In 2024, flagship smartphones boast AI-powered processors, 200MP cameras, and 5G connectivity. Yet a growing community of tech enthusiasts is turning to older models—not for nostalgia, but for practicality. Two devices frequently mentioned in retro Android discussions are the Samsung Galaxy S8 and the HTC U11. Released just a year apart (2017 and 2017 respectively), both were groundbreaking in their time. But nearly seven years later, which one holds up better as an affordable, functional daily driver? This isn’t about chasing specs—it’s about smart, sustainable choices in a world of planned obsolescence.
Design and Build: A Clash of Philosophies
The Galaxy S8 introduced Samsung’s “Infinity Display”—a near-bezel-less 5.8-inch Quad HD+ Super AMOLED screen that felt like holding a slab of future. Its glass-and-metal body curved elegantly at the edges, offering a premium feel despite being fingerprint-prone. The lack of a physical home button and the shift to facial recognition and iris scanning marked a turning point in smartphone design.
The HTC U11 took a different approach. It featured a stunning liquid-surface glass back that shimmered under light, paired with a more conventional front layout. What set it apart was Edge Sense—pressure-sensitive sides that let users squeeze the phone to launch apps or take photos. While gimmicky to some, it offered genuine utility when customized. Both phones support IP68 water resistance, rare for their era, making them resilient to spills and rain.
Performance and Software: The Real Bottleneck
Under the hood, both phones launched with the Qualcomm Snapdragon 835—a powerhouse in 2017, still capable today for basic tasks. However, the difference lies in software longevity. Samsung committed to four major Android updates for the S8 (up to Android 9 Pie), while HTC ended U11 support at Android 10. Neither receives security patches anymore, posing risks for banking or sensitive data use.
In real-world usage, neither device handles modern multitasking gracefully. Apps like Instagram or Chrome may stutter or reload constantly due to limited RAM management. The S8 has 4GB RAM; the U11 has 6GB, giving it a slight edge in app retention. Still, both struggle with background processes common in 2024.
“Legacy devices can serve well if you accept their limits—but never treat them as primary phones for digital banking or messaging.” — Marcus Lin, Mobile Security Analyst at TechShield Labs
Camera Comparison: Nostalgia vs. Innovation
The S8 features a single 12MP rear sensor with Dual Pixel autofocus and f/1.7 aperture. In daylight, it captures rich, accurate colors with excellent dynamic range. Low-light performance is decent but lacks the computational photography magic of modern phones. The front-facing 8MP camera supports iris scanning and delivers solid selfies in good lighting.
The U11 counters with a 12MP UltraPixel 3 sensor, also at f/1.7, but enhanced by HTC’s USonic technology for improved noise reduction. Its standout feature was top-tier audio recording—dual mics with voice isolation made it ideal for vloggers before vlogging was mainstream. DxOMark once ranked the U11 among the best camera phones, edging past the S8 in video stabilization and audio clarity.
| Feature | Samsung Galaxy S8 | HTC U11 |
|---|---|---|
| Rear Camera | 12MP, f/1.7, OIS | 12MP, f/1.7, OIS, USonic |
| Front Camera | 8MP, f/1.7 | 16MP, f/2.0 |
| Video Recording | 4K@30fps | 4K@30fps, HDR Boost |
| Audio Recording | Standard stereo | Dual forward-facing mics, Hi-Res Audio |
| Special Features | Iris scanner, Bixby Vision | Edge Sense, USonic Voice Match |
Battery Life and Charging: Diminishing Returns
The S8 packs a 3000mAh battery; the U11 has a slightly larger 3000mAh unit. Both support fast charging and wireless charging, a rarity in mid-tier phones even today. However, after six years, original batteries have typically degraded to 60–70% capacity. Replacements exist but require technical skill to install safely.
In practice, expect 4–6 hours of screen-on time with light use: reading articles, texting, occasional navigation. Heavy usage—streaming or GPS—drains either phone in under four hours. Neither supports modern USB-PD fast charging standards, so charging speeds feel sluggish by current benchmarks.
Real-World Use Case: The Minimalist Commuter
Meet Alex, a freelance writer who wanted a distraction-free phone for commuting. He bought a refurbished S8 for $40, replaced the battery, and installed /e/OS—a privacy-focused Android fork. He uses it solely for calls, SMS, offline notes, and audiobooks. No social media, no email syncing. For everything else, he uses a tablet at home.
After three months, Alex reports high satisfaction. The compact size fits in pockets, the screen remains vibrant, and the lack of app bloat keeps it snappy. He charges it every other day. His total investment: $60. Compare that to a new iPhone SE ($429) or Google Pixel 7a ($499), and the retro choice becomes compelling—for the right user.
Which Should You Buy? A Practical Checklist
Choosing between the S8 and U11 depends on your priorities. Use this checklist to decide:
- Do you value camera versatility? → Choose the U11 for better low-light audio and video capture.
- Do you prefer clean software and ecosystem integration? → The S8 works better with Samsung wearables and DeX mode (if using a monitor).
- Are you technically inclined? → The U11’s higher RAM helps, but both need battery swaps and custom ROMs for optimal use.
- Will this be your only phone? → Neither is recommended for full-time use due to security risks.
- Do you want a pocket-friendly size? → The S8 is narrower and lighter—ideal for one-handed use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use the Galaxy S8 or HTC U11 with modern SIM cards and networks?
Yes, both support LTE bands widely used in North America and Europe. However, they lack 5G and newer VoLTE optimizations. Some carriers may phase out compatibility soon, especially on T-Mobile’s evolving network.
Is it safe to install custom ROMs like LineageOS?
Generally yes, but proceed with caution. Custom ROMs can restore modern Android versions (up to Android 13 in some cases), but they void warranties and carry risks if flashed incorrectly. Always back up data and follow developer instructions precisely.
Why consider these phones in 2024 at all?
For specific roles—secondary phones, travel devices, minimalist tools, or retro collectors—these phones offer quality materials and design at near-disposable prices. They’re also easier to repair than sealed modern flagships.
Final Verdict: Purpose Over Performance
The Samsung Galaxy S8 and HTC U11 are not “better” than budget phones in 2024—they’re different. They won’t run TikTok smoothly or process AI photos, but they offer something rare: thoughtful design, repairability, and a break from digital overload.
If you seek a compact, reliable secondary device and enjoy tinkering, the S8 wins for its display and ecosystem support. If you prioritize audio, camera flexibility, and a unique interaction model, the U11 stands out—despite its steeper learning curve.
Neither phone is future-proof, but both are testament to a time when innovation wasn’t just about bigger numbers. With a new battery and realistic expectations, either can serve well—as long as you understand their role: not as replacements, but as purpose-built tools in a smarter digital life.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?