Huawei Y5 2017 Vs Samsung J5 Prime Is It Worth Upgrading In Current Year

For users still holding onto a Huawei Y5 2017, the question isn't just about whether to upgrade—it's about whether the jump to a slightly newer device like the Samsung Galaxy J5 Prime offers tangible benefits in today’s mobile ecosystem. Released just months apart in late 2016 and early 2017, both phones were entry-level devices designed for budget-conscious consumers. But nearly seven years later, their relevance has shifted dramatically. This analysis compares the two handsets across key categories—performance, software support, camera quality, battery life, and real-world usability—to determine if the upgrade makes sense in 2024.

Performance and Hardware Comparison

The core experience of any smartphone hinges on its hardware. The Huawei Y5 2017 runs on a MediaTek MT6737 quad-core processor clocked at 1.4 GHz, paired with 2GB of RAM and 16GB of internal storage. It supports microSD expansion up to 32GB. In contrast, the Samsung Galaxy J5 Prime features an Exynos 7570—also a quad-core chip but built on a more efficient 14nm process—alongside 2GB of RAM and 16GB or 32GB storage options (depending on region), expandable up to 256GB via microSD.

In practical terms, the Exynos 7570 provides marginally better power efficiency and smoother multitasking. While neither device handles modern apps with ease, the J5 Prime manages background processes and light gaming (like Candy Crush or older versions of PUBG Mobile) with fewer stutters. Benchmark scores reflect this: the J5 Prime typically scores 20–25% higher in synthetic tests like AnTuTu v6 (around 40,000 vs. 32,000).

Tip: If you're upgrading solely for performance, consider that even modest improvements may not translate to smooth social media or web browsing due to outdated software and limited RAM.

Software and Security: A Critical Gap

Software support is where the gap between these devices becomes most apparent. The Huawei Y5 2017 launched with Android 7.0 Nougat and received one major update to Android 8.0 Oreo. However, due to U.S. trade restrictions, it never received critical security patches beyond mid-2019. As of 2024, it cannot safely connect to many modern services without risking data exposure.

The Samsung J5 Prime, meanwhile, shipped with Android 6.0 Marshmallow and was updated to Android 8.1 Oreo. Samsung also provided monthly security updates until late 2020. While both phones are now unsupported, the J5 Prime had a longer patch cycle and better integration with Google Play Protect, offering a safer environment for basic tasks like email or messaging—even today.

“Security updates are non-negotiable in 2024. Devices without them should be treated as offline tools only.” — David Lin, Mobile Security Analyst at TechShield Labs

Camera Quality and Everyday Use

Photography expectations must be realistic with either device. The Huawei Y5 2017 features an 8MP rear camera with LED flash and a 5MP front-facing shooter. Image quality is soft, lacks detail in low light, and autofocus is slow. Video recording caps at 720p.

The Samsung J5 Prime improves slightly with a 13MP f/1.9 rear sensor—the wider aperture helps in dim conditions—and a 5MP front camera with screen-based flash. Photos exhibit better dynamic range and color accuracy under daylight. While neither phone competes with modern budget cameras, the J5 Prime delivers noticeably clearer images and faster shutter response.

Feature	Huawei Y5 2017	Samsung J5 Prime
Rear Camera	8MP, f/2.0, AF	13MP, f/1.9, AF
Front Camera	5MP, f/2.2	5MP, f/2.2, selfie flash
Video Recording	720p@30fps	1080p@30fps
Flash	LED	LED

Battery Life and Charging Experience

The Huawei Y5 2017 packs a 3000mAh battery, which delivered around 1.5 days of light use back in 2017. Today, degraded batteries often last less than 8 hours with minimal screen time. It charges via micro-USB at 5W, taking over 2.5 hours for a full charge.

The J5 Prime uses a smaller 2400mAh cell but benefits from the more power-efficient Exynos chip and optimized Android firmware. Real-world usage shows similar endurance—about 10–12 hours—but with faster standby recovery and lower idle drain. Like the Y5, it uses micro-USB charging and takes approximately 2 hours to reach 100%.

Neither device supports fast charging or wireless power. Battery degradation after 6+ years means replacement is likely necessary for reliable daily use—adding cost to the upgrade equation.

Real-World Example: Maria’s Upgrade Dilemma

Maria, a retiree in Manila, has used her Huawei Y5 2017 since 2018 primarily for calls, WhatsApp, and Facebook. By early 2023, she noticed the phone freezing during video calls and failing to load news websites. She considered switching to a J5 Prime after seeing one listed secondhand for $45.

After testing the J5 Prime for a week, she found that while WhatsApp opened faster and Facebook scrolled more smoothly, she still couldn’t install newer versions of Google Meet or access updated banking apps requiring Android 9+. Ultimately, she opted for a newer Android Go device instead, citing long-term usability over marginal gains.

Maria’s case illustrates a broader truth: incremental upgrades between obsolete devices offer limited value when ecosystem compatibility matters more than raw specs.

Step-by-Step Guide: Should You Upgrade?

If you’re evaluating this upgrade path, follow this decision framework:

1. Assess your current phone’s condition: Does it power on reliably? Is the touchscreen responsive? If not, repair costs may exceed device value.
2. List your essential apps: Check if they still support Android 7 or 8. Many banking, ride-sharing, and shopping apps now require Android 9+.
3. Test the J5 Prime in person: Look for lag in app launches, poor Wi-Fi connectivity, or swollen batteries.
4. Compare total cost: Factor in potential battery replacement (~$15–20) and accessories.
5. Consider alternatives: New Android Go phones (like Nokia C12 or Samsung Galaxy A05s) start at $80 and offer 3+ years of updates.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use WhatsApp on both phones in 2024?

WhatsApp officially dropped support for Android 4.1–7.1.1 in early 2023. While some users report partial functionality, message delivery failures and login issues are common. Neither phone is fully supported moving forward.

Is the Samsung J5 Prime waterproof?

No. The J5 Prime has no official IP rating. It lacks dust or water resistance, so exposure to moisture can cause permanent damage—especially given aging seals on used units.

Will either phone receive future Android updates?

No. Both devices have reached end-of-life. No further OS or security updates will be released by Huawei or Samsung.

Final Verdict: Is the Upgrade Worth It?

Technically, the Samsung J5 Prime outperforms the Huawei Y5 2017 in processing efficiency, camera output, and software longevity. However, in the context of 2024, the improvement is marginal and short-lived. You’re upgrading from one obsolete device to another with similar limitations: outdated operating systems, incompatible apps, degraded hardware, and security risks.

If your goal is merely to extend the life of a basic communication tool for emergencies or offline use, the J5 Prime might be a tolerable stopgap—provided it’s in excellent condition and priced below $50. But if you need reliable access to modern apps, secure browsing, or clear video calling, investing in a current-gen entry-level smartphone is far more cost-effective and practical.

🚀 Take action today: Instead of trading one outdated phone for another, explore certified refurbished models or budget Android Go devices that offer real longevity. Your digital safety and daily convenience depend on it.