Materials Used for Creating Printed Custom Boxes
Choosing the right material for printed custom boxes is essential for balancing aesthetics, durability, sustainability, and cost. Each material offers unique benefits depending on the product type, branding goals, and environmental considerations. Below is a detailed breakdown of the most commonly used materials in custom box manufacturing.
Cardstock
A versatile, medium-weight paperboard ideal for lightweight yet sturdy packaging solutions.
Advantages
- Excellent surface for high-quality printing
- Available in various textures (matte, glossy, linen)
- Lightweight and cost-effective
- Ideal for cosmetic, food, and retail packaging
Limitations
- Less durable under heavy loads
- Limited moisture resistance
- Not suitable for shipping fragile items
Best for: Gift boxes, cosmetic packaging, food containers, promotional mailers
Brown Kraft Paper
An eco-friendly, recyclable material known for its natural, rustic appearance and strong structural integrity.
Advantages
- 100% biodegradable and compostable
- High tensile strength for its weight
- Natural aesthetic appeals to eco-conscious consumers
- Custom printable with earthy, organic branding
Limitations
- Dark background limits color vibrancy
- May require lining for food safety compliance
- Less premium feel compared to white alternatives
Best for: Eco-friendly brands, bakery boxes, shipping envelopes, sustainable product lines
White Kraft Paper
A cleaner, brighter version of kraft paper that maintains environmental benefits while enhancing print quality.
Advantages
- Smooth, bright surface ideal for vibrant prints
- Retains recyclability and biodegradability
- Offers a premium look with sustainable values
- Excellent for detailed logos and full-color designs
Limitations
- Slightly more expensive than brown kraft
- May require coatings for moisture resistance
- Less rustic appeal for nature-focused branding
Best for: Luxury eco-brands, organic skincare, wedding favors, high-end retail
Corrugated Material
Composed of a fluted inner layer sandwiched between two flat linerboards, providing superior protection and rigidity.
Advantages
- Exceptional strength and shock absorption
- Ideal for shipping and long-distance transport
- Printable outer surface for branded packaging
- Available in single, double, or triple-wall configurations
Limitations
- Bulkier and heavier than paperboard options
- Surface texture may limit fine print detail
- Less suitable for small or delicate items unless padded
Best for: E-commerce shipments, electronics, glassware, industrial components
Rigid Stock
Also known as rigid board or setup paperboard, this dense material provides a luxury-grade, non-foldable structure.
Advantages
- Ultra-premium, high-end appearance and feel
- Perfect for high-resolution printing and foil stamping
- Excellent durability and stackability
- Ideal for custom logo boxes and gift packaging
Limitations
- Higher production and material costs
- Not foldable, requiring more storage space
- Heavier, increasing shipping costs
Best for: Jewelry, watches, premium cosmetics, luxury fashion, high-value gifts
| Material | Durability | Print Quality | Eco-Friendliness | Best Use Case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cardstock | Medium | Excellent | Good | Retail packaging, food boxes, promotional items |
| Brown Kraft Paper | Good | Fair to Good | Excellent | Eco-brands, bakery, sustainable packaging |
| White Kraft Paper | Good | Excellent | Excellent | Luxury eco-products, organic skincare, weddings |
| Corrugated Material | Excellent | Good | Good | Shipping, electronics, fragile item transport |
| Rigid Stock | Excellent | Superior | Fair | Luxury goods, high-end gifting, brand prestige |
Expert Tip: For optimal branding impact, pair your material choice with finishing techniques like spot UV coating, embossing, or foil stamping—especially on cardstock and rigid stock—to enhance visual appeal and tactile experience.
Customization Options for Printed Custom Boxes: Elevate Your Brand Packaging
Printed custom boxes are more than just containers—they're powerful branding tools that combine functionality with visual appeal. With a wide range of customization options, businesses can create packaging that not only protects their products but also enhances customer experience, reinforces brand identity, and stands out on shelves or in unboxing moments. Below is a comprehensive breakdown of key customization features available in modern box manufacturing.
1. Box Style Customization
Selecting the right box style is crucial for aligning packaging with both product type and brand personality. Businesses can choose from a variety of structural designs, each serving different functional and aesthetic purposes:
- Folding Cartons: Ideal for lightweight products like cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, or food items. These are easy to assemble and offer excellent printability.
- Shipping Boxes: Durable custom shipping boxes made from corrugated materials provide superior protection during transit, perfect for e-commerce and logistics.
- Pillow Boxes: Curved, elegant design often used for gifts, candles, or confectionery. Adds a premium, handcrafted feel.
- Tuck-End Boxes: Feature flaps that slide into place—commonly used for retail packaging due to their clean look and ease of access.
- Hexagon & Die-Cut Shapes: Unique geometric or branded silhouettes that increase shelf visibility and create memorable unboxing experiences.
Additionally, eco-conscious brands can opt for sustainable alternatives such as recycled cardboard, biodegradable paperboard, or plant-based materials. These environmentally responsible choices appeal to green consumers and support corporate sustainability goals.
2. Size and Dimensional Adjustments
Precision in sizing ensures optimal product fit, minimizing movement during shipping while maximizing space efficiency. Custom dimensions are especially valuable for irregularly shaped or fragile items.
Manufacturers allow businesses to input exact measurements—length, width, height, and internal cavity space—or select from pre-defined templates based on common product categories (e.g., bottles, electronics, apparel). This level of control results in:
- Improved product protection through snug, secure fit
- Reduced material waste and lower shipping costs
- Enhanced visual presentation by eliminating excess space
- Better stacking and storage capabilities in warehouses or retail displays
Advanced 3D modeling tools are often available to preview how the final box will look and function before production begins.
3. Material and Texture Choices
Material Options
- Cardboard: Lightweight and cost-effective, suitable for short-term storage and light products.
- Corrugated Board: Offers excellent strength and shock absorption, ideal for heavy or delicate goods requiring transport durability.
- Paperboard: Smooth surface perfect for high-end printing; commonly used in luxury packaging like perfume or premium chocolates.
Surface Finishes & Textures
- Matte Finish: Provides a soft, sophisticated look with reduced glare—great for minimalist or luxury branding.
- Glossy Coating: Enhances color vibrancy and adds a shiny, modern appeal that grabs attention.
- Spot UV: Adds selective shine to logos or design elements for a striking contrast.
- Embossing/Debossing: Creates tactile depth by raising or pressing down parts of the design, adding a premium sensory experience.
The combination of material and finish directly impacts perceived product value, durability, and environmental footprint.
4. Graphic and Text Integration
Custom printing transforms packaging into a dynamic marketing platform. High-resolution digital and offset printing technologies allow for:
- Full-color branding using precise Pantone or CMYK matching
- Seamless integration of logos, taglines, and brand color schemes
- Inclusion of QR codes, social media handles, or augmented reality triggers
- Custom illustrations, patterns, or storytelling graphics tailored to audience demographics
Whether promoting seasonal campaigns, limited editions, or core brand values, printed graphics ensure consistent messaging across all customer touchpoints. Modern printing also supports variable data printing for personalized packaging at scale—ideal for gifting or subscription boxes.
5. Closure and Opening Mechanism Enhancements
Functional Closures
- Interlocking Tabs: Simple, secure, and tamper-evident—common in standard retail boxes.
- Magnetic Closures: Deliver a premium, reusable opening experience, often used in gift or luxury packaging.
- Ribbon Pulls & Drawer-Style Slides: Add elegance and interactivity to unboxing.
- Water-Activated Tape or Adhesives: Provide tamper-proof sealing for secure shipping and authenticity assurance.
User Experience Impact
The way a box opens influences first impressions. A smooth, intuitive opening process enhances perceived quality, while overly complex or difficult closures may frustrate users. Thoughtful design balances security with accessibility, especially important in e-commerce where unboxing videos and social sharing are common.
6. Window Cut-Outs and Interior Add-Ons
Transparency and internal organization elevate both aesthetics and functionality:
- Die-Cut Windows: Allow partial product visibility, increasing consumer confidence—especially effective for food, apparel, or gift items.
- Clear PET or PVC Lamination: Covers window openings with food-safe, durable plastic that maintains clarity and protection.
- Custom Inserts: Foam, molded pulp, or cardboard dividers keep products securely in place and prevent damage during transit.
- Layered Trays or Compartments: Ideal for multi-item sets (e.g., skincare kits, toolboxes), enhancing presentation and usability.
These features not only improve protection but also turn packaging into an organized, visually appealing display—perfect for retail environments or direct-to-consumer deliveries.
| Customization Option | Best For | Key Benefits |
|---|---|---|
| Corrugated Shipping Boxes | E-commerce, Heavy Products | Durability, Protection, Cost-Efficiency |
| Matte + Embossed Finish | Luxury, Premium Brands | Elegant Look, Tactile Appeal |
| Die-Cut Windows | Retail, Food, Gifts | Product Visibility, Consumer Trust |
| Magnetic Closure Boxes | Gifting, High-End Products | Reusable, Premium Unboxing |
| Custom Inserts | Kits, Fragile Items | Organization, Damage Prevention |
Pro Tip: Always request physical samples before mass production. This allows you to test structural integrity, print quality, and overall user experience. Additionally, consider the full lifecycle of your packaging—design for recyclability, reuse, or compostability to meet growing consumer and regulatory expectations.
Applications of Printed Custom Boxes
Printed custom boxes have evolved far beyond simple containers—they are now strategic tools that enhance brand identity, improve customer experience, and support operational efficiency across industries. From luxury unboxing moments to practical logistics solutions, custom packaging serves diverse functions tailored to specific business needs.
Product Packaging
One of the most essential applications of printed custom boxes is in product packaging for commercial brands. These boxes not only protect items during handling and transit but also act as silent salespeople on shelves and in customers' homes.
- Luxury cosmetic boxes with embossed logos and matte finishes communicate premium quality and elegance
- Custom shapes, window cutouts, and vibrant graphics allow products to stand out in competitive retail environments
- Branded color schemes and consistent typography reinforce brand recognition with every interaction
- Eco-friendly inks and recyclable materials appeal to environmentally conscious consumers
Key benefit: High-impact design increases perceived product value and encourages repeat purchases
Subscription Box Packaging
For subscription-based services, printed custom boxes are central to creating a memorable and engaging customer experience. The unboxing moment has become a critical touchpoint that drives social sharing and brand loyalty.
- Themed designs for beauty, food, fitness, or pet care subscriptions build excitement and anticipation
- Seasonal artwork (e.g., holiday motifs or summer vibes) keeps content fresh and relevant
- Personalized messages or recipient names enhance emotional connection
- Durable construction ensures safe delivery of multiple items over recurring shipments
Pro tip: Include QR codes or augmented reality elements to extend engagement beyond the box
Gift Packaging
Custom-printed boxes elevate gifting by transforming ordinary presents into premium experiences. Whether for corporate gifts, holiday sets, or special occasions, these boxes serve as both container and statement.
- Die-cut windows showcase contents like perfumes, watches, or gourmet treats without opening
- Custom ribbons, magnetic closures, and foil stamping add luxury appeal
- Tailored sizes fit unique items perfectly, minimizing movement and damage
- Designs can reflect occasions—romantic themes for Valentine’s Day, festive patterns for Christmas
Creative idea: Use storytelling through packaging—sequential illustrations or hidden messages enhance surprise
Retail Display Boxes
In physical and online retail, custom printed boxes double as point-of-sale display units that attract attention and communicate brand messaging effectively.
- Counter-top displays for snacks or cosmetics draw shopper focus in high-traffic areas
- Bold colors and flavor-specific graphics help differentiate product variants at a glance
- Integrated handles or stackable designs improve functionality in-store
- Call-to-action messaging ("Try All Flavors!" or "Limited Edition") boosts impulse buying
Sales insight: Eye-level display packaging can increase conversion rates by up to 30%
Shipping and Storage Solutions
Beyond aesthetics, custom boxes play a vital role in logistics, offering secure shipping and efficient storage options tailored to specific products and operations.
- Precision-fit inner compartments prevent shifting during transit, reducing product damage
- Branded shipping boxes reinforce professionalism and trust upon delivery
- Color-coded or labeled boxes streamline warehouse organization and inventory tracking
- Double-walled corrugated materials provide extra protection for fragile or high-value goods
Operational advantage: Custom-sized boxes reduce filler material usage and lower shipping costs
Marketing & Brand Extension
While not always listed separately, custom boxes serve as powerful marketing tools that extend brand presence beyond the point of sale.
- Memorable packaging encourages social media sharing and user-generated content
- Reusable boxes become part of the customer’s lifestyle (e.g., jewelry boxes repurposed for storage)
- Consistent branding across all packaging types builds long-term recognition
- Inclusion of hashtags, website URLs, or referral codes turns packaging into a digital gateway
Growth strategy: Treat every shipped box as a mobile advertisement reaching new audiences
Expert Insight: When designing custom boxes, balance creativity with practicality. A stunning design loses impact if the box is difficult to open, too bulky to ship, or incompatible with automated fulfillment systems. Always test prototypes for durability, ease of assembly, and visual appeal under real-world conditions.
| Application | Design Focus | Material Recommendations | Key Performance Goal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Product Packaging | Brand identity, visual appeal | Kraft board, rigid cardboard, soft-touch lamination | Enhance shelf presence and perceived value |
| Subscription Boxes | Theming, surprise factor | Corrugated cardboard with high-gloss print | Create shareable unboxing experiences |
| Gift Packaging | Luxury finish, personalization | Rigid gift boxes with magnetic closures | Elevate emotional impact of gifting |
| Retail Display | Visibility, information clarity | Folding cartons with UV coating | Drive impulse purchases in-store |
| Shipping & Storage | Durability, efficiency | Double-wall corrugated, water-resistant coatings | Protect products and optimize logistics |
Additional Considerations for Optimal Impact
- Sustainability: Use FSC-certified paper and soy-based inks to align with eco-conscious consumer values
- Print Quality: High-resolution CMYK or Pantone matching ensures brand colors remain consistent
- Functionality: Consider ease of opening, resealability, and structural integrity for user satisfaction
- Scalability: Design packaging that works across product lines for cohesive brand storytelling
- Compliance: Include necessary legal labels, recycling symbols, and safety warnings where applicable
Factors to Consider When Selecting a Printed Custom Box
Choosing the right printed custom box is more than just aesthetics—it's a strategic decision that impacts product protection, brand perception, customer experience, and sustainability. A well-designed packaging solution not only safeguards your product during transit but also serves as a powerful marketing tool at the point of sale and unboxing. This guide outlines the key considerations to help businesses make informed decisions when selecting custom packaging that aligns with their functional needs and brand identity.
Important Note: Poorly chosen packaging can lead to damaged goods, increased shipping costs, and negative customer impressions. Always balance cost with quality and functionality to ensure long-term brand success.
Key Factors in Custom Box Selection
- Purpose and Product Nature
The primary function of your packaging should align with the characteristics of your product. Fragile or high-value items—such as glassware, electronics, or cosmetics—require robust protection and may benefit from corrugated or rigid boxes with internal cushioning. For lighter products like apparel, accessories, or footwear, custom shoe boxes or folding cartons offer an elegant presentation while maintaining structural integrity.
In addition to protection, packaging should reflect your brand’s style and enhance the unboxing experience. Luxury brands often use rigid boxes with matte finishes and foil stamping, while eco-conscious companies may opt for minimalist designs on recycled materials. Always consider how the box will be handled—from warehouse storage to final delivery—and design accordingly.
- Material Quality
The choice of material directly affects durability, print quality, and overall perception of your product. Common options include:
- Paperboard: Lightweight and cost-effective; ideal for retail-ready packaging with high-quality printing.
- Kraft Paper: Natural, earthy look; excellent for eco-friendly branding and easily recyclable.
- Rigid Stock: Thick, durable board used for premium packaging; offers superior protection and a luxurious feel.
- Corrugated Cardboard: Multi-layered for strength; perfect for shipping boxes and heavy products.
High-quality materials not only protect your product but also provide a smooth surface for vibrant, sharp printing. They resist dents and scuffing, ensuring your brand image remains intact throughout the supply chain.
- Box Style and Size
Custom box styles play a crucial role in both functionality and visual appeal. Popular options include:
- Tuck End Boxes: Easy to assemble and close; commonly used for food, cosmetics, and consumer goods.
- Reverse Tuck End Boxes: Provide a cleaner front panel; ideal for premium products.
- Sleeve Boxes: Feature a sliding outer sleeve; offer a dramatic reveal and enhanced presentation.
- Window Cut Boxes: Include transparent panels to showcase the product inside, boosting consumer confidence.
Choosing the correct size is equally important. A box that’s too large increases shipping costs and risk of product movement, while one that’s too small may damage contents or appear unprofessional. Ensure there’s enough space for protective inserts and branding elements without excess void fill.
- Printing Technology
The printing method you choose impacts color accuracy, detail, and production efficiency. The most common techniques include:
- Digital Printing: Best for short runs and full-color designs; allows for variable data and quick turnaround.
- Offset Printing: Offers superior color consistency and sharpness; ideal for large orders with complex graphics.
- Flexography: Cost-effective for simple designs and large quantities; commonly used for corrugated boxes.
For high-impact branding, consider additional finishing options such as spot UV coating, embossing, debossing, or foil stamping. These enhancements elevate the tactile and visual experience, making your packaging stand out on shelves and in social media shares.
- Cost Implications
While custom packaging involves upfront investment, it can deliver significant long-term returns through improved brand recognition, reduced damage rates, and increased customer loyalty. Key cost factors include material type, box size, printing complexity, and order quantity.
Bulk ordering typically reduces per-unit costs, making it a smart choice for established brands. However, startups may benefit from smaller digital print runs to test designs and gather feedback. Don’t forget to factor in shipping weight and dimensional pricing—lighter, compact boxes reduce freight expenses and environmental impact.
Ultimately, view packaging as a value driver, not just a cost. A beautifully designed box can increase perceived product value and encourage repeat purchases.
- Eco-friendliness
Sustainability is no longer optional—consumers increasingly expect brands to prioritize environmental responsibility. Opt for recyclable, biodegradable, or compostable materials such as FSC-certified paperboard or recycled Kraft. Use water-based, non-toxic inks and avoid plastic laminates that hinder recycling.
Highlight your eco-commitment on the packaging itself with certifications like “Recyclable,” “Made from 100% Recycled Materials,” or “Plastic-Free.” Even a simple brown box, when branded thoughtfully with a clean logo and sustainable message, can communicate authenticity and environmental awareness.
Additionally, minimizing excess packaging reduces waste and shipping costs, contributing to a leaner, greener supply chain.
| Selection Factor | Best For | Common Mistakes | Pro Tips |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose & Product Type | Fragile, luxury, or lightweight goods | Using flimsy boxes for heavy items | Match box strength to product weight and fragility |
| Material Quality | Branding, durability, print finish | Choosing cheap materials that smudge or tear | Test print samples before full production |
| Box Style & Size | Retail display, gifting, shipping | Incorrect sizing leading to wasted space | Use mock-ups to verify fit and appearance |
| Printing Technology | Color accuracy, design complexity | Low-resolution images or poor color matching | Select printing method based on run size and design needs |
| Cost & Budget | Balancing quality and affordability | Overlooking shipping and storage costs | Calculate total cost of ownership, not just unit price |
| Eco-friendliness | Sustainable brands and conscious consumers | Greenwashing without real eco-benefits | Use certified materials and transparent messaging |
Expert Tip: Always request physical samples before placing a large order. This allows you to evaluate material thickness, print quality, structural integrity, and overall look and feel—ensuring the final product meets your brand standards.
Final Recommendations
- Align your packaging design with your brand identity—colors, fonts, and finishes should be consistent across all touchpoints.
- Consider the entire customer journey: from warehouse to doorstep to unboxing.
- Invest in professional design services to create a cohesive and compelling package layout.
- Partner with a reputable packaging supplier who offers customization, quality control, and sustainable options.
- Regularly review and update your packaging based on customer feedback and market trends.
Selecting the perfect printed custom box is a blend of art and strategy. By carefully evaluating product needs, material choices, design elements, and environmental impact, businesses can create packaging that protects, impresses, and promotes their brand with every delivery.
Frequently Asked Questions About Custom Printed Boxes
The cost of printed custom boxes varies based on several key factors, including material selection, box size, design complexity, printing technique, and order quantity. While custom packaging typically costs more than generic, off-the-shelf boxes, it offers significant added value that justifies the investment:
- Brand Presentation: Custom boxes act as a powerful extension of your brand identity, creating a professional and memorable unboxing experience.
- Customer Experience: Thoughtfully designed packaging enhances perceived product value and increases customer satisfaction and loyalty.
- Marketing Tool: Every box becomes a mobile advertisement—when shared on social media or delivered to a doorstep, it promotes your brand organically.
- Volume Discounts: Larger orders often reduce the per-unit cost, making custom packaging more affordable for growing businesses.
Ultimately, while the upfront cost may be higher, the long-term benefits in brand equity and customer engagement make custom boxes a smart investment for businesses aiming to stand out.
The typical production and delivery lead time for custom printed boxes ranges from 10 to 15 business days, though this can vary depending on several factors:
- Design Complexity: Intricate artwork, special finishes (like embossing or spot UV), or multi-color printing may extend production time.
- Order Quantity: Larger volumes may require additional manufacturing time but often result in lower per-unit costs.
- Shipping Method: Standard shipping, express delivery, or international logistics will affect total turnaround time.
- Proof Approval: Delays in approving digital proofs or making design revisions can impact the schedule.
To ensure timely delivery—especially for product launches, seasonal campaigns, or promotional events—it's recommended to place your order at least 3–4 weeks in advance. This buffer allows time for design finalization, production, and unforeseen delays.
Yes, absolutely. One of the greatest advantages of custom packaging is the ability to incorporate a wide range of functional and aesthetic enhancements. These features not only improve usability but also elevate the overall brand experience:
- Window Cut-Outs: Transparent PVC or acetate inserts allow customers to view the product without opening the box, ideal for retail or gift packaging.
- Custom Inserts: Foam, molded pulp, or cardboard dividers securely hold products in place, offering protection during shipping and a premium presentation.
- Foil Stamping: Metallic gold, silver, or colored foils add a luxurious, eye-catching finish to logos or design elements.
- Spot UV Coating: A glossy, raised coating applied to specific areas creates contrast and texture, highlighting key branding features.
- Embossing/Debossing: Adds a tactile dimension by raising or recessing parts of the design for a sophisticated feel.
- Eco-Friendly Add-Ons: Soy-based inks, biodegradable adhesives, and recyclable window materials support sustainable branding efforts.
These customizable options allow businesses to create packaging that is not only protective and practical but also uniquely aligned with their brand’s personality and values.
Custom boxes are crafted from a variety of high-quality materials, each selected based on durability, appearance, sustainability, and intended use. Common materials include:
| Material | Characteristics | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Card Stock | Smooth, printable surface; lightweight yet sturdy; ideal for folding boxes. | Beauty products, cosmetics, small electronics, and retail packaging. |
| Brown Kraft Paper | Eco-friendly, rustic look; biodegradable and recyclable; naturally strong. | Eco-conscious brands, food packaging, and minimalist designs. |
| White Kraft Paper | Clean, bright base for vibrant printing; sustainable and durable. | Brands seeking a modern, eco-friendly aesthetic with full-color branding. |
| Rigid Stock | High-end, thick board with luxury feel; excellent structural integrity. | Premium products like jewelry, watches, and gift sets. |
| Corrugated Material | Layered with fluted interior for shock absorption; highly protective. | Shipping boxes, heavy items, and subscription boxes. |
| Flexible Paper | Lightweight and foldable; often used for wraps or sleeves. | Secondary packaging, gift wraps, or decorative overlays. |
All materials are chosen to balance strength for product protection with visual appeal, ensuring your items arrive safely while making a strong brand impression.
Branding is critically important in custom box design—it’s not just about aesthetics, but about creating a cohesive and impactful brand experience. Effective branding on packaging serves several key business objectives:
- Brand Recognition: Consistent use of logos, colors, typography, and imagery helps customers instantly identify your products on shelves or in their mailboxes.
- Emotional Connection: Thoughtful design elements—such as personalized messages, brand storytelling, or unique textures—can foster a deeper emotional bond with your audience.
- Differentiation: In a crowded market, strong branding sets your product apart from competitors and communicates your unique value proposition.
- Trust & Professionalism: High-quality, branded packaging signals credibility and attention to detail, increasing consumer confidence in your product.
- Customer Loyalty: A memorable unboxing experience encourages repeat purchases and word-of-mouth promotion, especially when shared on social media.
When designing custom boxes, treat them as an extension of your brand identity. Every detail—from color psychology to material choice—should align with your brand’s mission, values, and target audience to maximize impact and long-term success.








浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?