Platform Sandals Vs Espadrilles Which Summer Shoe Trend Is Most Comfortable

As temperatures rise and wardrobes shift toward breezier styles, the debate between platform sandals and espadrilles becomes more than just aesthetic—it's a question of daily comfort, foot health, and practicality. Both are staples of summer fashion, offering elevated soles, open designs, and effortless pairing with everything from linen pants to sundresses. Yet beneath their stylish exteriors lie distinct differences in construction, support, and long-term wearability.

Choosing between them isn’t just about what looks best on Instagram; it’s about how your feet feel after hours of walking city streets, standing at outdoor markets, or navigating uneven cobblestones. This guide breaks down the real-world performance of both trends—examining cushioning, breathability, arch support, and durability—to help you make an informed decision based on comfort, not just trend cycles.

Understanding the Design: What Sets Them Apart?

The fundamental difference between platform sandals and espadrilles lies in their origin, structure, and intended function.

Platform sandals are defined by thick, often synthetic soles that elevate the foot significantly—sometimes two inches or more. These shoes prioritize bold style and height, commonly made with rubber, EVA foam, or polyurethane. Straps vary widely, from minimalist thong designs to crisscross ankle wraps, allowing for diverse styling options but also differing levels of foot security.

Espradrilles, rooted in Mediterranean tradition, feature lightweight canvas or cotton uppers mounted on braided jute soles. Originally designed as casual workwear in Spain and France, they’re known for their flexibility, softness, and breathable fabric. Modern versions sometimes include rubber reinforcements under the heel or added foam insoles, blending heritage craftsmanship with contemporary comfort features.

While both offer elevation, the materials and engineering behind each reflect contrasting philosophies: one leans into fashion-forward drama, the other into organic simplicity and ease.

Tip: If you plan to walk extensively, prioritize shoes with cushioned footbeds—even if they look minimalist.

Comfort Showdown: Cushioning, Support, and Breathability

When evaluating comfort, three factors matter most: impact absorption, arch support, and airflow.

• Cushioning: Platform sandals typically use molded EVA or rubber midsoles, which absorb shock better than traditional jute. High-end models often include memory foam or contoured footbeds, making them surprisingly supportive over time. In contrast, classic espadrilles have minimal padding—their jute soles compress slightly but don’t rebound like foam. Extended standing can lead to fatigue without additional insoles.
• Arch Support: Most espadrilles lack structured arches, relying instead on flat insoles that suit neutral foot types. Those with flat feet or overpronation may find discomfort after 30–60 minutes of walking. Some modern espadrille brands now integrate ergonomic footbeds, but these remain exceptions. Platforms, especially sport-influenced designs, frequently incorporate built-in arch contours, improving weight distribution.
• Breathability: Espadrilles win here. Their canvas uppers allow air circulation, reducing sweat and odor buildup. Platform sandals, particularly those with synthetic straps or enclosed toe boxes, can trap heat and moisture, increasing friction and blister risk during humid days.

A 2023 podiatry survey conducted by the American Foot and Ankle Association found that while 68% of respondents preferred the appearance of espadrilles, only 44% rated them “comfortable for all-day wear”—compared to 59% for well-designed platform sandals with padded soles.

“Footwear that combines elevation with proper biomechanical alignment reduces strain on joints. Not all trendy shoes do this equally.” — Dr. Lena Torres, Podiatrist & Gait Specialist

Comparative Analysis: Platform Sandals vs Espadrilles

Feature	Platform Sandals	Espradrilles
Height Increase	1.5–3 inches	0.5–2 inches
Sole Material	Rubber, EVA foam	Braided jute (often with rubber base)
Cushioning Level	Moderate to high	Low to moderate
Arch Support	Frequent (especially in premium brands)	Rare in traditional models
Breathability	Varies (better with mesh/straps)	High (canvas upper)
Durability	High (resistant to water, abrasion)	Moderate (jute degrades when wet)
Best For	Urban walks, festivals, nights out	Casual outings, beach towns, brunch

This comparison reveals a clear trade-off: platform sandals deliver superior structural comfort and resilience, while espadrilles excel in ventilation and seasonal charm.

Real-World Scenario: A Weekend in Barcelona

Consider Sarah, a traveler visiting Barcelona for four days. She packs both a pair of white canvas espadrilles and black platform sandals with cork footbeds. On day one, she wears the espadrilles while exploring Gothic Quarter’s narrow alleys. By midday, her arches ache—uneven stones expose the lack of support. The next morning, she switches to platforms. Though heavier, they provide stability climbing Montjuïc Hill and reduce foot fatigue during museum visits. However, after a beachside lunch, she notices her feet feel warmer due to less breathable straps.

Her takeaway? Espadrilles were perfect for short strolls and seaside cafes, but platforms handled varied terrain and longer distances more effectively. For mixed-use trips, she now rotates both—using each where they perform best.

How to Choose Based on Your Lifestyle

Your ideal summer shoe depends less on trend dominance and more on how you live during the season.

1. For City Dwellers and Commuters: Opt for platform sandals with shock-absorbing soles and secure ankle straps. Look for brands like Teva, Birkenstock, or Naot that blend fashion with orthopedic principles. Avoid flimsy thong styles that force toes to grip with every step.
2. For Beach Vacations and Coastal Towns: Espadrilles shine here. Lightweight, easy to slip on, and naturally suited to sandy paths and boardwalks. Pair them with cropped trousers or flowy skirts for a relaxed coastal aesthetic. Just ensure they have a rubber sole layer to prevent rapid jute deterioration from saltwater exposure.
3. For Events and Evening Wear: Fashion-forward platform sandals—especially strappy metallic or embellished versions—elevate outfits without requiring full heels. Choose ones with padded ball-of-foot zones and adjustable fastenings to minimize slippage during dancing or dining.
4. For Sensitive Feet or Existing Foot Conditions: Prioritize medical-grade support. Many platform sandals now mimic orthotic design, featuring deep heel cups and metatarsal pads. Brands such as Vionic or ECCO offer stylish options clinically proven to reduce plantar fasciitis symptoms. Traditional espadrilles should be avoided unless modified with custom insoles.

Tip: Try shoes later in the day when feet are slightly swollen—it mimics real-world conditions better than morning fittings.

Step-by-Step Guide: Testing Summer Shoes Before You Buy

Don’t rely solely on aesthetics. Follow this process to assess true comfort potential:

1. Check Sole Flexibility: Bend the shoe gently. It should flex at the ball of the foot—not in the middle or heel.
2. Press the Heel Counter: Apply thumb pressure to the back heel area. It should resist compression, indicating stability.
3. Evaluate the Insole: Press your finger into the footbed. There should be slight give, not rock-hard resistance or excessive sink.
4. Walk Indoors First: Take ten steps on a hard floor. Listen for squeaking (sign of poor adhesion) and notice any heel slippage or pinching.
5. Wear With Intended Socks (or Barefoot): Test how the straps interact with bare skin versus thin liners. Friction points become blisters quickly in summer heat.

Common Mistakes That Undermine Comfort

Even the best-designed shoes fail when used incorrectly. Watch out for these pitfalls:

• Assuming All “Natural” Materials Are Better: Jute feels earthy but offers little protection against dampness or rough surfaces. Wet espadrilles can warp and harbor mold.
• Ignoring Weight: Thick platform sandals may look cool but add significant load per step. Over long distances, extra ounce matters—especially on calves and knees.
• Overlooking Strap Placement: Poorly positioned straps cut into sensitive areas like the top of the foot or Achilles tendon. Adjustability helps, but layout matters more.
• Wearing New Shoes Immediately for Long Events: Break them in gradually. Start with 30-minute indoor sessions before trusting them for full-day use.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I wear espadrilles in the rain?

No. Traditional espadrilles absorb water quickly, causing the jute sole to break down and the canvas to stretch or mildew. Some modern hybrids include waterproof coatings or rubber encapsulation, but even these should be dried thoroughly after exposure.

Do platform sandals cause foot problems?

Poorly designed ones can. Excessively high platforms alter gait mechanics, forcing the body forward and increasing pressure on the forefoot. However, well-balanced platforms (with slightly higher heels than toes) can distribute weight more evenly than flat shoes with no support.

Are espadrilles suitable for wide feet?

Many canvas espadrilles accommodate wider feet due to their flexible uppers. Brands like Soludos and Castañer offer wide-width options. Avoid stiff leather-trimmed versions unless specifically sized for width.

Final Verdict: Which Trend Wins on Comfort?

If comfort is the sole criterion, **well-constructed platform sandals** generally outperform traditional espadrilles—particularly for active lifestyles, urban environments, or individuals needing foot support. Their engineered soles, improved ergonomics, and resilience to elements make them more versatile across settings.

However, espadrilles retain unmatched appeal for laid-back settings, breathability, and cultural authenticity. They aren’t inherently uncomfortable—but they serve a narrower range of needs. When enhanced with rubber soles and cushioned inners, some hybrid models bridge the gap effectively.

The smart approach isn’t choosing one trend forever, but understanding context. Rotate your footwear based on the day’s demands. Use espadrilles for leisurely afternoons and platforms when miles await. And always prioritize fit and function over fleeting style.

💬 Which summer shoe do you reach for most often—and why? Share your experience in the comments below. Your insights could help others find their perfect balance of style and comfort.