (integrated valve)
Cleaning Ease	Very easy (wide mouth)	Moderate (valve disassembly needed)
Dishwasher Safe	Yes (top rack)	Yes (all parts)
Price per Bottle (approx.)	$14–$18	$7–$10
Leak Resistance	Fair (silicone flex can cause seepage)	Good (tight screw ring + seal)

Real Parent Experience: A Mini Case Study

Sarah, a first-time mom from Manchester, tried both bottles after her daughter showed signs of colic at three weeks old. Initially drawn to Comotomo’s soft appearance and rave reviews online, she found the bottles difficult to sterilize fully due to their depth and width. “They looked clean, but I could still smell milk residue after boiling,” she said. She also noticed slight leaking when placing them in her diaper bag.

Switching to Tommee Tippee, Sarah appreciated the straightforward assembly and consistent flow. “The difference wasn’t overnight, but within five days, my baby was taking longer naps after feeds and seemed less tense.” While she missed the aesthetic of Comotomo, she prioritized function over form. “I realized I didn’t need a ‘natural’ bottle—I needed one that worked.”

Her experience reflects a broader trend: while Comotomo wins points for innovation and visual appeal, Tommee Tippee often outperforms in reliability and long-term usability.

Step-by-Step Guide: Choosing the Right Bottle for Your Baby

Follow these steps to determine which bottle suits your feeding style and baby’s needs:

1. Assess Feeding Type: Are you breastfeeding, formula feeding, or combination feeding? Breastfed babies may adapt better to Comotomo’s soft texture, while formula-fed infants might benefit more from Tommee Tippee’s controlled flow.
2. Monitor for Colic Signs: Frequent crying, pulling legs up, bloating, or excessive burping suggest air ingestion. Try Tommee Tippee first for proven anti-colic results.
3. Test Flow Sensitivity: If your baby chokes, gulps, or falls asleep mid-feed, experiment with slower-flow nipples. Tommee Tippee offers clearer progression across stages.
4. Evaluate Cleaning Routine: Do you hand-wash or use a sterilizer? Comotomo’s wide neck is easier to scrub, but Tommee Tippee parts are dishwasher-safe and dry quickly.
5. Budget Consideration: At nearly double the price, Comotomo demands justification. Buy one to test, but consider Tommee Tippee for bulk purchases.

Tip: Always test one bottle before buying a full set. Babies vary widely in preference, and what works for one may frustrate another.

Checklist: Key Questions Before You Buy

• Does my baby struggle with gas or reflux?
• Am I transitioning from breastfeeding?
• Do I need bottles that fit easily in a bottle warmer or sterilizer?
• How important is leak resistance when carrying bottles out?
• Am I comfortable disassembling small parts for cleaning?
• Is cost a limiting factor for long-term use?

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use Tommee Tippee nipples on Comotomo bottles?

No, the threading and neck designs are incompatible. Each brand uses proprietary sizing, so mixing components isn't recommended for safety and sealing reasons.

Are Comotomo bottles safer because they’re BPA-free and silicone?

Both brands are BPA-free and meet international safety standards. Silicone is durable and heat-resistant, but rigidity doesn’t imply lower safety. Tommee Tippee’s plastic is food-grade and rigorously tested.

Which bottle lasts longer?

Tommee Tippee tends to show less wear over time. Comotomo’s silicone can develop micro-tears near the rim after repeated sterilization, especially if clipped improperly in a steamer. Proper care extends lifespan for both.

Final Verdict: Is the Hype Worth It?

Comotomo bottles are undeniably innovative. Their breast-mimicking design, wide mouth, and soft touch offer a unique feeding experience that appeals to many new parents—especially those committed to replicating breastfeeding mechanics. For babies sensitive to texture or transitioning from the breast, Comotomo can be a game-changer.

However, the hype often overshadows practical drawbacks: higher cost, inconsistent flow control, and moderate leak resistance. When evaluated purely on performance—particularly colic reduction, durability, and value—Tommee Tippee consistently delivers stronger, evidence-backed results at a more accessible price point.

If you're looking for a bottle that combines clinical effectiveness, ease of use, and affordability, Tommee Tippee is likely the better investment. Comotomo shines in niche scenarios but doesn’t universally outperform its competitor. The truth is, the “best” bottle isn’t the most expensive or Instagram-worthy—it’s the one your baby takes willingly, without discomfort, day after day.

💬 Have you tried both Comotomo and Tommee Tippee? Share your experience below—your insights could help another parent make a confident choice.