Pixel 4 Xl Vs Galaxy S20 Is The Older Google Phone Still Worth It

In the fast-moving world of smartphones, two years can feel like a lifetime. The Google Pixel 4 XL launched in 2019, while the Samsung Galaxy S20 arrived in early 2020—both now considered legacy devices. Yet, they still surface in secondhand markets and budget-conscious buyer discussions. With flagship-tier specs at discounted prices, the question arises: is the older Google Pixel 4 XL still competitive against the slightly newer Galaxy S20?

The answer isn’t straightforward. While both phones were top performers in their day, their current relevance depends on usage patterns, software support, and personal priorities like camera quality or ecosystem loyalty. Let’s break down how these devices stack up today.

Performance and Hardware Comparison

The Pixel 4 XL runs on the Qualcomm Snapdragon 855, a powerful chipset for its time, paired with 6GB of RAM. The Galaxy S20 steps up with the slightly improved Snapdragon 865 (or Exynos 990 in some regions), 8GB or 12GB of RAM depending on storage variant, and UFS 3.0 storage—faster than the Pixel’s UFS 2.1.

In real-world use, this means the S20 handles multitasking and app loading more efficiently, especially under heavy loads. For light users—those checking email, browsing social media, and streaming video—the difference may be negligible. But for anyone running multiple apps, using photo editing tools, or playing graphics-intensive games, the S20 pulls ahead.

However, hardware longevity isn’t just about raw speed. Thermal management and sustained performance matter. The Pixel 4 XL has been known to throttle under prolonged load due to modest cooling design, while the S20’s larger chassis allows better heat dissipation.

“Even mid-tier phones today outperform the Snapdragon 855 in AI and efficiency tasks. But for basic workflows, older flagships remain usable—if you accept some lag.” — Rajiv Mehta, Mobile Analyst at TechPulse Insights

Display and Design: A Tale of Two Philosophies

The Galaxy S20 introduced Samsung’s 6.2-inch Dynamic AMOLED 2X display with a 120Hz refresh rate—a major leap over the Pixel 4 XL’s 90Hz Smooth Display. While 30Hz doesn’t sound like much, the fluidity of scrolling, animations, and gaming on the S20 is noticeably smoother.

Both screens are bright, vibrant, and HDR-capable, but the S20 also offers QHD+ resolution (3200 x 1440) compared to the Pixel’s 1440 x 3040 panel. In practice, both look sharp, though the S20 gives users the option to toggle between FHD+ and QHD+, balancing clarity and battery life.

Design-wise, the Pixel 4 XL stands out with its minimalist front and distinctive two-tone back. It lacks an in-display fingerprint sensor, relying instead on face unlock and a rear-mounted sensor. The Galaxy S20 uses ultrasonic in-display fingerprint tech, which works reliably even with wet fingers.

Tip: If you frequently use your phone outdoors, prioritize brightness and auto-brightness accuracy. The S20’s higher peak brightness (~1200 nits) gives it an edge in sunlight readability.

Camera: Where Google Still Shines

This is where the Pixel 4 XL refuses to fade into obscurity. Despite having fewer lenses, its dual-camera system—12.2MP main + 16MP telephoto—delivers exceptional dynamic range, color accuracy, and low-light performance thanks to Google’s computational photography.

The Galaxy S20 features a triple setup: 12MP main, 64MP telephoto (hybrid zoom), and 12MP ultra-wide. On paper, it’s superior. In practice, Samsung’s processing sometimes oversaturates colors and struggles with noise in dim lighting. The Pixel consistently produces natural-looking photos with excellent HDR and detail preservation.

For video, both shoot 4K at 60fps, but the Pixel’s stabilization and audio processing are more refined. The S20 offers 8K recording—a novelty at the time—but it drains battery quickly and offers little practical benefit for most users.

Feature	Pixel 4 XL	Galaxy S20
Main Camera	12.2MP, f/1.7	12MP, f/1.8
Telephoto	16MP, 2x optical	64MP, 3x hybrid
Ultra-Wide	No	12MP, f/2.2
Night Sight	Yes, best-in-class	Night Mode, decent
Video	4K@30/60fps, excellent stabilization	4K@60fps, 8K@24fps

Battery Life and Charging: A Clear Winner

The Pixel 4 XL’s 3700mAh battery was underwhelming even in 2019. With moderate use, it barely lasts a full day. Fast charging (18W) helps, but wireless charging is limited to 11W, and there’s no reverse wireless charging.

In contrast, the Galaxy S20 packs a 4000mAh battery and supports 25W fast charging, 15W wireless, and 4.5W reverse wireless charging. Real-world testing shows the S20 consistently delivers a day and a half of light use, making it far more practical for travelers or busy professionals.

Software optimizations also play a role. Android 14 (as of 2024) runs on both devices via custom ROMs or unofficial builds, but neither receives official updates. The Pixel stopped at Android 13, while the S20 received four major OS upgrades, ending with Android 14.

Mini Case Study: Sarah’s Upgrade Dilemma

Sarah, a freelance photographer, needed a reliable backup phone for client meetings and quick social media uploads. She considered buying a used Pixel 4 XL for $120 due to its legendary camera. After testing one for a week, she returned it. “The battery died by 3 PM every day, and the lack of ultra-wide made framing group shots difficult,” she said. She switched to a Galaxy S20 for $160 and found the extra lens, longer battery, and smoother display made a tangible difference in her workflow—even if the photos weren’t quite as crisp in low light.

Software Support and Long-Term Viability

This is the Achilles’ heel of both devices. The Pixel 4 XL reached end-of-life in 2023, meaning no further security patches or OS updates from Google. The Galaxy S20, despite launching later, also ended support in 2024 after four years—an improvement over past Samsung policies but still limiting.

Without regular updates, both phones become increasingly vulnerable to security flaws. App developers may drop compatibility over time. Messaging apps, banking tools, and streaming services often require newer OS versions.

That said, enthusiast communities keep these devices alive. Custom ROMs like LineageOS or crDroid offer Android 13–14 experiences with ongoing security improvements. However, installing them requires technical know-how and voids any remaining warranty.

Tip: Before buying any discontinued phone, check XDA Developers forums to see if active ROM development exists for the model.

Is the Pixel 4 XL Still Worth It? A Practical Checklist

If you’re considering either device in 2024, ask yourself the following:

• Do I need guaranteed security updates? → Neither qualifies.
• Is camera quality my top priority? → Pixel 4 XL wins for point-and-shoot excellence.
• Do I want ultra-wide or high-zoom photography? → Galaxy S20 is the only option.
• Will I use the phone heavily throughout the day? → S20’s battery is significantly better.
• Am I comfortable with potential app incompatibility in 2025+? → Yes, if you accept trade-offs.
• Is budget under $150? → Both fit, but availability varies.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the Pixel 4 XL run modern apps smoothly?

Most everyday apps—WhatsApp, Instagram, Chrome, YouTube—run adequately. However, newer AR apps, high-end games, and multitasking-heavy workflows will expose performance limitations. Expect occasional stutters and slower app launches compared to modern mid-range phones.

Does the Galaxy S20 have better resale value?

Currently, no significant difference. Both sell for $100–$180 depending on condition. The S20 holds value slightly better due to broader appeal, but neither appreciates. Buying used is smarter than selling one now.

Is Face Unlock on the Pixel 4 XL secure?

It uses infrared detection and works in the dark, but lacks the spoof resistance of Apple’s Face ID. It can be tricked by high-resolution masks in lab conditions. For most users, it’s convenient but not bank-grade secure. Use a PIN or fingerprint as backup.

Final Verdict: Who Should Buy Which?

The Galaxy S20 is the more balanced choice in 2024. Its superior display, longer battery, extra camera lens, and extended software support make it a more future-proof option. It’s ideal for users who want a complete smartphone experience without spending $800 on a new flagship.

The Pixel 4 XL, however, remains a cult favorite for photography enthusiasts on a tight budget. If you primarily take photos in daylight or well-lit environments and don’t mind charging twice daily, its imaging prowess still impresses. Just be prepared for shorter longevity and weaker performance over time.

“The Pixel 4 XL proves that great software can outshine hardware for years. But eventually, battery degradation and app bloat catch up.” — Lin Chen, Senior Editor at Mobile Review Hub

Conclusion

The battle between the Pixel 4 XL and Galaxy S20 isn’t just about specs—it’s about values. Choose the Pixel if you prioritize photographic authenticity and clean Android experience. Opt for the S20 if you want reliability, versatility, and smoother long-term usability.

Neither phone is \"future-proof,\" but both offer surprising capability for their age. With careful maintenance and realistic expectations, either can serve as a functional daily driver—especially for those transitioning from basic smartphones or seeking affordable access to flagship-level features.

🚀 Ready to shop smart? Compare refurbished models, check seller ratings, and verify battery health before buying. Share your experience with older flagships in the comments below!