As we move further into 2025, the era of next-gen consoles like the PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S is well established. Yet millions of players still rely on last-generation hardware—particularly the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One S—for everyday gaming, streaming, and entertainment. These consoles were once flagships, but now they serve as budget-friendly entry points or secondary systems. The question isn’t just about nostalgia; it’s practical. Which of these two legacy machines offers better value, longevity, and usability today?
This isn't a contest of raw power from their prime years. Instead, it's an evaluation grounded in real-world performance in 2025: software support, game availability, streaming capabilities, user interface responsiveness, backward compatibility, and overall reliability. For parents, casual gamers, or anyone building a low-cost entertainment center, choosing between the PS4 and Xbox One S matters more than ever.
Performance and Hardware Longevity in 2025
Both consoles launched around the same time—2013 for the original PS4 and 2016 for the Xbox One S—and while neither matches current-gen specs, their underlying architectures have aged differently under sustained use.
The PS4 (especially the Slim model) uses an AMD Jaguar 8-core CPU and Radeon-based GPU with 8GB of unified GDDR5 memory. This setup gave it a slight edge in graphical fidelity during its generation, particularly in third-party titles optimized for its architecture. By 2025, this hardware struggles with newer indie games that push resolution or texture density, but most PS4-era titles run smoothly.
The Xbox One S, meanwhile, features similar CPU specs but uses slower DDR3 memory paired with eSRAM for bandwidth management. Its GPU is slightly weaker on paper, but Microsoft’s system-level optimizations often deliver stable frame rates. More importantly, the One S includes built-in 4K upscaling for Blu-ray and select games—a feature the base PS4 lacks entirely.
In daily use, both systems show signs of age. Boot times are slow compared to modern SSD-driven consoles. The PS4 interface remains functional but feels clunky, especially when navigating large libraries. The Xbox dashboard has seen iterative updates and remains snappier, thanks to Universal Windows Platform integration and better memory allocation.
Game Library and Backward Compatibility
When evaluating long-term viability, game access is paramount. Both platforms offer extensive back catalogs, but their approaches differ significantly.
Sony maintained tight control over its ecosystem. While the PS4 boasts an exceptional first-party lineup—God of War, The Last of Us Part II, Horizon Zero Dawn—backward compatibility with PS3 or earlier titles is nonexistent without PS Plus Premium cloud streaming. Even then, availability is spotty and internet-dependent. However, nearly all native PS4 games remain purchasable through the PlayStation Store, though some delistings due to licensing (e.g., music rights) have occurred.
Microsoft took a different path. The Xbox One S supports backward compatibility with over 600 Xbox 360 and original Xbox titles—many enhanced with higher resolutions and faster load times. This means classics like BioShock, Mass Effect, and Fallout 3 run better on the One S than they did originally. Combined with Game Pass (which still supports One S devices), users gain access to hundreds of games for a flat monthly fee.
“We designed backward compatibility not just as a feature, but as a commitment to player ownership.” — Phil Spencer, Head of Xbox, 2021 interview with The Verge
For gamers who value variety and catalog depth beyond the PS4’s acclaimed exclusives, the Xbox One S provides broader long-term playability, especially for families or retro enthusiasts.
Media and Streaming Capabilities
Many legacy console owners today use their systems primarily for streaming video. In this role, both consoles function adequately—but again, differences emerge.
| Feature | PS4 | Xbox One S |
|---|---|---|
| 4K Blu-ray Playback | No | Yes |
| Upscaling HD to 4K | Limited (via HDMI) | Yes, built-in |
| HDR Support | PS4 Pro only | Yes (on supported models) |
| Streaming Apps (Netflix, Disney+, YouTube) | All available, but sluggish | All available, smoother navigation |
| Bluetooth Audio Support | No native support | Yes (with firmware update) |
The Xbox One S clearly wins in media functionality. Its ability to play physical 4K UHD discs makes it a standalone upgrade from older DVD/Blu-ray players. For households without a dedicated media device, this eliminates the need for an additional box. The PS4 requires either digital rentals (often at lower quality) or reliance on another device altogether.
Streaming app performance has degraded slightly on both platforms since developers prioritize newer OS environments. However, the Xbox’s dashboard handles multitasking better—allowing quick switching between apps without full reloads.
User Experience and Ecosystem Integration
Navigating each console in 2025 reveals how well they’ve been maintained by their parent companies.
The PS4’s interface, while familiar, suffers from inconsistent design language and slow loading in submenus. The lack of folders or library sorting options becomes frustrating with large game collections. Social features are limited; cross-play support arrived late and inconsistently across titles. Remote Play works but requires technical know-how and a strong network.
The Xbox One S benefits from deeper integration with Windows 10/11 and Microsoft’s cloud infrastructure. Features like Smart Delivery don’t apply to new purchases, but existing backward-compatible titles automatically use the best available version. Achievements sync seamlessly across devices, and cloud saves ensure progress carries forward even if the console fails.
Moreover, the One S supports Bluetooth headphones and keyboards out of the box after updates, improving accessibility. Voice commands via Cortana were discontinued, but text input and dictation remain functional through the Microsoft account ecosystem.
Real-World Example: The Thompson Family Setup
The Thompsons, a family of four in Austin, Texas, purchased a PS4 in 2017 and an Xbox One S in 2019—one for the kids’ room, one for the living room. By 2024, they considered upgrading but opted to keep both due to cost constraints.
They found the Xbox One S became their primary media hub. With no 4K player otherwise, they appreciated being able to play 4K Blu-rays borrowed from the local library. Their teenage son used Game Pass to explore classic RPGs like Oblivion and Fallout: New Vegas, while the younger daughter played Minecraft and Roblox without issue.
The PS4 remained in the kids’ room, running lighter games and Netflix. However, they encountered frequent crashes when switching between apps, and the lack of Bluetooth meant buying proprietary headsets. When the disc drive failed in early 2025, they transitioned fully to digital, but download speeds on their rural connection made re-installing games impractical.
In hindsight, consolidating around the Xbox One S would have saved space and improved reliability. “We didn’t realize how much we’d depend on the Blu-ray player,” said Mark Thompson. “It’s become our go-to for movie nights.”
Step-by-Step Guide: Maximizing Your Legacy Console in 2025
If you’re holding onto a PS4 or Xbox One S, follow these steps to get the most out of it:
- Update Firmware: Ensure your system is on the latest OS version for security patches and stability improvements.
- Clear Cache and Rebuild Database (PS4): On the PS4, boot in safe mode and choose \"Rebuild Database\" to improve load times.
- Use External Storage: Attach a USB 3.0 external HDD (1TB+) to store games and reduce strain on internal drives.
- Optimize Internet Settings: Use wired Ethernet over Wi-Fi whenever possible to minimize lag during downloads and streaming.
- Enable Cloud Saves: Activate auto-syncing on both platforms to protect your progress.
- Limit Background Apps: Close unused applications to free up RAM and improve responsiveness.
- Monitor Temperatures: Place the console in a well-ventilated area; avoid enclosed shelves.
Which Console Holds Up Better? A Final Comparison
Ultimately, the choice depends on priorities:
- If you want **cinematic experiences**, own physical media, or seek maximum backward compatibility, the Xbox One S is the superior option in 2025.
- If you value **exclusive single-player narratives** (Uncharted, Ghost of Tsushima) and already own a PS4 library, sticking with the PS4 makes sense—provided you accept its limitations.
Neither console receives major new game releases anymore. Developers have shifted focus entirely to PS5 and Xbox Series S|X. However, Sony continues patching online services and security for PS4, with official support expected until at least 2026. Microsoft has stated it will maintain Xbox Live functionality for supported consoles “for the foreseeable future,” though no hard end date exists.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I still buy new games for PS4 or Xbox One S in 2025?
Yes, but selection is limited. Most major publishers no longer release native versions for these consoles. However, many indie titles and cross-gen ports are still available digitally. Retail boxed copies may be scarce.
Is Game Pass still worth it on Xbox One S?
Absolutely. Over 300 titles—including backward-compatible classics and select EA Play games—are accessible via subscription. It remains one of the best values in gaming, especially for families or those exploring older genres.
Will my save data transfer if I upgrade later?
Yes, both ecosystems support cloud sync. PS4 saves can be restored on PS5 via PS Plus. Xbox saves transfer automatically to newer consoles if linked to the same Microsoft account.
Conclusion: Make the Smart Choice for Your Needs
The PS4 and Xbox One S were titans of their generation, but time has reshaped their roles. In 2025, the Xbox One S emerges as the more versatile and future-resilient option—thanks to 4K disc playback, robust backward compatibility, and seamless integration with Microsoft’s ecosystem. The PS4 holds sentimental and narrative appeal, but its technical constraints grow harder to overlook.
Whether you're maintaining an old system or buying secondhand, consider what you truly need: high-quality media playback, broad game access, or beloved exclusives. Both consoles can still deliver joy, but only one offers a genuinely sustainable experience moving forward.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4
Comments
No comments yet. Why don't you start the discussion?